• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF's Nintendo Discussion, News, and Speculation |OT|

Ailynn

Faith - Hope - Love
Okay, so...I got 120 stars in Mario 64 again. It's probably the 20th time I've done it now. I love that game. It's still fun all these years later. Good times!

Then, I excitedly started in on Mario Sunshine.

:messenger_expressionless:

I remember now why I never played the game again once I collected all the possible Shines back when it came out. It's by far the most frustrating Mario game I've ever played. The stress of obtaining some of those shines back then probably permanently shortened my lifespan.

Completing Mario Sunshine 100% before was something I'm proud to have accomplished, but I cannot allow myself to be subjected to that torture a second time.

Mario,
I am sorry, my friend...

tenor.gif
 
Last edited:

DunDunDunpachi

Patient MembeR
Okay, so...I got 120 stars in Mario 64 again. It's probably the 20th time I've done it now. I love that game. It's still fun all these years later. Good times!

Then, I excitedly started in on Mario Sunshine.

:messenger_expressionless:

I remember now why I never played the game again once I collected all the Shines in the game back when it came out. It's by far the most frustrating Mario game I've ever played. I honestly believe obtaining some of those shines back then may have permanently shortened my lifespan.

I've 100% completed Sunshine before, but I cannot allow myself to be subjected to that torture a second time.

Mario, I am sorry...
Mario does not forgive.

mario_suffer_more_face_meme_by_delightfuldiamond7_dby8vos-200h.png
 

ExpandKong

Banned
Okay, so...I got 120 stars in Mario 64 again. It's probably the 20th time I've done it now. I love that game. It's still fun all these years later. Good times!

Then, I excitedly started in on Mario Sunshine.

:messenger_expressionless:

I remember now why I never played the game again once I collected all the possible Shines back when it came out. It's by far the most frustrating Mario game I've ever played. The stress of obtaining some of those shines back then probably permanently shortened my lifespan.

Completing Mario Sunshine 100% before was something I'm proud to have accomplished, but I cannot allow myself to be subjected to that torture a second time.

Mario,
I am sorry, my friend...

tenor.gif

"You'll be back"

ShowyReliableBinturong-size_restricted.gif
 

cabbage5k2

Member
Okay, so...I got 120 stars in Mario 64 again. It's probably the 20th time I've done it now. I love that game. It's still fun all these years later. Good times!

Then, I excitedly started in on Mario Sunshine.

:messenger_expressionless:

I remember now why I never played the game again once I collected all the possible Shines back when it came out. It's by far the most frustrating Mario game I've ever played. The stress of obtaining some of those shines back then probably permanently shortened my lifespan.

Completing Mario Sunshine 100% before was something I'm proud to have accomplished, but I cannot allow myself to be subjected to that torture a second time.

Mario,
I am sorry, my friend...

tenor.gif

Luckily, most of the stars you actually have to clear are quite fun to play through tbh. Most of the levels, beyond the crap hotel one, are precursors to the playground philosophy of Odyssey. Although you can't quite grab the stars out of order without obscure glitches, you can approach the mission objectives in numerous ways a lot of the time, and the game actually does reward exploration quite often as well with blue coins and 1-ups. This, combine with Mario's mobility, makes this game quite a joy to traverse through. When you begin diving into the other shines in this game though... it falls apart. The obnoxious design of these stars, the technical problems you'll keep finding in these levels, the chore that is finding every god damn blue coin in this game, the piece of shit pachinko level... nothing works in that level, it doesn't even function as a thing that can exist in our reality...

Honestly, play that game for the joy of the level designs and the freedom you have to explore them, not to be a completionist about the game. For that matter, don't feel obliged to even complete the game either, as the last level is hotel levels bad :/
 

StormCell

Member
3D World was too safe and lacked too much excitement to be anything really special imo.

It a good game and a really good Platformer but it was bland in comparison to other 3D Mario's.

Sadly, I actually agree.

For all the hate Mario Sunshine gets, I'm enjoying every last bit of it. I look forward to revisiting Galaxy in a short while.

PS. I'm not 100 percenting it. Don't care to. I've gotten through the lousy levels I really hated in the past (ie. legendary wet bag of sand bird).
 
Last edited:

-Arcadia-

Banned
About 3D World, I’ve come to appreciate it a lot more. It felt like the right Mario, but the wrong time, you know?

In 2013, with Nintendo just stepping into HD with some gorgeous results, what I wanted was a Mario game that was a showpiece for the system. I wanted a free camera. I wanted amazing visuals in a traditional style. I wanted gigantic environments to pan around and explore. I wanted Odyssey, lol

Moreover, Nintendo continuing a handheld design based around casual, simple fun, on console, after the back-to-back spectacle of Galaxy 1 and 2, didn’t sit right with me.

On its own merits though, I feel it is an amazing game, and I really feel like the upcoming Switch rerelease might finally be ‘the right time’.
 

DunDunDunpachi

Patient MembeR
About 3D World, I’ve come to appreciate it a lot more. It felt like the right Mario, but the wrong time, you know?

In 2013, with Nintendo just stepping into HD with some gorgeous results, what I wanted was a Mario game that was a showpiece for the system. I wanted a free camera. I wanted amazing visuals in a traditional style. I wanted gigantic environments to pan around and explore. I wanted Odyssey, lol

Moreover, Nintendo continuing a handheld design based around casual, simple fun, on console, after the back-to-back spectacle of Galaxy 1 and 2, didn’t sit right with me.

On its own merits though, I feel it is an amazing game, and I really feel like the upcoming Switch rerelease might finally be ‘the right time’.
It's best 3D Mario, if you're in it for the platforming. 8 way controls feel laser-precise. And the 4p aspect was brushed off but it should be considered a feat. 4p 3D Mario? C'mon man, you know the thing. Why is this not taken into consideration? Hur hurr lemme be P2 and collect star bits with my Wiimote while you bing bing wahoo BEST 3D MARIO GAME.

The Bowser DLC better be good, though, or I'm skipping.

Ring Fit Adventurer needs to get in!
RingFit needs a sequel.

But the thought of a giant Ring monkey going OHHH KAAAYY!!! across the screen in a Final Smash makes me grin.
 

ExpandKong

Banned
It's best 3D Mario, if you're in it for the platforming. 8 way controls feel laser-precise. And the 4p aspect was brushed off but it should be considered a feat. 4p 3D Mario? C'mon man, you know the thing. Why is this not taken into consideration? Hur hurr lemme be P2 and collect star bits with my Wiimote while you bing bing wahoo BEST 3D MARIO GAME.

The Bowser DLC better be good, though, or I'm skipping.


RingFit needs a sequel.

But the thought of a giant Ring monkey going OHHH KAAAYY!!! across the screen in a Final Smash makes me grin.

4P simultaneous 3D Mario is indeed a feat but the thing is it's a feat I don't give a shit about lol. I'm not buying these games to play multiplayer. 3D World is still a fine game though.
 
Is there an iconic Monster Hunter character or player avatar? Monster Hunter would be a good synergy at the moment, but I don't know if there's a design that's recognizably "Monster Hunter!"
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
It's best 3D Mario, if you're in it for the platforming. 8 way controls feel laser-precise. And the 4p aspect was brushed off but it should be considered a feat. 4p 3D Mario? C'mon man, you know the thing. Why is this not taken into consideration? Hur hurr lemme be P2 and collect star bits with my Wiimote while you bing bing wahoo BEST 3D MARIO GAME.

The Bowser DLC better be good, though, or I'm skipping.

I very well might not be. 64 and Sunshine, alongside the Galaxies, both changed my thinking on what a Mario game could be, with the former pulling towards exploration, and the latter pulling towards just sheer overjoyed, magical fun in gameplay .

All have truly amazing platforming (maybe 64 a little less?), but yeah, it’s not 100%, all the time. 3D World might be the purest Mario in quite some time.

I just don’t necessarily think that equals best Mario anymore. But I totally understand if you do. Comparing these games is like comparing the most delicious chocolate cake of your lifetime, to the most perfect cheesecake anyone ever tasted. Nobody is wrong. Everybody is winning.
 

Evangelion Unit-01

Master Chief
Real talk-if I had to pick a character I would go with a SMT character (SMT V protag? Jack Frost?) or some combination of Xenoblade 2 characters (Rex+Pyra/Mythra).
 

DunDunDunpachi

Patient MembeR
I very well might not be. 64 and Sunshine, alongside the Galaxies, both changed my thinking on what a Mario game could be, with the former pulling towards exploration, and the latter pulling towards just sheer overjoyed, magical fun in gameplay .

All have truly amazing platforming (maybe 64 a little less?), but yeah, it’s not 100%, all the time. 3D World might be the purest Mario in quite some time.

I just don’t necessarily think that equals best Mario anymore. But I totally understand if you do. Comparing these games is like comparing the most delicious chocolate cake of your lifetime, to the most perfect cheesecake anyone ever tasted. Nobody is wrong. Everybody is winning.
They all exist on a spectrum, of sorts, and 3D World definitely seems like the "purest". Doesn't mean it will be everyone's favorite Mario, of course. I think it'll remain pretty obscure / unpopular and won't ever reach the adoration of SM64 or SMG, or even Odyssey.

4P simultaneous 3D Mario is indeed a feat but the thing is it's a feat I don't give a shit about lol. I'm not buying these games to play multiplayer. 3D World is still a fine game though.
Multiplayer extends the life of these games significantly, especially since this one has drop-in mp. It might not be on your radar now, but someone who might not be interested to replay 3D World solo could be convinced to have another go in 2p (or 4p) mode, just for the spectacle of it all. I played through the game solo but continue circling back on levels when playing w my kids.
 

ExpandKong

Banned
They all exist on a spectrum, of sorts, and 3D World definitely seems like the "purest". Doesn't mean it will be everyone's favorite Mario, of course. I think it'll remain pretty obscure / unpopular and won't ever reach the adoration of SM64 or SMG, or even Odyssey.


Multiplayer extends the life of these games significantly, especially since this one has drop-in mp. It might not be on your radar now, but someone who might not be interested to replay 3D World solo could be convinced to have another go in 2p (or 4p) mode, just for the spectacle of it all. I played through the game solo but continue circling back on levels when playing w my kids.

I GUESS

My kids aren't really old enough to play with me yet but my daughter loves watching. We finished Mario Galaxy a few weeks ago, then we started Galaxy 2 the next day and she was very distraught that the princess was kidnapped again hahah.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
They all exist on a spectrum, of sorts, and 3D World definitely seems like the "purest". Doesn't mean it will be everyone's favorite Mario, of course. I think it'll remain pretty obscure / unpopular and won't ever reach the adoration of SM64 or SMG, or even Odyssey.


Multiplayer extends the life of these games significantly, especially since this one has drop-in mp. It might not be on your radar now, but someone who might not be interested to replay 3D World solo could be convinced to have another go in 2p (or 4p) mode, just for the spectacle of it all. I played through the game solo but continue circling back on levels when playing w my kids.

I really think the Switch release will change things. People have had the big, gigantic, traditionally ambitious Mario, and I think they might be ready for something back to basics.

I have never played multiplayer, for more than a single session, sadly. I’m hoping to change that with this one, and finally see what that part of the game is all about.

Btw, I hope I haven’t slipped on showing how brilliant I think the game is. So much childlike joy and fun to all these stages, with Nintendo doing its thing of constantly introducing amazing new ideas, and polish beyond any other developer. All wrapped up in amazing visuals and music.
 
H

hariseldon

Unconfirmed Member
the 4p aspect was brushed off but it should be considered a feat. 4p 3D Mario? C'mon man, you know the thing.

That's what I'm REALLY looking forward to. New Super Mario Bros U Deluxe Penis feels too cramped for multiplayer and the camera is unhelpful, but the space afforded by 3D means I should be able to play it with my wife without either of hurling any controllers at the TV. That feels like a step in the right direction.
 

DunDunDunpachi

Patient MembeR
I GUESS

My kids aren't really old enough to play with me yet but my daughter loves watching. We finished Mario Galaxy a few weeks ago, then we started Galaxy 2 the next day and she was very distraught that the princess was kidnapped again hahah.
Lotta 3D World fans point out how the post-game content is much more challenging / interesting, while detractors mention that the main campaign is fairly easy.

But there's actually a much harder difficulty mode available from the start, called 'Cat Herding Simulator'. Unlock it by giving each of your kids a controller and a cat suit and then attempt to finish the stage without losing all your lives.

 

Astral Dog

Member
3D World was too safe and lacked too much excitement to be anything really special imo.

It a good game and a really good Platformer but it was bland in comparison to other 3D Mario's.
I like 3D World but i think the game is held back by some things.

The overall presentation and artsyle is a little safe for 3D Mario after the amazing GALAXY pushed the limits on Wii,cat suit couldn't make up for the blandness, they had an amazing thing with Bowsers amusement park but it was totally wasted just a random level with a few perks.

The focus on multiplayer and simple controls affects the level design, its still a fun game (more than Odyssey imo) but very very easy until the post game worlds at least GALAXY 2, Sunshine and 64 had good challenge for completing the game, World unfortunately doesn't.

The game felt like a bit of a devolution at the time even if its still awesome.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Btw, I’m not sure this even qualifies as music anymore, it’s so weird, but I absolutely love how playful and fun this track is. A complete earworm I was humming for months.



So much of the music is like this. And I absolutely adore that sax that plays over the world with the Goombas just chilling in their floaties, lol, but sadly can’t find it.
 
Last edited:

ExpandKong

Banned
Lotta 3D World fans point out how the post-game content is much more challenging / interesting, while detractors mention that the main campaign is fairly easy.

But there's actually a much harder difficulty mode available from the start, called 'Cat Herding Simulator'. Unlock it by giving each of your kids a controller and a cat suit and then attempt to finish the stage without losing all your lives.



This is the challenge a true MLG gaming expert like myself craves.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
3D World sounds like it was aimed directly at N64/Gamecube ears don't you think -Arcadia- -Arcadia- ?

Definitely. I kind of thought Galaxy 2 was heading too far in the direction of ‘serious’, orchestral music. There was one level in particular where I recall it actually kind of overpowering everything and kind of annoying me, in a peaceful, chill level. Like just chill out a bit.

I think 3D World was a nice scale-back to having epic orchestras and real instruments, but also playing with weird, synthesized, utterly Mario sounds, and creating completely memorable melodies. The latter is very important to Nintendo music.
 
Btw, I’m not sure this even qualifies as music anymore, it’s so weird, but I absolutely love how playful and fun this track is. A complete earworm I was humming for months.



So much of the music is like this. And I absolutely adore that sax that plays over the world with the Goombas just chilling in their floaties, lol, but sadly can’t find it.

Did I mention that 3D World is also the GOAT OST?
That Big Band direction they went in was pure fire. Such an incredible soundtrack. As much as I love Galaxy’s orchestral tunes, this was something so much bolder and they pulled it off without even breaking a sweat.
 
Top Bottom