• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

[VGT] Resident Evil Village DEMO: PS5 vs Xbox Series X|S Frame Rate Comparison

Lol, this is becoming hilarious. This is Capcom engine, it comes at no surprise to me that the x have better performance with rt, actually, if you look at the relative performance from dmc to re. It is the ps5 that improve the most on rt mode. I have said there is no pattern. Engines will dictate which game run better on the platforms. As seen recently, crash 4 and Tony hawk favor the ps5. Outsiders favor the series x.

Dunno from where you quoted his post, can't find it anymore. Anyway, said this around 2 months ago

It's basically almost every win for PS5 because Phil Spencer "most powerful console" narrative crap. Fps difference between all in this game is what....0.7% difference. As long PS5 with almost 2 TF deficit shows graphical settings and performance on par with XSX, it's basically a win for PS5. In vast majority of games XSX didn't showed almost 2TF difference in games ( that includes fps advantage, graphicall and resolution advantage - all in 1.
 

Bumblebeetuna

Gold Member
I can’t take any comparisons of this game seriously after those documents leaked talking about technical parity.

What are all of these 1080p/50fps comments though? Some inside joke I am missing? Doesn’t the PS5 run the same as XSX just with a tiny frame rate difference?
 

Umbasaborne

Banned
course diss GIF
Too true, what cry babies.
 

assurdum

Banned
Are you sure ? You do seem to take it personally and act like you're personally ofended because microsoft placed more performant hardware in their console and sony didnt. Laying out specs bothers you ? Its the hard truth. Hard numbers. No need to be offended that sony has a weaker console. Its just a corporation after all
Wait a second. It's me offended and attached on a brand because I said the difference are virtually imperceivable but you, who continues to repeat the Xbox are always higher specs blablabla superiority here and there, you are supposed to be the less attached and more objective one there? Lol.
 
Last edited:

elliot5

Member
I can’t take any comparisons of this game seriously after those documents leaked talking about technical parity.

What are all of these 1080p/50fps comments though? Some inside joke I am missing? Doesn’t the PS5 run the same as XSX just with a tiny frame rate difference?
Technical parity just means you can't slap RT or HDR on Xbox/other platform without including it in a capable PlayStation, barring technical limitations like last gen consoles not being able to run RT. Doesn't mean one needs to be handicapped... it was nonsense from the start.
 
Last edited:
Wait a second. It's me offended because I said the difference are virtually imperceivable or a person who continue to repeat the specs are higher as you?


You just seem to take this really hard for some reason. As if you bought shares in the wrong company. Its ok. Stating facts like how series x is stronger should not botter anyone, since its just stating the truth
 

Stuart360

Member
Lol, this is becoming hilarious. This is Capcom engine, it comes at no surprise to me that the x have better performance with rt, actually, if you look at the relative performance from dmc to re. It is the ps5 that improve the most on rt mode. I have said there is no pattern. Engines will dictate which game run better on the platforms. As seen recently, crash 4 and Tony hawk favor the ps5. Outsiders favor the series x.
I was joking. I had white text but the mods deleted the post. Sorry mods, was just having a laugh..

At the end of the day, the diffrerences are going to be minimal the whole gen. PS5 will be the lead platform for most devs this gen due to the success of PS4. So devs will concentrate on getting PS5 versions to where they want to be, then other versions will follow.

And i hope it stays like this for the rest of the gen as these comparisons are getting a little tiresome. If there were huge differences between versions then sure go for it, but for these tiny differences most people wouldnt even notice, yeah getting tiresome.
 

xion4360

Member
I was joking. I had white text but the mods deleted the post. Sorry mods, was just having a laugh..

At the end of the day, the diffrerences are going to be minimal the whole gen. PS5 will be the lead platform for most devs this gen due to the success of PS4. So devs will concentrate on getting PS5 versions to where they want to be, then other versions will follow.

And i hope it stays like this for the rest of the gen as these comparisons are getting a little tiresome. If there were huge differences between versions then sure go for it, but for these tiny differences most people wouldnt even notice, yeah getting tiresome.

that lead platform thing was a biproduct of ps3 and 360 having such different hardware..thats not a thing anymore...all cross platform games are developed on PC and then optimized to each platform
 

assurdum

Banned
You just seem to take this really hard for some reason. As if you bought shares in the wrong company. Its ok. Stating facts like how series x is stronger should not botter anyone, since its just stating the truth
I ever said the Xbox is the weaker one or not the more powerful? I just stating multiplat game are virtually identical for the most. It's another fact. Can you live stating that truth? Or we want to continue to reply about the superior hardware specs (as if anyone has ever argued otherwise)?
 
Last edited:

Stuart360

Member
that lead platform thing was a biproduct of ps3 and 360 having such different hardware..thats not a thing anymore...all cross platform games are developed on PC and then optimized to each platform
ALL games are developed on PC's, then ported to the devkits to tidy up. I was talking more about targeting PS5 specs when developing, so that version will be good, then cleaning up other versions after.
Fact is there are not going to be huge differences this gen with any game, outside of maybe the odd game having a noticeable higher resolution on XSX, but its not like PS5 will ever have a game with low resolution anyway.
 
Last edited:

xion4360

Member
ALL games are developed on PC's, then ported to the devkits to tidy up. I was talking more about targeting PS5 specs when developing, so that version will be good, then cleaning up other versions after.
Fact is there are not going to be huge differences this gen with any game, outside of maybe the odd game having a noticeable higher resolution on XSX, but its not like PS5 will ever have a game with low resolution anyway.
you wouldnt expect big differences with such similar specs, but Gaf will blow up over the dumbest thing regardless. :messenger_tears_of_joy:
 

BigLee74

Member
Anyway, my point regarding the stats (I have one, unlike half the folk in here), is that the XSS RT version needs sorted. It’s an unacceptably wild range that benefits nobody. Res needs lowered, or frame rate capped.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Topher

Gold Member
dj khaled sip GIF by Apple Music


Sony fanboys downplay the 1-5 fps xsx advantage? But If it was the other way around they'd make sure even their neighbor knows about it.


Hmmmm, from the Crash 4 comparison....

Still, it's seriously embarrassing

Ps5 29250 (99.09%) XsX 28946 (98.57%)

0.52% of advantage, and most of this nothingness is during the cutscenes and not the gameplay. lol

tn_1235245586270.jpg
 
Last edited:

RobRSG

Member
blue team
slightly better on xsx = not a 2TF difference!
slightly better on PS5 = another one!
any amount better on SX = photo mode

green team
slightly better on SX = win
slightly better on ps5 - VRR
any amount better on sx = better GPU
It’s funny and sad at the same time, I’d prefer that everyone could have all boxes and fucking enjoy the games instead of fighting over them.

Having that said, congrats XSX for the rare but important win.

Code:
Real Winner is PC. Does whatever you
want without
Checkerboarding.

dL3qkiu.jpg
 
Last edited:

Genx3

Member
I mean a win is a win but if it matters to you is another question. If I had an XSS and a PS5 I would definitely pick up the PS5 version no questions asked. But if I had a PS5 and an XSX visuals probably wouldn't be a consideration since they are almost always extremely close. It would probably boil down to controller features or content.
So having VRR is not an advantage for XSX?

I guess that's why Sony TV's that advertised VRR capability still don't support it because apparently its not an important feature for Sony's customers.
Any game that doesn't run locked 60fps and drops frames is going to feel smoother with VRR when combined with a display that supports VRR.
 

AGRacing

Member


I ran the demo on PC last night... 6900 XT with Ray Tracing ON. Lots of maxed detail settings. Quick and dirty... but the framerate was sky high. I wish Metrics overlay recorded... but we are talking 120 fps at 1440p with RT ON.

I believe this is one of the first AMD optimized RT implications on PC. We have consoles to thank I'm sure.
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned


PlatformsPS5 RT OnXbox Series X RT OnXbox Series S RT On
Frame Amounts
Game Frames290922920420189
Video Frames293082930729308
Frame Tearing Statistics
Total Torn Frames000
Lowest Torn Line---
Frame Height216021602160
Frame Time Statistics
Mean Frame Time16.79ms16.73ms24.19ms
Median Frame Time16.67ms16.67ms16.67ms
Maximum Frame Time33.33ms33.33ms50ms
Minimum Frame Time16.67ms16.67ms16.67ms
95th Percentile Frame Time16.67ms16.67ms33.33ms
99th Percentile Frame Time16.67ms16.67ms33.33ms
Frame Rate Statistics
Mean Frame Rate59.56fps59.79fps41.33fps
Median Frame Rate60fps60fps42fps
Maximum Frame Rate60fps60fps58fps
Minimum Frame Rate46fps48fps31fps
5th Percentile Frame Rate57fps59fps36fps
1st Percentile Frame Rate54fps54fps34fps
Frame Time Counts
16.67ms28876 (99.26%)29101 (99.65%)11072 (54.84%)
33.33ms216 (0.74%)103 (0.35%)9115 (45.15%)
50ms0 (0%)0 (0%)2 (0.01%)
Other
Dropped Frames000
Runt Frames000
Runt Frame Thresholds20 rows20 rows20 rows


57yz51.jpg
 

pasterpl

Member
No. You know gamers actually care about stuff other than a few frames. Like for example, the Dual Sense. Which provides a much more tangible difference than a few frames nobody notices when the FPS counter isn’t turned on.
So now with games that are performing better on xbsex (expecting more games to perform better on xbsex) narrative will be dual sense? What else, except dual sense players care about? I am just curious. Also what about games that doesn’t support dual sense?
 
So having VRR is not an advantage for XSX?

I guess that's why Sony TV's that advertised VRR capability still don't support it because apparently its not an important feature for Sony's customers.
Any game that doesn't run locked 60fps and drops frames is going to feel smoother with VRR when combined with a display that supports VRR.

Every damn game by every analysts are analysed in its pure form, so, without VRR, as it should be.

So now with games that are performing better on xbsex (expecting more games to perform better on xbsex) narrative will be dual sense

I'm sure you're damn proud how 1.8 TF advantage provides an overall 0.7% fps advantage. But of course, Dualsense support provides a better gameplay immersion, that is not a some narrative.
 
Last edited:

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
This thread turned Out great! Lol I think it’s the curse of the exclusivity deal. Valhalla had marketing rights with Xbox and ran worse. This is ps and Xbox is the best place to play 😂

peeps, don’t downplay vrr or freesync, or g sync. It’s a gamechanger and sonys customers should be demanding it. Sony fucking promised it.
 
Last edited:

Thirty7ven

Banned
So now with games that are performing better on xbsex (expecting more games to perform better on xbsex) narrative will be dual sense? What else, except dual sense players care about? I am just curious. Also what about games that doesn’t support dual sense?

You’re really trying hard to make Xbsex happen aren’t you? There’s no narrative, just cold hard facts. The performance difference is minuscule and there are other more tangible differences.

But keep trying to make that sex thing work, and keep creating a fantasy in your head.
 

SkylineRKR

Member
S does a good job. It was supposed to run 1440p/30fps in RT mode but apparently its unlocked and hovers higher. Capcom can easily patch this and lock the fps.
 

skit_data

Member
So now with games that are performing better on xbsex (expecting more games to perform better on xbsex) narrative will be dual sense? What else, except dual sense players care about? I am just curious. Also what about games that doesn’t support dual sense?
Why not? People are using ”at least the Series consoles have VRR” in the games PS5 perform 0,5% better i framerate graphs. I’d say its more relevant than VRR to 97,5% of the potential buyers.

Dualsense support and smaller game sizes on PS5 vs better BC in general and VRR on Series X are the only mentionable differences so far if we are to be completely honest to ourselves.
 
Last edited:

geordiemp

Member
So some engines and game setups run 0.5 % better on ps5, some run 0.5 % better on XSX



Whats funny is that some posters are getting excited and claiming victories.

Fast clocks cancel out the extra CU, extra CU cancel out the fast clocks. Who would of guessed ?

All I can say is the series S should be ditched.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
I can’t take any comparisons of this game seriously after those documents leaked talking about technical parity.

What are all of these 1080p/50fps comments though? Some inside joke I am missing? Doesn’t the PS5 run the same as XSX just with a tiny frame rate difference?
That technical parity wasn't about graphical parity. This has been explained countless of times before.

The XsX isn't locked at 60fps on RT mode and that alone should tell you that there's not enough headroom left (or none at all) for improvement.
 

Fredrik

Member
Why is this thread so long?
Oh... There is a 2fps difference...

If those frames are important, here’s the tip of the day, it runs well on oldish PCs too for those of you who bought a PC last gen to play MS exclusives. Full controller support as well.
1080ti, 1080p, prioritize graphics, won’t beat the new consoles on visuals but it runs beautifully ❤️
mjr1MXB.jpg
 
Going back to Dusk Golems rumor and assuming that it was true. I'm seriously impressed with how quickly the developers managed to turn around the PS5 version. Definitely a testament to the ease of development on the platform and should bode well for future games.
 
I mean, we know for a fact that the hardware specs in xbox are higher across the board. Higher cpu clock speed, higher ram bandwidth and a pretty nice uplift in gpu power. Common sense points that games performing better on series x should be standard. Who knows why they werent in the first couple of months, but they seem to have figured out whatever they had to

Well it could just be dependent on the needs of the engine. Also the XSX isn't superior in every single way which could account for any advantages the PS5 might have. Your definitely not comparing a high end PC to a high end PC from 5 years ago.
 
Why is this thread so long?
Oh... There is a 2fps difference...

If those frames are important, here’s the tip of the day, it runs well on oldish PCs too for those of you who bought a PC last gen to play MS exclusives. Full controller support as well.
1080ti, 1080p, prioritize graphics, won’t beat the new consoles on visuals but it runs beautifully ❤️
mjr1MXB.jpg

Good to know. 1080P is more than enough for me.
 
Top Bottom