retsof624
Member
You really posted this bullshit here and expected to get a pat on the back lmao
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
[DF] Metro Exodus Enhanced Edition: PS5 vs Xbox Series X - Image Quality + Performance Tests
- Thread starter 3liteDragon
- Start date
- Analysis
You really posted this bullshit here and expected to get a pat on the back lmao
Inviusx
Member
The PS5 version definitely has gamma issues. I'm playing it as we speak and I'm seeing a lot of crushed blacks everywhere. Some areas it works in the games favour like some of the tunnels in the Volga area where the pitch black image makes it seem more intense but I don't think that's the developers intention.
In normal play I'm definitely losing detail in shadows where I shouldn't be. I'm currently running 1 notch above default for the gamma setting.
This is on a C9 OLED running via HGIG calibration.
In normal play I'm definitely losing detail in shadows where I shouldn't be. I'm currently running 1 notch above default for the gamma setting.
This is on a C9 OLED running via HGIG calibration.
Last edited:
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
On my phone Xbox looks like hot trash and ps5 looks great, but on my tv Xbox has great blacks and ps5 you can't see shit.
jezhumphrey75
Banned
xbox running a train on the industry.
Shmunter
Member
Is that despite being able to see the left most logo in the game calibration?
Bo_Hazem
Banned
Depends on TV type/model/make as well. Both look off but both are shown in SDR anyway here.
assurdum
Banned
Well it's not like they don't called it. If their talks was more limited about analytics tech aspects, maybe less people would attack them. Never seen anyone blame VGtech. Alex passed ten minutes calling noticeable difference, what you can catch mostly looking to some subpixels details in specific spots; I stop to believe to the coincidence when they search such narrative. It seems they put their hand ahead as to say "you see, 30% higher res broh, who cares of some drops". And we seen how many people here parrot their words just to get the point.
Last edited:
Justin9mm
Member
Was the same on the One X compared to Pro
Last edited:
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
This is odd then. Maybe it's an LCD or OLED issue? Not sure. Funny though, really shows the difference a tv makes. Kinda seems like calling something washed out, too dark or too bright is down to the tv, and not the console version.
Inviusx
Member
I can see the left most logo on every single notch on the gamma slider.
Rea
Member
He confirmed the original controller also has same issue. Read the comments.
assurdum
Banned
Er not exactly. One X had almost of the double of the resolution gap seen in this generation, with sometimes better performance and also graphic setting.
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
You need to calibrate your tv.
Shmunter
Member
This games lowest dark on PS5 is on a hair I believe and is dependent on the black level.
If the black level is even slightly lower for anyone, no amount of gamma adjustment will bring it out. And with display variances it’s obvious some are falling on one or the other side.
Bump up brightness (or whatever it’s called on your set) and I bet the logo will appear.
The Xbox version is definitely blowing out the blacks. It looks terrible with the lowest black being a shade of grey. A set would really need to be out of whack to produce pure black from that signal.
Last edited:
Shmunter
Member
Then conversely you should see every detail in the game. Somewhat confounding your findings.
Exanthus
Banned
Are you serious?
assurdum
Banned
Just look at thread and see what people said
Last edited:
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
I have a 12 foot window beside my tv and I havnt watched the video at night, but looked fine with insane glare haha.
DarkMage619
$MSFT
There are plenty of people here receptive to this message.
Inviusx
Member
The game is the issue. I'm not changing my TV settings for one title when the rest work as expected.
You Can't rely on a niche feature, their DRS profiler is setup wrong and constantly sets the repulsions slightly too high, others have theorised it's due to the proper Dev kit having a bit more power.
Inviusx
Member
I think gamma as a whole is just borked on PS5. The highlights get insanely blown out on the higher end of the gamma scale but the black level isn't raised in accordance with that shift.
The Xbox footage is what im expecting to see on my PS5. At the moment it's insanely contrasty and not in a good way although I know some people like seeing crazy amounts of contrast between dark and light but generally that isn't how the games artists want it to be viewed.
Last edited:
Kingthrash
Member
Fanboy conspiracy theory? Does everything you disagree with have to be fanboy status? Proof was well provided and even Digital Foundry is changing their story..."fanboy conspiracy theory" ...you are the only insecure fanboy here.
Kingthrash
Member
Pat on the back?? From who?? Lol all I do is deliver the facts lol ...yall just too insecure to accept it
Kingthrash
Member
Naw I got a whole youtube account based on the facts. You just too insecure to see it. Lol I didn't even bash the xbox...even said the both look equal....there is just something wrong with capturing video with it. Even provided proof....you got proof stating otherwise or are you just gunna sit here crying over the facts?
Spukc
always chasing the next thrill
holy shit this is HUGE
Kingthrash
Member
Lol that all you got? You got ANY point showing this is some lie? Did you even watch the video? Or are you just a lil insecure guy who has this unpaid duty to pretend any facts about xbox is a lie?
Timestamp where the video hurt you bro?
Spukc
always chasing the next thrill
Kingthrash
Member
"Go away"? Lol why? Is this some kind of club or something? There is alot of insecurities flying around here lol.
Shmunter
Member
Still wouldn’t explain your prior crush issue
Kingthrash
Member
Then why would they give you a flashlight?
I've played all metro games....they were all dark. Tbh both the ps5 and xbox series x look identical...both look like the Playstation version in the DF video....there is a problem when capturing off a xbox
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
IMO the darker presentation is correct.
The enhanced edition if washed out piece of shit on pc. Even worse in HDR. Gamma is broken too.
With -deependark, it looks WAY closer to how original looked in SDR. hdr is still raised a bit.
Maybe You need oled to see this but by default on pc, the enhanced edition does not have "black color". Everything is grey
The enhanced edition if washed out piece of shit on pc. Even worse in HDR. Gamma is broken too.
With -deependark, it looks WAY closer to how original looked in SDR. hdr is still raised a bit.
Maybe You need oled to see this but by default on pc, the enhanced edition does not have "black color". Everything is grey
Inviusx
Member
The only explanation needed is that it's a software fault.
saintjules
Member
I'm looking to buy it this week, but can someone tell me is it The Complete Edition or the Enhanced Edition that has all the bells and whistles + DLC?
Microsoft store says Enhanced Edition, but the physical copies say Complete Edition. I still have to check DF's comparison to see if there's anything better on the PS5 version.
Microsoft store says Enhanced Edition, but the physical copies say Complete Edition. I still have to check DF's comparison to see if there's anything better on the PS5 version.
Last edited:
ultrazilla
Gold Member
That's horrible input lag/bug. MS needs to fix that ASAP. Wow.
Negotiator101
Member
Comedy goldListen, you are the last person who can talk about caricature there. You are so desperate to get your win every single time, to ignore any kind of logic, insulting here and there, showing a scarce tech knowledge in most of your post. The problem it's not me who talks about trivial differences but people like you who hides their hypocrisy behind the math number, to exalt something barely visible with naked eye, calling more noticeable fps issue a second factor, as MS give for free to all his fans a TV monitor with VRRand how do you know FPS is fixable just with lower resolution? Because I wouldn't be so sure about it.
MadchesterManc
Member
I mentioned something similar earlier in the thread as a possibility given to why the Xbox version looks washed out, could have ended up suffering the same problem if PC & Xbox are to share a toolset going forward. It was the same for me with the PC connected to a Panasonic LCD when the update first dropped and I had to use the same steam command to fix. With 4A providing the fix themselves I assume the darker presentation is what they originally envisaged.
Iced Arcade
Member
LOL oh, unpluck your bloomers. was referencing your youtube page in general that you are here promoting. I gave you some clicks, you're welcome!
Last edited:
Stuart360
Member
So its not a pardoy acount?. I wasnt sure with the way you can barely put a scentence together, and sound like an idiot.
mancstheps5fanboy
Banned
if you got the physical disc
Kingthrash
Member
Account*
Wasn't*
Sentence*
(You didn't need a comma before you typed "and")
For someone trying to tell me that I can barely put a sentence together, you'd think they'd know how to put a actual sentence together.
Stuart360
Member
Well i have dyslexia, but i'm sure you got my point.
assurdum
Banned
Last edited:
Synless
Member
I have the ps4 disc, downloaded the ps5 version.
Kingthrash
Member
Smh so you have dyslexia but talk to people the way you do? There is no excuse for that. You need to mature up, dyslexia isn't an excuse to attempt to troll people just because you disagree.Well i have dyslexia, but i'm sure you got my point.
Understand that it is ok to disagree...that's how the best conversations and learning experiences are had....but when you spit insults because you disagree, it's really immature and most people just cringe at it.
BigLee74
Member
AN actual sentence.
Kingthrash
Member
So you got nothing?
I don't care for the clicks I care for the accuracy of information by those we trust.
(Assuming you are a gamer)
Clearly you didn't have any objections to what I said... you just disagree with the facts....sadly you just want as much misinformation to fire off so you can continue the childish console war and continue to be taken advantage of for the sake of trolling