Support NeoGAF

[Pelao]

I didn't like Alan Wake 1, dropped Quantum Break and thought Control was nothing to write home about. I haven't really liked any of Remedy's post-Max Payne games, so I didn't even bother with Alan Wake 2. I don't care how much the critics praise it, I'm not going to bother trying it until it hits Gamepass or whatever.

 

[SnapShot]

That's a bummer, it's one of my favorite 2023 releases. I hope they know what they are doing with this Epic exclusivity thing. Hopefully it'll sell as well or even more than Control after they release it outside EGS.

 

[Giallo Corsa]

Allan is rarer but still used in the English language.

Allan (given name) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[rofif]

Is Alan Wake even in the game? It kind of looked like they replaced him with a black woman. You know, pulling a Disney. Or if he is in the game, they kill him off in the first act like another game everybody loves.

Even if he is in the game, I only thought the first game was ok and I think I got it for free or deeply discounted. I would only play it once it comes to Steam and is on sale or is free on Epic. So it will be a while if ever.

Yeah it's like 60:40. 60% being for Saga

 

[adamsapple]

Lol what, most people still buy physical.

No, we're a dying breed.

Physical Games Represented Just 4% of Sales for PlayStation Last Quarter

The only category down year-on-year

www.pushsquare.com

 

[KungFucius]

I just started playing it seriously. Loving it like I did every remedy game.

 

[Krappadizzle]

If anyone wants to buy it for me on Epic, I will no longer say I'm waiting for Steam to pick it up. I really like the series, so much so that I bought the first one twice on the 360 after relase simply because I liked the collectors edition.

I really don't even have a problem with Epic, I've bought quite a few games on it. It's just at times like this, I still have BG3 to finish, Alien: Dark Descent, Cyberpunk DLC, RE4make... I just have so much, and then I'd like to check out Ready or Not's latest update.... I just have too much to play that the annoyance of fracturing my library even more in the eventual time I might get to check out Alan Wake 2...Well, by then, it'll probably have gone on a significant sale, so there's just no reason to buy it now.

It's such a stacked holiday season right now that you have to have all possible avenues going for people to consider you over other choices, and other than fans like me that probably like the original more than most, it's an uphill battle. But if the alternative is the game not being made at all, I'm very glad that Remedy has gone down the path they chose and really do look forward to checking it out. Eventually.

I just started playing it seriously. Loving it like I did every remedy game.

I've loved nearly every Remedy game since Max Payne....

But let's all collectively continue to forget the game they released before Control. That one sucked.

 

[The Cockatrice]

well 2 different genres, AW2 is survival horror and RE4R is looter shooter ^^

no way someone legit has this idiotic take

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

FMV gaming needs to stay in the grave where it rightly belongs

 

[rofif]

No, we're a dying breed.

Physical Games Represented Just 4% of Sales for PlayStation Last Quarter

The only category down year-on-year

www.pushsquare.com

It’s hard to say. It might be 4% when considering all genes sold. Even cheap psn shovelware or ps+ stuff.
What is more important what is the divide for ps only games that release same day on disc and psn.
Like… no way is 4% with AAA games like sm2 or god of war

 

[Skifi28]

FMV gaming needs to stay in the grave where it rightly belongs

Sure, but what does that have to do with anything?

 

[Krappadizzle]

well 2 different genres, AW2 is survival horror and RE4R is looter shooter ^^

Why would you consider RE4R a looter shooter out of curiosity?

 

[Sushi_Combo]

Because AW is a niche game, nobody in the mainstream cares or even knows its existence.

 

[Killer8]

Not releasing on Steam was a huge sales mistake although it was understandable given that Epic bankrolled and published the game. They weren't going to pass on the opportunity to make it exclusive to lure people to EGS. People holding out for an eventual Steam release might be waiting forever.

I'm still bitter about no physical release but I doubt that would have contributed so much to sales figures that it could turn a failure into a success.

The original Alan Wake was also a sales flop at first but reached about 4.5 million eventually with the PC port, substantial bundling and holiday sales. I just don't think the series has nearly as much appeal as people think. The remaster didn't meet sales targets either, supposedly.

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

Sure, but what does that have to do with anything?

Theres FMV in alan wake 2. The reason why im not playing it. Devs need to be original and not go back to a time in gaming that isnt necessary.

 

[Hero of Spielberg]

This on half price on Epic with a 33% coupon as well bringing it down to about $25 AUD ($16 USD) ... do I pull the trigger? Or RDR2 for $14 AUD ($9 USD) ... help me GAF

 

[Skifi28]

Theres FMV in alan wake 2. The reason why im not playing it. Devs need to be original and not go back to a time in gaming that isnt necessary.

An FMV game from ages ago and a regular game that has a few live action cutscenes is not the same, but do what you like.

 

[Alexios]

Theres FMV in alan wake 2. The reason why im not playing it. Devs need to be original and not go back to a time in gaming that isnt necessary.

3D graphics aren't much newer than FMV so I guess you aren't playing many games nowadays. Waiting for that 4D revolution of which you can only play a single game before it's all the same tripe I guess.

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

3D graphics aren't much newer than FMV so I guess you aren't playing many games nowadays.

Nice edit to save yourself but luckily i quoted your original message

I mean if youre gonna quote me to try to be witty, at least compare apples to apples.

Live action and FMV are the exact same thing. Both use real people, not sure why this is a difficult concept to grasp.

Hey enjoy what you want....i see live action/FMV in a game and it immediately screams to me as low class and no originality

 

[Last Hearth]

I think one of my biggest complaints is that it all feel so mundane and they pretty much ignore stuff from the first game and American Nightmare. Sam Lake even admitted he forgot a lot of stuff about the first two games and uses Wikipedia to try to keep everything consistent.

A good example for me is how they mention alien intelligences and lovecraftian beings that supposedly dwell in the Dark Place in the first two games. There's no weird creatures or no appearances by any kind of lovecraftian type being and instead it's just a bunch of shadows. I guess you could count the Dark Presence that only shows up a couple times as one of these beings but all it shows up as is a warp in the air.

They had a chance to really do something interesting with the game and instead pretty much ignore the really interesting parts of the first two games.

This proving this was not a passion project but a cash grab.

 

[transformer]

Shame if this game doesn’t sell well. Best game I’ve played all year.

 

[Alexios]

Nice edit to save yourself but luckily i quoted your original message

I mean if youre gonna quote me to try to be witty, at least compare apples to apples.

Live action and FMV are the exact same thing. Both use real people, not sure why this is a difficult concept to grasp.

Hey enjoy what you want....i see live action/FMV in a game and it immediately screams to me as low class

Not sure what you think my point was but with or without the edit it's exactly the same. I meant real-time 3D graphics obviously, as I'm sure you're playing games using this tired old feature that is in fact about as old as FMV if not older but Alan Wake 2 is where you draw the line, lol.

 

[Skifi28]

Live action and FMV are the exact same thing. Both use real people, not sure why this is a difficult concept to grasp.

Hey enjoy what you want....i see live action/FMV in a game and it immediately screams to me as low class

When talking about FMV games people usually mean games that had little to no gameplay and were comprised almost excusively from just video. Comparing that to something like Alan Wake is silly to say the least, it has as much in common with those games as any other game that breaks up gameplay with cutscenes. Whether the cutscenes are static images, or polygons or actual video is irrelevant, still has nothing to do with the fmv genre.

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

When talking about FMV games people usually mean games that had little to no gameplay and were comprised almost excusively from just video. Comparing that to something like Alan Wake is silly to say the least, it has as much in common with those games as any other game that breaks up gameplay with cutscenes.

Respectfully disagree....i dont want to see real world people when i game, regardless of the context.

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

Not sure what you think my point was but with or without the edit it's exactly the same. I meant real-time 3D graphics obviously, as I'm sure you're playing games using this tired old feature that is in fact about as old as FMV if not older but Alan Wake 2 is where you draw the line, lol.

Nowhere near a comparable game type but you do you

 

[Alexios]

Nowhere near a comparable game type
but you do you

I didn't mention game types anywhere, nor is Alan Wake 2 a different game type than something like RE because it happens to have some live action scenes which you literally also said is just the same thing as a FMV (for all the wrong reasons as no, FMV doesn't have to use real people and every live action is a FMV but not every FMV is a live action). GTAVI having some live action cut scene tucked away somewhere (or more prominent) wouldn't suddenly beome a different game type. Loathing seeing real people is a whole different deal to what you initially implied about originality.

Must have hated all MGS games I guess.

 

[Majima Everywhere System]

Didn’t seem like a good gameplay type game. Control didn’t have exceptionally well done story telling…very stop and go with all the outdated log based story telling.

Between those two factors, you can’t really convince me this game is worth a shot at more than $30 bucks or if I think I’m in the mood.

 

[S0ULZB0URNE]

well 2 different genres, AW2 is survival horror and RE4R is looter shooter ^^

What's up with these dumb posts?

 

[Portugeezer]

Small indie digital only game.

 

[sloppyjoe_gamer]

I didn't mention game types anywhere, nor is Alan Wake 2 a different game type than something like RE because it happens to have some live action scenes which you literally also said is just the same thing as a FMV (for all the wrong reasons as no, FMV doesn't have to use real people and every live action is a FMV but not every FMV is a live action). GTAVI having some live action cut scene tucked away somewhere (or more prominent) wouldn't suddenly beome a different game type. Loathing seeing real people is a whole different deal to what you initially implied about originality.

Must have hated all MGS games I guess.

Jesus Christ the number of times you edit your responses after the fact to try to make yourself look smarter or to get one over on someone is ridiculous. I already said you do you....off to the ignore list you go buffoon

 

[Skifi28]

What's up with these dumb posts?

You're just mad that legendary handgun with +30% crit didn't drop for you from a barrel in RE4.

 

[S0ULZB0URNE]

Game is great, gaf is full of Spiderman 2 loving, chips and dip eating dullards.

You saying SM2 isn't good?

You're just mad that legendary handgun with +30% crit didn't drop for you from a barrel in RE4.

You mean he's mad as I know RE4 is the superior game.

 

[Morrie’s wig shop]

It’s hard to say. It might be 4% when considering all genes sold. Even cheap psn shovelware or ps+ stuff.
What is more important what is the divide for ps only games that release same day on disc and psn.
Like… no way is 4% with AAA games like sm2 or god of war

I’m thinking here in the US….. I can’t think of one person that buys physical anymore and I mean it’s been years.
I have yet to stick a disc into my PS5 or XSX
Now that I think about it actually, both my brothers will buy physical only on the Switch and that’s all to do with space.

I would love to see a comprehensive list by country physical vs digital.

 

[kikii]

What's up with these dumb posts?

opinions helloo opinions ^^

You mean he's mad as I know RE4 is the superior game.

im not mad, u seem to be mad

 

[EDMIX]

This on half price on Epic with a 33% coupon as well bringing it down to about $25 AUD ($16 USD) ... do I pull the trigger? Or RDR2 for $14 AUD ($9 USD) ... help me GAF

If you've never played RDR2, that is a must play first. imho

 

[StereoVsn]

This on half price on Epic with a 33% coupon as well bringing it down to about $25 AUD ($16 USD) ... do I pull the trigger? Or RDR2 for $14 AUD ($9 USD) ... help me GAF

At those prices, get both.

 

[Hestar69]

Its getting a lot of critique praise, but i thought the game had a very generic story, great direction, poor combat, and a simple premise.

I'm not sure why its so beloved by some, i figured it wouldn't sell well.

You pretty sure your talking about alan wake 2 and not your avatar ff16? that game was awful ( WORST ff game)

 

[Warablo]

Those type of games never sell well unless you are a Sony exclusive

 

[Hero of Spielberg]

At those prices, get both.

I like the way you think you smooth talker

 

[Sir Vilhelm]

Best game this year, absolutely a beast. Enjoyed the hell out of it.

 

[tmlDan]

You pretty sure your talking about alan wake 2 and not your avatar ff16? that game was awful ( WORST ff game)

don't get all defensive, it'll be okay.

At least FF16 is playable and fun, it's not my GOTY but it's also not insufferable to play like AW2 is. Jank ass shooting and movement.

 

[Rayderism]

Well, damn Jackie, I'm not gonna buy another copy!

 

[semiconscious]

opinions helloo opinions ^^

friend:

Looter shooter (also called loot shooter) is a subgenre of shooter video games that features role-playing elements and procedurally generated weapons and equipment. A main goal of games in the genre is obtaining better items through grinding for random drops, typically with rarities ranging from common to legendary...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Looter_shooter

describing resident evil 4 remake as a looter shooter is the equivalent of calling super mario bros wonder a survival horror. it's simply, & objectively, incorrect. it's not an 'opinion'...

 

[F31 Leopard]

Well duh, epic exclusive and no physical release on consoles

Once I heard there was no physical copies I no longer cared about the release date. To be honest I didn't even know it already released digitally lol.

 

[Maori]

Not a good game imo.

It hides it's many flaws under the pretense of "artistic flare", but at it's core it's a game with an identity crisis; Should have been an adventure game ala Heavy Rain.

If it's a storyline-game with limited gamplay and a lot of walking and seeing, you might as well just turn it into one, instead of giving us just a taste of a few different genres, all wrapped up in a lot of walking and a dubious storyline at best.

 

[Terenty]

T

Must have hated all MGS games I guess.

There's a huge fucking difference between a cheap FMV and a cool in game cutscene ala MGS on every level, don't be ridiculous

 

[KiteGr]

I buy physical on consoles and digital on Steam.

 

[whatup]

Woke bullshit tends not to sell very well generally.....see movies,comics etc.

Just beat the game. What was woke about it?

 

[Zathalus]

It’s hard to say. It might be 4% when considering all genes sold. Even cheap psn shovelware or ps+ stuff.
What is more important what is the divide for ps only games that release same day on disc and psn.
Like… no way is 4% with AAA games like sm2 or god of war

It's not 4% of games sold, it's 4% of revenue. Digital games is 21% of revenue. So physical games are actually 20% of all games sold. It's likely a bit higher as Sony looses some revenue on physical games due to vendor overhead and second hand sales. Probably around a quarter to a third of all games sold are physical. Not quite as bad, but it is still a shrinking market.

 

[Alan Wake]

Someone doesn't get out to shop.

Look at the split of digital vs physical sales on PlayStation and Xbox, as well as Switch, over time.