-Minsc-
Member
I found lost sagged a bit in the middle then managed to pull it's self together and end nicely.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Summer 2012 Anime |OT2| Of Suspended Anime Due To Olympics
- Thread starter dakkumauji
- Start date
- Status
I found lost sagged a bit in the middle then managed to pull it's self together and end nicely.
amishpriest99
Member
Review of episodes 1-6.
And part of his defense of said review in the talkback forum:
Another ANN review did give it a better review, though.
chickdigger802
Banned
Yeah the interaction between the genders in taritari is great. I occasionally forget this is anime.
RurouniZel
Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Good good!
It's hard not to be disappointed in anime sometimes, I can see where he's coming from.
Wat? I'm not the biggest F/Z fan but that's just fuckin' bonkers!
Its like Glee without the ugly 3D people
Chet Rippo
Member
and replaced with ugly 2D people.
I can tell Glee characters apart, I can't say the same about Tari Tari
Jim E. Rossler
Banned
Why didn't they name Motto To Love-Ru "Mo_ To Love-Ru"? Then it would have been punny
Doesn't "MoTrouble" sound more daft than punnish, though?
amishpriest99
Member
Just another reason why I trust my own judgement (and AnimeGAF now) rather than anime journalist reviews, particularly ANN.
Joe Molotov
Member
Mo moe, mo problems.
cosmicblizzard
Banned
MoMoney MoTroule.
KO Traveling Hobo
Member
Yuri macaroons > old and busted wizards
Jex
Member
I don't think it really matters, to me at least, whether they 'like' a work or not. That's not something I am concerned about.
I am far more concerned about the actual argument that they construct to back up their position. From my, admittedly limited, experience with the site they tend to be poorly thought-out and filled to the brim with fallacies, both formal and informal. Many of them struggle to rise above the level of a forum post.
KO Traveling Hobo
Member
I have to wonder how many people take them seriously. It's my understanding that ANN is a very popular website, but that could just be from the database side of it.
Just going to chip in here. This technique likely crosspollenated into Hidamari via SZS, where it's a several-times-an-episode cliche used to introduce major characters; during the later parts of X365 and episode EX especially, there was a lot of stylistic interplay within SHAFT between the two series. If I wave a chance to rewatch, I'll point out other scenes where this happened.
Hasn't it been around for a while? Longevity may contribute to that.
PoeticProse22
Member
Yuru Yuri 9
Despite several great moments, particularly the scene with Akane, this was a pretty mediocre episode. Once again, so much time was wasted on the dreadful Chinatsu.
Next episode should be much, much better, since Ayano, Kyouko, and Yui seem far more prevalent.
Despite several great moments, particularly the scene with Akane, this was a pretty mediocre episode. Once again, so much time was wasted on the dreadful Chinatsu.
Next episode should be much, much better, since Ayano, Kyouko, and Yui seem far more prevalent.
ANN has been around for years. Although it's not as old as, say, Anipike (which is now long irrelevant), ANN's pretty much the granddaddy of anime news sites in the English world, and now that they actually have people translating Yaraon articles etc. it's also pretty up to date.
There aren't many sites that offer a similar portal-esque experience for anime out there, and they have a good breadth of coverage of both manga and anime as well as the database. While I don't necessarily agree with their opinions on things, I can't begrudge the site's success.
As for Zac Bertschy, to be perfectly honest I agree with the kernel of what he says about a lot of things, but could really do without the inflammatory way he presents his opinions as it just causes drama both on the site and in threads like this.
For good reviews I used to refer to a site called animeondvd. Some guy with an awful lot of expendable income named Chris Beveridge bought up almost every DVD and reviewed it quite professionally, and I felt his scores were pretty fair. I think it was sold or absorbed into another site, because his reviews show up here.
This is an example of his reviews.
This is an example of his reviews.
Yeah, he sold his site a while back and worked for them for a while. These days he runs/writes the still-covers-anime-but-less-anime-specific Fandom Post.
Chris Beveridge sold AnimeOnDVD to Mania. While presumably a sound business move, it was a terrible artistic one - no-one had ever heard of Mania, no-one could actually read the reviews as the front end is so terrible, and eventually even he gave up and set up Fandom Post instead.
EDIT: beaten! We had some good times on those old forums... DiGi are you still active on either Mania or Fandom Post's boards? I kind of fell off them after I couldn't afford to buy DVDs for a couple of years and never really went back.
KO Traveling Hobo
Member
Ah, I didn't mean to dump on ANN as a whole as my experiences with it are limited to the database(good stuff) and whatever gets posted or discussed here on GAF.
And his questionable delivery is getting him free publicity here and likely elsewhere, so there's that.
I used to lurk that site too. Even submitted an easter egg! It sold me on some weird stuff and introduced me to other things like Blue Submarine No. 6 and was my first exposure to Princess Nine.
Unfortunately, even the db is sadly suspect from what I've read on here.
amishpriest99
Member
I'll certainly agree to your point that the content is what matters in writing reviews; I probably should have said a more favorable scoring towards Fate/Zero rather than a better review. What gets me about ANN is the (at least at times) condescending and pretentious tone they take, which extends to Zac and the ANNCast (though they were better about it in the most recent episode).
Yeah I think his review (plus the fact that it was really fucking cute) is what sold me on Popotan initially. He really loved that series.
I still visit occasionally, though more to talk about iM@S news than anime. I'll sporadically post about shows I'm particularly interested in, but there's a handful of strong personalities who tend to dominate discussion a little too much these days whom I don't always agree with but don't really want to get into an argument with either. I'm not really into anime for that kind of stress ^^;
KO Traveling Hobo
Member
Still pretty handy, though.
I ended up buying a particular dvd player that was recommended on that site so often due to how well it handled interlaced stuff. Strange times.
Was it an OPPO?
It is but I wish I didn't feel the need to crosscheck info.
It was some modestly priced Pioneer model with a particular chipset or something. I used to get compliments all the time on how nice stuff looked. Wanted to gouge my eyes out when it died and I was left with a PS2 for dvd needs.
Joe Molotov
Member
ANN is a good database, but a database can't draw conclusions.
I used to rely on a built in DVD player in my old TV. It always skipped and crashed on those pathetically poorly manufactured early anime discs and generally drove me crazy.
darkside31337
Tomodachi wa Mahou
Databases are also boring as heck and insufferable to listen to.
Theonik
Member
It's not even that good a database, their staff lists tend to have errors and it takes them forever to fix them!
It's about as comprehensive as it'll get for non-jp fans. Flawed, but it's all we have for now.
Jex
Member
We need such informative reviews even more now than ever before!
Why not make something better?
It was really bad back then if I remember right. Rainbows everywhere. Trigun was especially bad for that.
They don't always get names right
They don't always get all the credits
Sometimes they add extra ones by mistake
At some point, they merged all entries for a name down to one entry, so for particular common names there can be three or four people who all share a single entry
For shows, all the impacts on shows that the above causes, plus they're very bad with show and episode titles.
- Status