• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

New Sonic rumor from the same guy that was right about Sonic Generations

Gunstar Ikari

Unconfirmed Member
So...how are they gonna fuck it up this time?

Shitty boss battles. Aside from maybe Perfect Chaos in Generations, the bosses in Sonic games have been terrible for a long time.

Whats up with the Dimps shit? They made better Sonic games than the Sonic team.

The last good Dimps game was Rush. Rush Adventure's sailing segments are terrible and everything since feels phoned in.
 
Man if only we got another Sonic game with multiple characters, minigames, and set in a human open world with a story incongruous to the art.

I bet if they made another one of those it could not at all be a trainwreck
 
Sonic, Tails and Knuckles are good, amy is not if anything like before. She should stick to being a cut scene character like in SA2.
 
You guys got your Sonic Adventure 3 in Sonic 2006.

It didn't need the word Adventure to be the same kind of game and the name Adventure would not have made it any less bad.

Move on.
 
Sonic Team makes quality games now. Good.

They can now handle multiple playable characters. Great.

The plot sounds fun, down to earth, and very in character for the Sonic world. Fantastic.

Will play like Generations. Fuck.
I think I'm in the minority, admittedly, but I'm really sick of the boost track-racer style of gameplay. I'd love for a more free-roaming approach again, with the goal of earning your momentum vs hitting a button and instantly moving at lightspeed. Oh well, the positives here far outweigh this negative. I'm literally drooling at what the Sonic art team is going to pull off with next gen hardware. Colors/Generations/Unleashed were some of the most appealing, beautiful games on their respective consoles. I am so in.
 

Dark Schala

Eloquent Princess
The friends were never the problem; it was the shitty gimmicks that they brought to the table. If this rumor is true, then they're handling it Advance style, which is great.
I was just going to post something like that. The friends themselves weren't the issue; their gameplay mechanics just didn't work.

Advance at least handled that adequately and didn't add a ton of oddly-designed and paced bloat to the core game like the Adventure games / Heroes did. If this game takes after that, I don't think I'd mind as much. Play like Sonic + one or two things that differentiate them from him... just like Tails and Knuckles. I'd just want Sonic front and centre as opposed to the friends taking the spotlight more often than he did a la Adventure/Heroes/06.
 

tajd

Banned
That's how it starts.

First they make them playable
Then they make Chaotix playable
Then they make Silver and Shadow playable
then they make Blonic playable


main story

sonic tails knuckles amy eggman

side story

shadow rouge blaze silver cream

cameos

vanilla emerl espio vector charmy

no sign of omega tho
 

iavi

Member
I was just going to post something like that. The friends themselves weren't the issue; their gameplay mechanics just didn't work.

Advance at least handled that adequately and didn't add a ton of oddly-designed and paced bloat to the core game like the Adventure games / Heroes did. If this game takes after that, I don't think I'd mind as much. Play like Sonic + one or two things that differentiate them from him... just like Tails and Knuckles. I'd just want Sonic front and centre as opposed to the friends taking the spotlight more often than he did a la Adventure/Heroes/06.

Getting a Generations quality title that has the friends as playable in it is going to be really fucking weird, for some reason.

And it shouldn't be, given that the friends have been playable since 2.
 
You guys got your Sonic Adventure 3 in Sonic 2006.

It didn't need the word Adventure to be the same kind of game and the name Adventure would not have made it any less bad.

Move on.

Why can people not differentiate between an incompetent team and a style of gameplay. If you gave blueprint of Uncharted to the Sonic Team of 2001/06 it would have turned out like dogshit because the devteam was composed of dogshit. But does that invalidate Uncharted's style of gameplay? No. ST cleaned house after 06 with completely new people. The execution is the issue here, not the gameplay style.
 

Daingurse

Member
look man, it'll worth it in the end once they bring back Mighty and Ray


My man! We need Mighty, he was the original pallet swap!

mighty.jpg
 

QisTopTier

XisBannedTier
I don't mind if ammy is playble, just make her use her hammer on certain things only she and say knuckles could break into and let her use it to high jump up to stuff.

Keep the gameplay as close to sonic's gameplay as possible.

There is nothing wrong with sonic's "shitty" friends being characters as long as they don't go the shitty adventure route and follow the Sonic 3 route
 
look man, it'll worth it in the end once they bring back Mighty and Ray
Poor Mighty, of all the various friends seen over the years this guy going into a ball makes far more sense than the rest, so he's the guy who gets dropped.

At least they're not introducing a new character...I think.

Didn't you see the cycle? you've got to wait a bit, get those hopes raised and then they unveil the new character for maximum impact.
 
main story

sonic tails knuckles amy eggman

side story

shadow rouge blaze silver cream

cameos

vanilla emerl espio vector charmy

no sign of omega tho

Omega wasn't present in Generations, either (outside of being a statue). Is Sega ditching him? =(
 

Piers

Member
I don't know why but the fact Shattered Heights retreads Speed Highway so much is the sort of dumb thing I expect SonicTeam to do. (Presuming that this poster is true) Still sounds pretty interesting and exciting - the fact there are humans in the stage itself is a cool touch if true.
 

Dark Schala

Eloquent Princess
man the sonic levels in 06 were awesome and long like 13 minutes each
Which part(s) of the levels' designs did you like?

Miizy F Baby said:
Getting a Generations quality title that has the friends as playable in it is going to be really fucking weird, for some reason.
If they manage to execute the various types of gameplay for different characters well enough and cohesively enough so that the characters aren't taking more precedence from Sonic, and they don't feel like a chore for the player, then I'll be content. However, I'm still feeling a little iffy about that.
 

Slermy

Member
sonic rush - yes

sonic rush adventure and generations 3ds , noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Sonic Rush Adventure wasn't that bad, I still enjoyed it, though not as much as Sonic Rush.

Sonic Colors (DS) though.... UGH.
 
Hmm, it has been a while since I played Colors DS. I don't remember hating it. What was consensus for that one?

Anyways, I kind of hope this is more similar to Colors where they mixed in 2D and 3D. I enjoyed Generations a lot but didn't like the segregation of the levels so much.
 

Revven

Member
Sounds exactly what I've been wanting for the last couple of years. As long as it's using Generations/Colors gameplay we should be in for a real treat!
 

RagnarokX

Member
Sounds good. Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Amy is the way it should be. Amy should be hard mode (slower, no spin attacks, has to manually use her hammer).

Also... STOP MAKING SO MANY CITY LEVELS!
 

Azure J

Member
I've been craving some new Sonic since PC Generations and this is all sounding wonderful. Hope they get down the content to presentation ratio like they did with Colors here though. Generations was a spectacle, but Colors had more levels and fun things going on in stages.

Oh yeah, good job on only using the OG 4 for multiple character stuff.
 
Top Bottom