GaviotaGrande
Banned
No comparison to PC? NOW THAT'S DISSAPOINTING. Digital Foundry = console shills confirmed.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF - Assassin's Creed Valhalla: PS5 vs Xbox Series X/ Series S Next-Gen Comparison!
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Ouch.
ethomaz
Banned
Well least you know what you are buying beforehand.... a capped machine.
I believe it did really fine in the comparison...
And it is not 1080p... "1188p to around 1656p".
It is running great in resolution for the hardware specs.
Maybe 900-1080p it can reach 60fps.
MisterXDTV
Member
Ouch.
BUT VRR.......
IShowUBasics
Member
There is a reason microsoft had to change "most powerful console" to "most powerful xbox".
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
Just having some fun friend. And no, I didn't spend nearly any time on that obviously. We already knew what's in the video so it doesn't change anything. It's still way to early to draw any sweeping conclusions, but have your fun and I will have mine.You have been spending all your time making this when you could of been watching the video, Then again i totally understand why you don't want to watch it totally, it's bad news bud, really bad news for you. haha
I guess you got to try get your pot shot in, before the flood arrives.
GaviotaGrande
Banned
Did they? Seriously? If yes then ultimate LOL. Any proof of this?
danstar
Neo Member
Just seconds before that comparison they say the only differences you'll see is due to time of day. That comparison is just to prove their point.OOOFF! DOF is less quality on ps5.
edit : its not about the dark vs light there is clearly more banding, more blobbiness in the ps5 screen. thats a lesser DOF setting.
Last edited:
BlueXImpulse
Banned
Ouch.
That's not a CPU limited scenario, in this scene the XSX GPU itself can't keep up at those resolutions.
Shakka43
Member
Gotta go for any tiny bit of W's you can get these days...
sircaw
Banned
Knitted Knight
Banned
Kitty was probably right all along?
Low Moral Fibre
Member
Guess I should have waited a week and got it on PS5!
I noticed immediately how horrible the frame rate was with a torch out on XSX even by eye.
Maybe they will improve it on XSX but I'm not going to hold out any hope. It's perfectly playable on XSX but you'd be crazy to choose it over PS5 if you have both consoles.
I noticed immediately how horrible the frame rate was with a torch out on XSX even by eye.
Maybe they will improve it on XSX but I'm not going to hold out any hope. It's perfectly playable on XSX but you'd be crazy to choose it over PS5 if you have both consoles.
ikbalCO
Member
Ouch @ series X version. Especially during the torch parts. There aren’t a lot of tearing like in that indoor scene but suprise effect of it really ruined it for me.
And this is a game with heavy xbox marketing deal.
When it comes to PS5 side, all praises belong to Cerny imo.
Obviously he designed a killer architecture that allows developer gain more performance from a lower spec system.
And this is a game with heavy xbox marketing deal.
When it comes to PS5 side, all praises belong to Cerny imo.
Obviously he designed a killer architecture that allows developer gain more performance from a lower spec system.
Captain Hero
The Spoiler Soldier
Damn.. the X is trying so hard to be steady at 60fps in many shots. Still both looking good but fuck me with that screen tearing on the X!
The conclusion is .. you wanna feel nextgen? PS5 is doing it better.
The conclusion is .. you wanna feel nextgen? PS5 is doing it better.
Agnostic2020
Member
Ouch.
yikes.
IShowUBasics
Member
they changed the slogan on their website. but my "they had to" was obviously a joke
Popup
Member
... and then proceed to make images further demonstrating how the point Digital Foundry was trying to make was lost on them..
Andodalf
Banned
Clearly something very wrong with how the Xbox preforms here, it's way off the other titles we've seen, however few. I wonder if it is the SDK/APIs, or is something to do with the hardware interacting with this engine. Looks like I'll be buying the PS version of a AC game since liberation, lol.
Gaf taught me that games can be completely judged by a single zoomed in and cropped frame tho?
Gaf taught me that games can be completely judged by a single zoomed in and cropped frame tho?
Last edited:
Vognerful
Member
I found someone on reddit saying that the performance issues on xbox series x are similar to this on pc. If that is the case, would that be an engine comparability issue?
Nevertheless, the videos I saw online of this game looks beautiful still on xbox but I am still not sure if I should buy it now or wait for sales.
Nevertheless, the videos I saw online of this game looks beautiful still on xbox but I am still not sure if I should buy it now or wait for sales.
FranXico
Member
To be fair, other analyses had already said as much.
alucard0712_rus
Member
What we've learnt so far:
- Tflops is not all the story
- GPU clocks matters
- API and dev. tools matters
- Tflops is not all the story
- GPU clocks matters
- API and dev. tools matters
RoboFu
One of the green rats
Okay last post because I see this going on and on and on.. look below at the background grass. its way blurred out. some parts barely show on the ps5 version. Thats a lesser DOF setting. even the parts that have the same brightness or shadow.
Last edited:
Agnostic2020
Member
Its a trend now. Ps5 outperforms xsx in cpu bound tasks
Bitmap Frogs
Mr. Community
Well, there it is.
Black Flag settled it 7 years ago, now another crossgen assassin’s creed does it t.
Black Flag settled it 7 years ago, now another crossgen assassin’s creed does it t.
FunkMiller
Member
That screen tearing at the door entrance on Series X is fucking appalling...
Yep. That's the GIF alright.
Ouch.
Yep. That's the GIF alright.
Last edited:
Agnostic2020
Member
He said he looked at the file setting and they are identical. Now we have you, an arm chair analyst saying otherwise cause u r upset?Okay last post because i see htis going on and on and on.. look below at the background grass. its way blurred out. some parts barely show on the ps5 version. Thats a lesser DOF setting. eve the parts that have the same brightness or shadow.
Same CPU for what? Run at 30fps? MS said a 1440p and up to 120fps. But dynamic res and 30fps?
mansoor1980
Gold Member
why is this happenning the TF differrence shud be able compensate for the lack of good tools.
Donarudo
Member
Ouch.
Alex says that in that scene the XSX is performing 15% worse than PS5. But from the comparison in the video it's more than 15%. 60fps on PS5 compared to 48fps on XSX means the XSX is performing 20% worse, or the PS5 is performing 25% better in that scene.
ethomaz
Banned
That is different scene... you can see the shadow of the tree on his head.Okay last post because i see htis going on and on and on.. look below at the background grass. its way blurred out. some parts barely show on the ps5 version. Thats a lesser DOF setting. even the parts that have the same brightness or shadow.
In simple terms the time of the day is not the same in both pics... there is more cloud in Xbox version (due the different time of day) too that affect the shadows.
Last edited:
sojuwarrior
Member
I am just echoing what was said in the video.
If you watched it, even DF called it disappointing at 7:05 mark lol
Vaztu
Member
Ouch.
From that calculation alone, PS5 is performing 25-30% more than XSX
Cherrypepsi
Member
Okay last post because I see this going on and on and on.. look below at the background grass. its way blurred out. some parts barely show on the ps5 version. Thats a lesser DOF setting. even the parts that have the same brightness or shadow.
seriously, you are really imagining things
Vae_Victis
Banned
OOOFF! DOF is less quality on ps5.
edit : its not about the dark vs light there is clearly more banding, more blobbiness in the ps5 screen. thats a lesser DOF setting.
Since in the first image the background is brighter than her arms it overtakes them, while in the second her arms are brighter than the background so they appear larger.
You understand that in a defocus by definition the brighter portions of the picture override the darker ones, right? That this is literally how a defocus works, right?
I don't have to explain to you how fucking LIGHT works, right?
Last edited:
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
"- Resolution side, looks like SeX and PS5 run both at dynamic 4k with the 1440p as minimum (6:28)
- The max resolution from SeX and PS5 are 4k, but none system archieve by the time or not spotted "
Dynamic 4k.
can't achieve 4k...
Nani?
...
Dynamic whatever...
- The max resolution from SeX and PS5 are 4k, but none system archieve by the time or not spotted "
Dynamic 4k.
can't achieve 4k...
Nani?
...
Dynamic whatever...
Andodalf
Banned
They take averages of scenes, not the lowest single frame.
Mr. PlayStation
Member
Ouch.
I think it dropped 12 frames on Series X because the game wants you to move a little slow? like the video gif on the left you can see Eivor going too close to another npc. So it's probably a specific tool set that Xbox has given to the devs to reduce frames to maintain player movement in the game world without hitting against each other?
Last edited:
ToadMan
Member
Well you can’t spell Ubisoft without QC!
Uh actually yes ...yes you can, there’s no QC in Ubisoft. My mistake.
Bitmap Frogs
Mr. Community
The Xbox S is a pretty bad deal. Thing can barely do above 1080p at 30fps on a crossgen game. Once the heavy hitters that run at 1440p/30 on the X start hitting god knows how they’ll look on the S.
Stilton Disco
Member
XSX and PS5 are both Beasts, but the XSS is clearly not the 'true' next gen system MS sold it as.
Half the frame rate, a fraction of the resolution, yet still with frame drops and noticeably worse effects.
Really hope it never becomes successful. Let the struggle console slowly die off and hopefully developing for it will be dropped as a requirement.
Half the frame rate, a fraction of the resolution, yet still with frame drops and noticeably worse effects.
Really hope it never becomes successful. Let the struggle console slowly die off and hopefully developing for it will be dropped as a requirement.