• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PS4 to PS5 transition will take 3 years, more cross-gen games coming - SIE VP Hideaki Nishino confirms.

THE DUCK

voted poster of the decade by bots
Some People here should relax.Why should Sony throw away 130 million PS4 players and they also have the right to be supported.They are not second class gamers only because you have the newer version of their console.Sony is doing the right and best thing,they are supporting PS5 with exclusives from the get go and the cross gen Titels are best played with better graphics on PS5.This way everyone is or should be happy PS4 and PS5 gamers.What Jim meant with we believe in generations is exsactly what Sony was always doing exclusives for newest console but older one won’t be left behind immediately.It would be extremely unfair for PS4 players when Sony would forget them as soon as the newest console would be out.Like i said everyone should relax PS5 gets lots of exclusives and the best versions to play.

That's all fair, and makes sense, but then why do some hardcore sony fans run around saying xbox series s is ruining next gen? You can't have it both ways.
 

ZywyPL

Banned
Some are missing that so far Astro's Playroom, Demon's Souls, Returnal, R&C Rift Apart, and even garbage like Godfall and Destruction Allstars are all next-gen only. Potentially God of War: Ragnarok and Grant Turismo 7 as well.



Trolls gonna troll.

But are they next-gen only due to actual technical limitations or just a business decision? So far other than R&C there isn't anything that couldn't have been ported on PS4 by dropping down from 4K60 to 1080p30, lower res textures, turning RT off and some LOD/draw distance adjustments. Even the recent HFW. None of the games represent even a single gameplay mechanism that exceeds Jaguar CPU capabilities, they are the same old engines, running the same old code, just coated with a nice make-up from the artist, CoD4 Remaster did the exact same thing years ago, and (rightfully) no one called it a next-gen title not previously possible. So yeah, the real next-gen will start once the engines are games are made from the ground up for those Zen2 CPUs, otherwise it'll all be just the same old games, just prettier, which was already achievable years ago by just buying a PC with more than a 2TF GPU.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
But are they next-gen only due to actual technical limitations or just a business decision? So far other than R&C there isn't anything that couldn't have been ported on PS4 by dropping down from 4K60 to 1080p30, lower res textures, turning RT off and some LOD/draw distance adjustments. Even the recent HFW. None of the games represent even a single gameplay mechanism that exceeds Jaguar CPU capabilities, they are the same old engines, running the same old code, just coated with a nice make-up from the artist, CoD4 Remaster did the exact same thing years ago, and (rightfully) no one called it a next-gen title not previously possible.

Demon's Souls could easily be ported to any platform, but then you need to drastically change the whole data streaming system and reinvent coding to work on slower systems. That means you can't be as aggressive with high quality assets as well. It's not always just game mechanics, it's also IQ.

Then with ultra speed traversal you need as fast as possible system to keep up, so something like Star Citizen would work great with PS5, XSX, PC's with NVMe m.2. Games that will take full advantage of the system are yet to be revealed/seen, with R&C being the obvious one so far but it's still just scratching the surface of the full potential with all the customizations inside PS5. Would GOW:R be the first true one? I doubt it, I think it'll be around 2023-2024 when all engines have matured and realized.

Development would be more expensive to design for both PS5 and PS4, but then PS4 huge player base pays that back much more. Also you need to justify your console that show off your system prowess. Designing for many platforms and for lesser system will always make a serious impact on the overall game design. Horizon FW although being wonderful it's clear that it's being held back by PS4.
 
Last edited:
That's all fair, and makes sense, but then why do some hardcore sony fans run around saying xbox series s is ruining next gen? You can't have it both ways.

I don't believe in the Series S holding back next gen, but PS4 is only going to get these big exclusives for the next year and will be phased out (which Xbox is also doing)

Series S is here to stay for the next decade

Not exactly the same thing
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
They're still making next gen exclusives though, we had one at launch, a 2nd one weeks ago and another is coming on June 11th

My only concern is, we probably won't see true huge next gen exclusives to the likes of horizon and god of war for years now. Let's think what the huge ps4 games were. Uncharted 4, last of us 2, God of War, spiderman and horizon. I can't think of any other first party Sony games that were as big as that. That's 5 games in 8 years. I imagine the next big naughty dog game is 4 to 5 years away. With all the talk leading up to launch I really expected Sony to trail blaze next gen. Then horizon got announced as cross gen, God of War will probs be next. I'm convinced that demons souls could run on a pro at 1080p 30fps. Not sure about ratchet with the portal tech.

I'm sure it will be fine but with all the talk of the incredible IO I just doubt it will be utilised fully anytime soon. Also with the push to pc, will it ever get used fully?

Just reading some more posts, there is absolutely no way anyone can Diss the series s and call it a mistake when the current gen is now being held back by 1tf legacy systems with mechanic hdds.
 
Last edited:

ReBurn

Gold Member
Err, both the xbox one s and digital were on for $199 multiple times during peak sales periods such as black Friday. Same with ps4. So your statement is completely wrong.
But no permanent price drops. If you didn't get one in the hour or less they were available you don't get one for that price.
 
Last edited:

bitbydeath

Member
Series S is here to stay for the next decade
gq4tnjC.png
 

jroc74

Phone reception is more important to me than human rights
I don't believe in the Series S holding back next gen, but PS4 is only going to get these big exclusives for the next year and will be phased out (which Xbox is also doing)

Series S is here to stay for the next decade

Not exactly the same thing
Thank you.

Cross gen holding next gen back hasnt disappeared. Some devs just seem to handle cross gen better than others...

Lol
Which exclusives are those?
Returnal and Ratchet and Clank are both PS5 exclusives in 2021 as is Gran Turismo 7 and Final Fantasy 16 in 2022 so.........
That post might as well been written 10 years ago. So much has changed since the consoles launched, lol.

It was before the consoles launched.
 
Last edited:

THE DUCK

voted poster of the decade by bots
But no permanent price drops. If you didn't get one in the hour or less they were available you don't get one for that price.

What? They were literally available in the hundreds of thousands at every major retailer.
Pretty much everyone who wanted one at that price got one, there were no stock issues at all.
 

Zeroing

Banned
Oh look, this thread turned into a console war.. who would had know?
somehow people need to write about Xbox “power” the Series S etc etc. the world doesn’t seem to care.

Also Jim did said in a interview there weren’t be any games launching for both PS4/5


anyway people keep up the fight!
 

Kokoloko85

Member
Thank you.

Cross gen holding next gen back hasnt disappeared. Some devs just seem to handle cross gen better than others...


That post might as well been written 10 years ago. So much has changed since the consoles launched, lol.

It was before the consoles launched.

I actually thought this was a new thread lol
 

lh032

I cry about Xbox and hate PlayStation.
wait you guys actually believe Sony will release PS5 only games while majority of people cant get a hold of a PS5, let alone the huge market of PS4!!???
 

mckmas8808

Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Xbox will have its own share of exclusives. Don’t try to change the narrative, we all heard the rhetoric, gamers thought that even Spider-Man was going to be PS5 only.

What narrative? You guys are seeing ghosts. The only problem people had with MS was that they stated that there wouldn't be ANY next-gen only games on the Xbox Series consoles for 1-2 years! THAT my friend was the ONLY issue.
 

e&e

Banned
PS5 already has exclusive games like Demon’s Souls, Returnal and Ratchet and FF7Remake DLC are weeks away.

What games are exclusive to Series X and don’t run on Series S or any other console?
Is that what Sony meant? Their games have to be exclusive to their platform and nothing else when talking about generations? 🤔
 

Gamer79

Predicts the worst decade for Sony starting 2022
I was having this discussion with a buddy of mine earlier. Until the PS5 is in most homes it's bad business to develop games only to cater to it. There are around 100million ps4 users and less than 20 million ps5 users. Easy math. It sucks because I am a ps5 owner and want to see the full potential without the need to cater to the last generation consoles. I understand the business side.
 

THE DUCK

voted poster of the decade by bots
How many times have you written that post now?

You haven't set the bar very high.

One could argue it's akin to the level of ambition put into making the plastic box.

Or if he were to take opposite approach like yourself and pretend that the Series s is far weaker than it really is? (Akin to comparing it to a plastic box) 🙄

The bar was set just fine, you just can't seem to accept what was delivered.
 

quest

Not Banned from OT
Believing in generations doesn't mean there wouldn't be any cross-gen games. Returnal is a PS5 exclusive.
You sure about that want to go through the post June threads last year destroying Microsoft and praising Sony for true next-gen only games like miles morales and forbidden west. Sony used the we believe in genatations and hiding cross generation games to create backlash at Microsoft for 4 months from all sides.
 
That's all fair, and makes sense, but then why do some hardcore sony fans run around saying xbox series s is ruining next gen? You can't have it both ways.
They say that for the Series S because series S is also a next gen console it will stay the same time as the series x.Sony will stop support of the PS4 after 2—3 years and the PS5 gets real exclusives from the startProblem is The series s is to low in performance and it will stay the whole gen here meaning it will drag all multi platform games down for the whole new gen, as far as I know Microsoft wants all their own games also on the series s but x is way more powerful than s it will hinder later on xbox exclusives as well not only Multiplattform games.That is the reason Some fans are against it.
 

THE DUCK

voted poster of the decade by bots
They say that for the Series S because series S is also a next gen console it will stay the same time as the series x.Sony will stop support of the PS4 after 2—3 years and the PS5 gets real exclusives from the startProblem is The series s is to low in performance and it will stay the whole gen here meaning it will drag all multi platform games down for the whole new gen, as far as I know Microsoft wants all their own games also on the series s but x is way more powerful than s it will hinder later on xbox exclusives as well not only Multiplattform games.That is the reason Some fans are against it.

By the time sony is done supporting ps4 we will be half way through the generation. And you still have low end pc's dragging everything down, series s won't be any lower than a low end pc. It's not going to hinder anything.
The idea that games are somehow built to the lowest common denominator is a myth anyhow, or we'd all still be playing games at 1080p with no ray tracing at 30fps.
 

dcmk7

Banned
Or if he were to take opposite approach like yourself and pretend that the Series s is far weaker than it really is? (Akin to comparing it to a plastic box) 🙄

The bar was set just fine, you just can't seem to accept what was delivered.

I don't get why anyone would be celebrating the console being better than last generations models.. the console should be able to prove that all by itself, right?

The fact that people actually need to write that statement, well over 6 months into the new gen is defensive beyond belief.

It suggests, if anything, that things aren't going well, which looking at UK stock, it isn't.

And you're right, I don't think the bar was set very high.. Did anyone ask for a HD gaming console in 2021, which in the majority of occasion's can only run games in a compromised state? Doesn't sound a next gen experience if you ask me.
 
Last edited:

RCU005

Member
By that logic All Stars, Demon's Souls and R&C would be cross gen too.

But they aren't.

Exactly! More Cross-gen coming does NOT mean ALL games will be cross gen.

My bet is that all AAA games will be exclusive to PS5. AA and lower as well as third party (even AAA) will still be cross-gen.

Horizon Forbidden West was planned as a PS4 title. They began working on it since the first released and knew it was going to be a launch window game.

God of War will not be cross-gen. I don’t buy it will release in 2022. It’s going to get delayed, otherwise they wouldn’t have announced it with just a logo. There would’ve been a small teaser.

Other AAA games that Sony announce should come after 2022, so they are less likely to be cross-gen.

Just think about it logically. They know games like FIFA, Ubisoft games, Other EA games and many Japanese games will still launch on PS4 just like they were still releasing on PS3 at the time. They are speaking generally, not specifically for their own studios.
 

Varteras

Gold Member
Considering the PS5 is in such short supply it's the right move for Sony to ensure they have a product to sell at any given time to anyone who wants it. Giving a previous gen console a long tail is part of what allowed PS2 to achieve the sales that it did. Obviously the games will become fewer and further between. We've already clearly seen that Sony's cross-gen offerings are very limited and most of their first party studios aren't likely to make anymore PS4 games. Pixelopus, San Diego, Media Molecule, and Japan might be the exceptions after this year. They may also have contracted a number of third parties who are still making PS4 games.
 

Ev1L AuRoN

Member
It depends on what they mean by support. I think it make it sense in a market standpoint, after all a lot of places are suffering due to the pandemic and the world economy will need some time to recover. Since both are x86 a lot of projects could be reduced to fit in the last gen constraints.

But games that rely on the new primitive engine and the I/O of the ps5 should be exclusives to the next gen. I don't believe PS4 will receive much first party blockbusters after Horizon FW and God of War Ragnarok, maybe GT7...
 

THE DUCK

voted poster of the decade by bots
I don't get why anyone would be celebrating the console being better than last generations models.. the console should be able to prove that all by itself, right?

The fact that people actually need to write that statement, well over 6 months into the new gen is defensive beyond belief.

It suggests, if anything, that things aren't going well, which looking at UK stock, it isn't.

And you're right, I don't think the bar was set very high.. Did anyone ask for a HD gaming console in 2021, which in the majority of occasion's can only run games in a compromised state? Doesn't sound a next gen experience if you ask me.

Well it does actually prove that by itself, it's just a handful of people who don't seem to understand what's actually in the hardware that typically bash it.

Your right, 6 months in it has proven it can play next gen games just fine at lower resolutions. Some with rt, some without, but 99% of the buyers don't care and are very happy with the machine. Yet it seems to be those who don't own one or never will that bash it the most.

Things are going just fine for the series s sales wise, and will continue ue to sell every single unit built by the end of 2021. They may not even need to lower the price as planned if things keep on like this with shortages.

You are measuring a "next gen" experience by what you want instead of the masses. Many buyers would see and experience the series s as a bona-fide next gen experience on thier 1080p TV, or even a smaller 4k tv since they can't see 4k. Just because you and I want or expect 4k at 60fps doesn't mean everyone does. The s is still a huge step up from an original xbox one, you can't deny that.

You keep saying compromised state, that's like saying driving a slow car vs driving a fast car is compromised, when both can be fun.
Or using a $400 tablet vs a $800 tablet, both can be fun. Or pc is even a better example, are you saying that anyone playing on less than a 2070 is in a "compromised state" (basically 75% of pc gamers? )
 

GloveSlap

Member
Theres always a bit of overlap, but there would probably be more next gen exclusives on both systems if they actually had to push new hardware sales. Everything sells out regardless now though, so they can have their cake and eat it too.
 

e&e

Banned
Is Ratchet a system seller? Will Ratchet actually sell? I know Sony hardcores are hyping it but it being on just PS5 and not also PS4 has me scratching my head (yes I know they tout the fast SSD for level loading). What’s the highest selling Ratchet?
 
Last edited:

martino

Member
Ratchet & Clank, Demon's souls, astroboy: niche games/genres = PS5 exclusives.

Horizon, Spiderman, GT7, GoW (maybe?): mainstream blockbuster titles = crossgen.

It's quite clear what they mean, you'd be dumb to think any of the "big games" coming out in the next years will be PS5 only.
this is what i was about to post.
Exclusive are less successful or new licenses with lesser sale potential and costing less to produce so far (for first party)
let's see if this is the criteria for games to be next gen exclusive for the next three year.
this rules only work so far
 

jigglet

Banned
The truth will be somewhere in the middle. 3 years is absurd - half the console life. Not happening. But at the same time they can't abandon it completely. 18 months is more likely. By this time next year PS4 will be a distant memory. This is non-news. Fanboys, disarm.
 
Top Bottom