Most people I've seen call the writing bad post YouTube videos of someone else writing "a better version" of the story, which ends up being filled with actual plot holes.
It really makes me believe that these people don't know what "good writing" truly is.
People who believe that TLOU2 is good writing are -by literal definition-, people who don't know what "good writing" is.
They'd better make "Joel, the Fungus Zombie" DLC, where Joel turns to zombie after being killed and goes to killing rampage himself.
Zombie Joel killing Abby and her trans friend.
It's like poetry, it rhymes.
Maybe we'll finally see where she got all the growth hormones from.
Already explained by Cuckmann. The explanation is: "there's a gym ovah there".
So it doesn't matter that in a post apocalyptic world you don't have neither the time, the rest cycle, the nutrients, the steroids or in this case the genetics to reach such a level.
And that's not mentioning that in the postapocalyptic world of The Last Of US 2, being that buffed would be quite counterproductive. You have a far better chance being lean.