Will you ever forgive XBox?
I said "no", meaning I don't think he should be replaced. Not sure what there is to forgive. My issue was RROD and the focus on Kinect at the expense of core gamers. The guy responsible for that is already out, has been for a while as Spencer reversed course on a sinking ship that was Mattrick - sad how quickly people forget...
Anyways, I don't doubt Xbox hardware quality anymore and greatly appreciate Xbox's inclusiveness with respect to PC gamers. It was surprising to see 4/10 of the top selling global Steam games were Xbox Games Studio games a few weeks ago so I don't know what people are talking about when they say Xbox has no games as that was without Forza and Gears as well. In my mind and in my gaming universe (largely PC), Xbox and Phil Spencer have been a great friend and I wish him and the division continued success as they try to enable ALL gamers to be able to enjoy ALL games.
Edit: I should add that I'll never forgive RROD, my teenage self worked a lot of hours at $7 CAN minimum wage to buy a 360 and got lemon after lemon and had to bus it to Purolator to take it back costing me an hours wage each time and over an hour of life. They should have just given me a new redesigned console instead of the same model with the same issues... But again, that was under Mattrick