-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Cyberpunk 2077 Comparison - Xbox Series X vs. Xbox Series S vs. Xbox One S vs. PS5 vs. PS4
- Thread starter Craig of War
- Start date
GHG
Member
Let me just say this - Just because it will be "ambitious" for a Halo game, that doesn't make it ambitious in the grand scheme of things.
If there was going to be anything special about Halo Infinite they would have told us already considering they had no issue in showing off that trailer earlier this year with the mindset that people would get excited because of it.
ThatOneGrunt
Member
Gunslinger
Member
So the game can hold a steady 60fps on PS5 ( performance mode ) ?
Aenima
Member
XSX and PS5 runs at 60fps but they both drop frames. From the streams i saw its a very smooth experience on PS5. But i usually dont notice frame drops uless they are big drops.
Ogbert
Member
So here's another PS5 v Series X comparison No commentary but it seems to the first one that seems to show that the X version seem to have more detail but marginal at best.
Also a couple of screen shots from it
The X version seems to be much sharper. But I'm guessing that's down to the X being better at BC?
Ogbert
Member
They were only allowed to review on PC.
As others have pointed out, this is why they're pushing the free upgrade. The game is not designed for last gen - it just can't handle it.
Mobilemofo
Member
Just installing on my ps4 pro. Almost done installing. Will put up some thoughts in an hour or two.
Aenima
Member
So here's another PS5 v Series X comparison No commentary but it seems to the first one that seems to show that the X version seem to have more detail but marginal at best.
Also a couple of screen shots from it
That seems to be XSX in quality mode (30 fps) vs PS5 performance (60 fps). Game is so much more silky smooth on PS5, you can see some stutter on XSX but has better shadows and slight less blurry detail.
Bruno_Arrais85
Member
Question: why they are comparing the ps5 and SX versions without the next gen patch? I'm missing the point.
Last edited:
McCheese
Member
Having a blast with it myself on the pro, it's a bit depressing seeing the promotional cutscenes as there is clearly a huge downgrade for current gen systems, but game is still great fun and one of the best looking PS4 titles.
Yams
Member
I played a few hours on the Series X yesterday. If the Series X version is sharper, it's not anything to brag about. The game feels quite blurry. I don't know what resolution it runs in but I'd be surprised if it was above 1080p in Performance mode. It certainly doesn't feel like 1440p. Quality mode is crisper but it feels janky.
Riky
$MSFT
Last edited:
Ogbert
Member
No, sure.
I'm playing on a 2070 and it's the first game where I'm really having to dial stuff back to get the 60fps. Still looks great, but this game has no business being on last gen.
Delays wouldn't have made a difference. It's too advanced.
DavidGzz
Member
Easy. They are showing us the current differences. They will double dip on views and show us the difference when the patches hit which won't be until next year some time.
OmegaSpear
Member
I want to play this game so bad but the patch is at 22gb/41gb on my base PS4. The download speed seems to go slower every hour and currently sits at 5hours. Does anyone have any base PS4 screenshots of Cyberpunk 2077(no spoilers)?
VisualFidelity
Member
Slightly higher resolution, more ppedestrians, and better SSAO on Series X
Martinski43
Member
Playing this on a Series X now, runs and looks better than on my PC, with GTX 1080, i7 4790k, 16 gb ram.
This is on performance mode .. too bad i am so shit with controller aim..
This is on performance mode .. too bad i am so shit with controller aim..
bargeparty
Member
Feel free to bookmark my post and return to it once Infinite finally launches and let me know.
Batiman
Banned
They shouldn’t even be selling it in that state. Embarrassing for such a great studio. They lost my respect but gained a shitload of money. I’m sure they don’t care
Markio128
Member
I can’t comment on the X1X version, but the PS5 visuals are really jarring, especially since I am currently playing through Valhalla, which is a really nice looking game. I wish I had waited for the PS5 upgrade, because while it seems to run smooth, the visuals are blurry, even by PS4 standards. And within 30 minutes of play, I noticed weird visual artefacts, particularly around lights.
I’m going to delete it and wait patiently for the update, which is fine because I’m not short of great games to play. The moral of this story is: if you have a PS5, just be patient and wait for the update.
I’m going to delete it and wait patiently for the update, which is fine because I’m not short of great games to play. The moral of this story is: if you have a PS5, just be patient and wait for the update.
Last edited:
Liberty4all
Banned
Glad I saw this thread. Was thinking about picking up for PS4, but now gonna be a hard pass until I can find a PS5.
Agnostic2020
Member
Nowhere near steady, down into the forties on this video
Both have issues with fps.Xsx frame in Performance mode
Last edited:
Batiman
Banned
They haven’t given a date? Could be a fuckin year.....
thelastword
Banned
Are you saying that most of these comparisons have been comparing the XBOX's quality mode to the PS5's performance mode?
So here's another PS5 v Series X comparison No commentary but it seems to the first one that seems to show that the X version seem to have more detail but marginal at best.
Also a couple of screen shots from it
If anything I see a higher AA pass on PS5. If not it's quality mode on XBOX vs Perf mode on PS5...
PS5 looks better here, better colors, better lighting, sharper.......There have been so many patches, so maybe some of these comparisons were done without certain patches.....I'm sure the PS5 version should have a Quality setting sooner of later if not already present...As for NPC's, it's an open world game, surely you don't expect the same NPC's and quantity to be represented across consoles.....A.I would cause them to populate different areas based on the gameplay....Slightly higher resolution, more ppedestrians, and better SSAO on Series X
ThatOneGrunt
Member
Last edited:
Riky
$MSFT
Both have issues with fps.Xsx frame in Performance mode
Playing with VRR, it's nice and smooth.
Yams
Member
Yeah I'm also playing Valhalla on Series X and going from it to Cyberpunk like quite drastic from an image quality standpoint. Valhalla rarely holds a full 4K but even at its lowest resolution, it feels dramatically sharper. The same can be said for any other back compact title I've tried (so far just Doom Eternal and Red Dead 2).
Jtibh
Banned
I find it sad and phatetic claiming these versions to be ps5 and xsx when its clearly stated by the devs that next gen patch arrives next year.Slightly higher resolution, more ppedestrians, and better SSAO on Series X
This is backcomp bullshit and neither show their full potential .
Yams
Member
I don't think anyone is trying to claim these are the definitive PS5 or Series X versions.
However, even in back compact mode, they are still the best showing of the game on console, which is why they are being shown.
Last edited:
Jtibh
Banned
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
The only difference I see in those images is HDR implementation.
OrtizTwelve
Member
So here's another PS5 v Series X comparison No commentary but it seems to the first one that seems to show that the X version seem to have more detail but marginal at best.
Also a couple of screen shots from it
Honestly both platforms will put out impressive visuals and effects. Comparing the two is just nit picking really, or preference
Jtibh
Banned
How is that a showcase of whats to come when just by nature xsx works with xboxonex code and its settings and ps5 works with ps4pro settings aka like in cod warfare or what ever when it couldnt go past the ps4 pro legacy codes resolution?
Xsx backcomp has many features ps5 wont ever have.
So ps4 has less detail in its code and other lower settings and ps5 does its best to work with whats given but even soo with garbage backcomp it still manages to run 60 and a much cleaner image quality.
Not to mention it doesnt even have a quality mode like xsx only performance mode
Slightly higher resolution, more ppedestrians, and better SSAO on Series X
Is there a context for comparisons like this?
Are they both from performance mode? Or one from performance mode and the other from quality mode?
In that case if you need to cut the frame rate in half to get these small differences it's not even worth it.
Unfortunately this game won't run to the full potential of next gen consoles until next year. It's just BC, it's not PS5 vs XSX anyway. It's PS4 Pro vs Xbox One X with BC improvements.
Bladed Thesis
Member
PS4 and by extension the PS5 doesn't have a performance mode. Or so reddit, forums and others have led me to believe.
Last edited:
Moogle11
Banned
So people who want to buy and plan now rather than waiting can decide which to get now.
Some comparison vids and quality mode on XSX only (and being 59gb instead of 102 on a system with less storage space) made me go with XSX instead of PS5. I'll do a replay as another origin/class when the next gen patch is out. I imagine any difference between the two post upgrade will be negligible to non-fussy (meaning don't care much about minor resolution or fps differences) people like myself just like most multiplat comparisons to date.
Last edited:
DaleinCalgary
Member
Seems Jeff Gerstman was the only honest press guy that said this game is a mess.
shame on all those that gave it 9/10's and 10's
shame on all those that gave it 9/10's and 10's
RoadHazard
Gold Member
TW3 had some issues (like hard v-syncing to 20fps on PS4 in some areas), but it was never anywhere near this bad. It was perfectly playable from day 1, and was improved from there (now runs at an almost flawless 30).
Moogle11
Banned
To be fair, reviews were of the PC versions which isn't nearly as bad, bugs aside. It's definitely a game that needs separate PC, current gen/PS4 Pro/X1X, and base PS4/X1 reviews though as the graphics and performance so different.
onnextflix5
Member
Slightly higher resolution, more ppedestrians, and better SSAO on Series X
Is the xbox sx running in performance mode like the ps5 ?, dam this is a shit show everywhere, they should have delayed it.