Support NeoGAF

[MasterCornholio]

It's literally in the video?



58 FPS vs 49 FPS.

Note the "up to", it's not always that far ahead.

It's probably an outlier correct?

 

[sncvsrtoip]

DF says is 10% is that wrong and is 15%? Just asking. Haven't seen the video.

around 10% hard to say exactly couse scene is dynamic and drops are not in same second on ps5 and xsx, we have to wait for vgtech spreadsheet

 

[Kuranghi]

It's literally in the video?



58 FPS vs 49 FPS.

Note the "up to", it's not always that far ahead.

The point you linked to shows the XSX drops to 48 and the PS5 drops to 46, am I missing something here? Where are you getting 58 vs. 49 from?

 

[OverHeat]

Framerate vs loading time...hummm

 

[skit_data]

Remember that due to locked 60fps the Xbox could be even higher under normal situations

Ah, this gives me flashbacks from the Hitman 3 thread.

 

[ethomaz]

DF says is 10% is that wrong and is 15%? Just asking. Haven't seen the video.

At heavy scenes the Series seems X seems to have 10% better framerate... the heavy scene they are talking about is 50fps vs 45fps.

But again the dips are really really rare... the game is over 99% of time 60fps locked.

 

[Golgo 13]

Sounds like the RT is kinda shitty. Doubt I'll even turn it on TBH, I'd much prefer a flawless 60FPS.

 

[assurdum]

around 10% hard to say exactly couse scene is dynamic and drops are not in same second on ps5 and xsx, we have to wait for vgtech spreadsheet

Well that's undoubted when the scenario is solely limited to the GPU usage, series X shows his advantage. Things change when both CPU GPU are stressed.

 

[MasterCornholio]

On ps5 too. What's exactly the point?

I think the reason why they lock it is to keep the experience relatively smooth. You're right that both systems go above 60FPS.

 

[Kangx]

Also during that heavy scence which John have found to be most stress because of a lot of ray tray refection. Even though the scene did not line up, but you find the series x have 3 to 4 frames, at most I see a couple of 7 to 8 frames. As vgtech and Richard also demonstrate that for most scenes, series x have 1 to 2 frames differences. The x has the advantage here, no one is denying that, but don't abuse graph and spread misinformation. And here, this is what DF said about both platforms performance.

" So PS5 has faster loading and Xbox Series X has an edge in frame-rate when using ray tracing but, honestly, both versions are extremely close to one another. It's one of the closest calls we've seen and it feels like Capcom has done justice to the two new machines "

 

[Fredrik]

Another thread?

lol unexpected ending

Anyway, another one for Xbox but personally I don’t see how RT is worth it if they have to stop to point out such small differences. I played the demo on PC at 1080p 144fps without RT and it was definitely a more pleasant experience.

I guess the living room and couch and surround sound could get me to choose the XSX version, but I’m not sure it’s worth losing 84fps.

 

[Arias05]

It's literally in the video?



58 FPS vs 49 FPS.

Note the "up to", it's not always that far ahead.

XSX flexing its gpu

 

[Zathalus]

It's probably an outlier correct?

Yes, of course, that is worse case scenario.

The point you linked to shows the XSX drops to 48 and the PS5 drops to 46, am I missing something here? Where are you getting 58 vs. 49 from?

Odd, it shows 58 vs 49 for me. It happens just before the spoiler section.

 

[carloseduardocd]

Up to 18% better performance in RT mode for the Series X, and 4x loading speeds on the PS5.

Seems to be showing off the strengths of each system.

No, you must see frame by frame.

For example, if i look to the image below, they're equal in 52 fps. But it's not the same frame.

This "monster water" sequence drops from 52 to minimum 48fps on Xbox Series X, and from 52 to 47 and minimum 45fps on PS5.

It's better on Xbox Series X, but not 18%. It's maximum 10% on few frames.
For example,

if

 

[assurdum]

lol unexpected ending

Anyway, another one for Xbox but personally I don’t see how RT is worth it if they have to stop to point out such small differences. I played the demo on PC at 1080p 144fps without RT and it was definitely a more pleasant experience.

I guess the living room and couch and surround sound could get me to choose the XSX version, but I’m not sure it’s worth losing 84fps.

Dude...both are extremely close. All these chats about you no console war and another one for a better performance who barely someone can perceive?

 

[rickybooby87]

PS5 has no loading screen

 

[Riky]

The point you linked to shows the XSX drops to 48 and the PS5 drops to 46, am I missing something here? Where are you getting 58 vs. 49 from?

 

[Kangx]

It's literally in the video?



58 FPS vs 49 FPS.

Note the "up to", it's not always that far ahead.

Oh, spare me the bulletin. During that heavy scence which John have found to be most stress because of a lot of ray tray refection. Even though the scene did not line up, but you find the series x have 3 to 4 frames, at most I see a couple of 7 to 8 frames. As vgtech and Richard also demonstrate that for most scenes, series x have 1 to 2 frames differences. The x has the advantage here, no one is denying that, but don't abuse graph and spread misinformation. And here, this is what DF said about both platforms performance.

" So PS5 has faster loading and Xbox Series X has an edge in frame-rate when using ray tracing but, honestly, both versions are extremely close to one another. It's one of the closest calls we've seen and it feels like Capcom has done justice to the two new machines "

 

[DenchDeckard]

I wonder why this is the "most important thing" ...

The load times aren't the end of the world tbh; I'm thinking Capcom aren't leveraging DirectStorage API (let alone SFS) on the Series platforms here, but they might be tapping into Sony's SSD I/O stack more directly. Considering the marketing partnership, I would be surprised if Sony did not provide them the assistance there as needed.

Most important thing in this new comparison, the last one didn't show it, this one did, we already knew how it runs.

Thanks for covering Moose.

That's exactly it. We knew where performance was but didn't have any comparison for load times. So I feel this is the most important thing from this new comparison.

 

[Ass of Can Whooping]

It's probably an outlier correct?

The Xbox recovered from the falling wood scene while the PS5 hasn't. It's not a like for like comparison

 

[OverHeat]

Another thread?

Look at those console monkeys!!!! this GIF is just perfect, you want performance? Drop the cash and go PC

 

[Kuranghi]

Odd, it shows 58 vs 49 for me. It happens just before the spoiler section.

Oh right! Okay I agree with you then.

I wasn't trying to be disengenuous you just didnt link it properly, I was looking at the spoiler bit for comparison, link to at least few seconds before the point you want to talk about in the future not the exact second you want to talk about epsecially when the scene in question ends immediately after that.

 

[ethomaz]

Most important thing in this new comparison, the last one didn't show it, this one did, we already knew how it runs.

Yeap the new feat are the loading times.
We already new PS5 was below 2s but they hide three Series loading times until now.

 

[ethomaz]

Odd, it shows 58 vs 49 for me. It happens just before the spoiler section.

Not the same scene... you need to look the same.

 

[ethomaz]

Resident Evil Village tech review: Capcom transitions beautifully to next-gen

Resident Evil Village has arrived and while the various demos over the last few weeks gave us a chance to sample the te…

www.eurogamer.net

 

[assurdum]

Man we need desperately of a clown pic in the like button. Riky desperately asks for this.

 

[Julius Ibidus]

this nerd fight is disappointing. up your game guys!

 

[carloseduardocd]

Itś not the same frame. The Xbox equivalent frame (look at the water) has 53fps.

There's a difference, but not significant.

 

[OverHeat]

Resident Evil 8 Village Benchmark Test & Performance Review - Raytracing Quality | TechPowerUp DF should put High end pc in the mix just for the lol's

 

[StreetsofBeige]

That entire scene is a huge gain for Series X. That particular image is at the 15.39 mark.

 

[MachRc]

none of this will matter as

Im going PC version for the mods...

Resident Evil Village already has an incredible mod scene

Just wait until they have the full game

www.polygon.com

 

[ethomaz]

That part is 53 vs 49.

 

[SlimySnake]

5 fps difference in rt mode in one sequence. Dusk Golem redeemed.

Another one.

 

[SplunkyMunkey]

Pretty impressive just shows that ps5 isnt all that weak what people seem to think. We all know series x will do well for RT due to having that 52cu but ps5 is quite capable despite only having 36cu that ssd is quite something

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Itś not the same frame. The Xbox equivalent frame (look at the water) has 53fps.

There's a difference, but not significant.

You literally cherry pick one second before Riky's image snapshot.

That entire scene has Xbox with a better frame rate almost the entire time.

 

[assurdum]

I want this written on the DF grave:
with a small but noticeable performance lead on the Microsoft machine
From the article.
We have reached a new way to spin the superiority narrative.

 

[carloseduardocd]

Resident Evil 8 Village Benchmark Test & Performance Review - Raytracing Quality | TechPowerUp DF should put High end pc in the mix just for the lol's

Jesus, such a nice job on Xbox Series X and PS5.

 

[ethomaz]

You literally cherry pick one second before Riky's image snapshot.

That entire scene has Xbox with a better frame rate almost the entire time.

He picked the actual same frame in both.
When you align the scenes the framerate different when the dips happens is not big as big like the different scenes are showing in the Riky pic.

So the posted pic fame on Series shows 53 vs 49 on PS5.

 

[OverHeat]

Jesus, such a nice job on Xbox Series X and PS5.

its not the same settings so slow down

 

[Mister Wolf]

The VRR will come in handy for those drops in RT mode.

 

[NullZ3r0]

Loading speed 5x faster on PS5

Which in the real world is 5 seconds faster. To put this in context, we came from 30 second to 2 minute loading times on previous gen consoles so in the end it's as negligible as we expected.

 

[ChuckeRearmed]

Well in theory the PS5s I/O has more throughput. That definitely helps.

It still not to the point of 1 to 7s difference.

 

[carloseduardocd]

You literally cherry pick one second before Riky's image snapshot.

That entire scene has Xbox with a better frame rate almost the entire time.

No, i'm just making the right way, i.e, comparing the exactly frame.

In this frame it's not 58 vs 49, it's 53 vs 49.

It's just a matter to see the video and the pixel sequence.

 

[Ass of Can Whooping]

Which in the real world is 5 seconds faster. To put this in context, we came from 30 second to 2 minute loading times on previous gen consoles so in the end it's as negligible as we expected.

Excuse me sir do not try to deny me a win

 

[assurdum]

It still not to the point of 1 to 7s difference.

8 second Vs 1 second isn't exactly that?

 

[Riky]

The VRR will come in handy for those drops in RT mode.

Yep, they say that in the video, practically flawless performance on Series X with RT on.

 

[RoboFu]

If I could get a PS5 I would get this game on it for the faster loading alone. even if the Xboxload isnt that long in game.

 

[carloseduardocd]

its not the same settings so slow down

Of course not. They obviously don't put maximum presets on consoles.

But it's a great result at all.

 

[Zathalus]

Thanks for the image, anyone can just look at the FPS graph at the bottom and see one is just under the 60fps mark and the other is just under the 50fps mark.

Damn, some really get triggered over this.

 

[Stuart360]

Dude...both are extremely close. All these chats about you no console war and another one for a better performance who barely someone can perceive?

As have all the comparisons so far since launch (barring maybe Hitman 3), but that didnt stop 20 page threads full of bollocks.
You have to take the losses as well as the 'wins'.