Support NeoGAF

[BootsLoader]

Xbox and Bethesda by far the best press. Nintendo is 2nd because nobody else showed anything.

 

[swaffles23]

Probably Xbox because a lot of the 3rd party stuff looks good

 

[arvfab]

When the industry is holding an industry wide event for the fans, you have to show up. It's like not showing up to your friends birthday party when you know everyone else is gonna be there. People are going to wonder why you didnt show up. Do you not like him? Are you making a statement? Do you think you are above them?

I dont think it matters that ratchet came out this week. That has nothing to do with holding an yearly conference that they have held since 1994. They have been releasing games in summer forever and they still showed up every time. GT3 was a summer 2001 release. MGS4 was either June or July. TLOU, TLOU2, GoT. It means nothing when it comes to holding press conferences where they show people that the investment they have made and lets be honest, the console is an investment. We all know that this thing is not worth $500 at launch, but it will be by the end of the gen. But as part of that silent agreement, we assume that they would show up to these industry events and continue to sell us the future.

If they want to do things on their own. Fine. I am perfectly willing to wait a couple more weeks for their event.

I will use your analogy:
They GAVE you games (a gift for your friends party), the've shown something BEFORE E3 (inviting your friend for a drink because they won't make it to the party) and you don't know if you they are maybe organizing a surprise party.

Like last year, when they also skipped E3 and had an own event.

 

[Kagoshima_Luke]

Sony, for making the decision to not show up, because all of these presentations sucked.

 

[STARSBarry]

Take Two and there bold use of a Zoom Meeting where they lectured the audience about how much better people they are than you.

This is the kind of content I watch E3 for.

 

[Hitchyhero]

Sony because now that BOTW 2 is not coming in 2021 they can slot in some Horizon Forbidden West as a solid 2021 Fall title XD....

I would say XBOX/Nintendo were about equal maybe slight edge to XBOX if im being honest
Square I was initially pretty tough on but they would probably be next after.

Lol Sony fanboys are hilarious. Even when Sony don't attend E3 people proclaim they won.

Or people can't bare that they can't say that it wasnt Sony so have to say no one won.

 

[Supermjmt12]

Xbox won by a large margin, the fact that Nintendo didn't show off Metroid Prime 4 or Bayonetta 3 is really concerning. Capcom, Ubisoft and Square Enix was terrible

 

[Deleted member 471617]

For me personally, easily Microsoft. Ubisoft was second. Everything else was meh or worse for me.

 

[SlimySnake]

I will use your analogy:
They GAVE you games (a gift for your friends party), the've shown something BEFORE E3 (inviting your friend for a drink because they won't make it to the party) and you don't know if you they are maybe organizing a surprise party.

Like last year, when they also skipped E3 and had an own event.

lol I will buy that.

But no one likes surprise parties. Just tell me you will throw me a party two weeks from today and I will be ok. MS did that last year. THey announced a summer event after E3 was cancelled. It's just common courtesy to keep your fanbase in the loop especially since they knew Sony was holding a conference right around E3 time.

 

[rapid32.5]

xbox, only proves that MS scored with Bethesda since all third parties shows were abysmal and it's not gonna change in near future. 3rd parties don't take risks anymore as they used to., game budgets go up. we either see old games being remastered or dumb sequels that don't make sense.

 

[Tripolygon]

In terms of overall presentation and content Microsoft had the better showing. Nintendo came a distant second and everyone else just judged behind.

 

[Kamina]

They all sucked balls, but Nintendo and MS didnt do as bad as most oders.
Personal Highlights:
Metroid Dread
Elden Ring

 

[DenchDeckard]

Xbox by default. They didnt treat E3 with disdain. They showed up and treated their audience with respect. I dont think they did a great job demo'ing their games. Too many trailers, not enough gameplay, but they were professional and had a decent lineup. Cant say that about anyone else.

Nintendo direct was also not bad by any means, but it's not for me. So Xbox wins imo.

Sony refusing to show up is straight up disrespectful to the gaming industry and their own fanbase. Not to mention the userbase that spent $500 buying their hard to find console. Half of us probably had to suck a dick just to get a hold of one, and they dont think we even deserve an E3 showing. If there werent rumors of a summer showcase in a couple of weeks, it wouldve been infuriating. That said, Horizon Forbidden West wouldve probably been my game of the show if it was shown this week. So there is that.

If I had to rank games.

5) Metroid Dread - It's 2D but it's from Nintendo. Lets face it, it will be fantastic.
4) Replaced - Amazing looking combat this is what 2D games should be.
3) Zelda BoTW 2 - only 1 minute trailer but the gameplay looked fresh and you could finally do something with those abilities.
2) Forza Horizon 5 - Insane Photorealistic next gen trackside detail. DriveClub on steroids. Amazing.
1) Avatar - Probably the only true next gen game we saw at E3 apart from the criminally short Starfield teaser. Absolutely jaw dropping scale.

My lol emoji is out of respect for your Sony "had to suck a dick comment" the rest of the post I also agree with.

Ms had a solid show and just needs some small tweaks to future shows and more gameplay and they will be absolutely god tier at delivering conferences.

Sony should have been here, just seems shitty as fuck passing it up.

 

[kingpotato]

Xbox didn't bring down gaf...

Nintendid

 

[Fredrik]

Xbox won, with a huge margin. More specifically, Gamepass subscribers won.

Just watched the Nintendo show and not even a new sidescrolling Metroid could save it, everything looked 10 years old, or more, I don’t understand the popularity of this hybrid strategy they’re going with, I think it’s awful.

 

[Mabdia]

Koei Tecmo.

 

[yurinka]

No Switch Pro and no big game announcements at Nintendo. Forza Horizon looking awesome as the best E3 game, they sold many GPs, no but all non-Forza 1st party announcements were CGs, no studio purchases, no MS Kojima game, and Halo even if didn't look bad, it didn't look awesome. No hyping big announcements from Square, Ubisoft, Capcom etc.

Sony wasn't at the E3 and will continue as the company with more green metacritic exclusives released since last E3 and with more announced to be released from now until the next E3. And even without going to E3 got 2nd party games from Kojima and the CoDBO guys. So they are the ones in the best postiion after E3, and if we don't count them because weren't at E3, then MS won it.

 

[Shelookdlvl18]

It's not Sonygaf they say.
It's a persecution complex they say.
First page= 5 answered Sony had the best E3.

You literally couldn't make this shit up. Lol

 

[graywolf323]

Overall, Xbox showed me the most things I'm interested in playing - and the fact that most of the stuff they showed was included in the subscription I already have was great.

Nintendo a close second.

I'm like this but flipped, Nintendo showed the most things I'm interested in playing and Xbox was a close second since the most of the stuff shown that did interest me is included in the subscription I already have

It's not Sonygaf they say.
It's a persecution complex they say.
First page= 5 answered Sony had the best E3.

You literally couldn't make this shit up. Lol

I don't see how your post disproves a persecution complex? so freaking what if 5 posts said Sony out of 50 posts on the first page?

 

[ValiantTraveler]

Lol who the hell voted for Square. They must be really excited for Guardians of the Galaxy.

That was a weak-ass E3, but Nintendo won it simply by showing up with a few games people are actually interested in.

 

[Yoboman]

We haven't had Bandai Namco? Obviously it's just about Elden Ring for them but it was obviously the most exciting game of the show, hopefully we see more at their event

Of that list, Nintendo for me but it was pretty weak overall

 

[Garani]

Nintendo Conference was okay.

Xbox conference wins E3 since they have the most coming and honestly sold me on series x.

PlayStation doesn't win anything since they haven't had any event for whatever dumb reason, even on their own.

 

[jshackles]

We haven't had Bandai Namco? Obviously it's just about Elden Ring for them but it was obviously the most exciting game of the show, hopefully we see more at their event

Of that list, Nintendo for me but it was pretty weak overall

Namco show was confirmed to just have info on their new Dark Pictures Anthology game, House of Ashes

 

[Damigos]

Laugh all you want, but actually Sony won. E3 had another shitty year and Sony was right to avoid it.
From those that participated, Devolver Digital won

 

[sublimit]

Yup. Thank God for this man.

 

[SJRB]

Looking at my Steam Wishlist I guess indies won?

I added like 15 titles to my wishlist over the last couple of days.

 

[Dr. Samuel Hayden]

Microsoft and Nintendo are tied for me. They both win because they actually showed games and didn't just fuck around with a bunch of stupid bullshit like all the others on that list did.

 

[qiqiqiiq]

Nintendo announced Advance Wars, a new Metroid Game, and Mario Party Superstars that's 3 games I'm interested in, at Microsoft conference only Psychonauts 2 and Halo multiplayer have my interest, and one of those is multiplatform.

 

[kungfuian]

The winners were Fromsoftware and Elden Ring and it's not even close.

 

[Beelzebubs]

As always, the correct answer is Devolver Digital.

 

[Spidey Fan]

CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS CHAOS, I don't know who can top that.

 

[Astral Dog]

Metroid Dread and Elden Ring

 

[Vagswarm]

Definitely Microsoft. They have the kind of games I have the most interest in, and Halo's multiplayer was a nice surprise. Battlefield is the best looking game that was shown (not graphically).

 

[INC]

verizon

 

[SlimeGooGoo]

.

 

[DigitalScrap]

Intellivision Amico. But only because the Atari VCS didn’t do a show.

 

[DryvBy]

I know who didn't.

Take 2. They set the bar so low, Sony even placed.

 

[McCarth]

Frankly no one "won". But if you have to pick someone it's MS easily.

 

[S0ULZB0URNE]

What make a thread before the biggest of the 3 even has it's show?
trolling?

 

[El Pistolero]

Fatal Frame is coming to XOne/Ps4 and XSX/PS5, that hurts Nintendo's showing a bit since people were screaming about it as a Nintendo exclusive earlier.

Wait, it's coming to all platforms? Well, I'm surprised...

 

[KiteGr]

I found this year's E3 quite weak.
I would say the popular choice would be Microsoft/Bethesda, but that doesn't say much.

For me it was Limited Run...

 

[Kagero]

Neogaf isn't biased they said....

Someone should make a poll.

You’re a fanboy of what console?
1. nintendo
2. Sony
3. Microsoft

I legit want to know if Gaf is biased

 

[GymWolf]

Stadia.

 

[graywolf323]

Neogaf isn't biased they said....

dude the poll has over 50% voting for Xbox, why are you focusing on less than 10 posts of some PlayStation fanboys?

Someone should make a poll.

You’re a fanboy of what console?
1. nintendo
2. Sony
3. Microsoft

I legit want to know if Gaf is biased

Sega because the Dreamcast 2 will happen dammit!

 

[Camreezie]

Worst E3 I've yet to see. Dont even think it will be back next time now. Nintendo was a little stronger than Microsoft imo

1.Nintendo
2. Xbox
3.Ubisoft
4. Square Enix
5. Capcom
6. Bandai Namco
7. Take Two

 

[ZehDon]

Microsoft were the only ones who brought an E3 show to E3. Everyone brought junk and scraps and tried to pretend they didn’t.
Fortunately, Microsoft’s show was actually pretty decent, their personal best in years. Everyone else… for shame.

 

[Impotaku]

Lol you mean a pile of cgi trailers yeah, total e3 A game that.

 

[Nocturno999]

The biggest loser was Sony:

1. Not showing.
2. MS announcing that PS5 isn't getting any Bethesda game
3. MS saying GP on every game announcement while Sony keeps betting on 70 dlls per game.

 

[clem84]

Take Two isn't in the options?

I voted Xbox. Nintendo's showing was good, but it was more or less what I expected. MS surprised me. There was so much cool stuff shown. Every game available through gamepass. I like where they're going.

 

[MvCSpiderman]

What make a thread before the biggest of the 3 even has it's show?
trolling?

?

Microsoft and Nintendo already went.