Support NeoGAF

[SpearFist]

Max Payne 3
Bloodborne
Doom eternal
Battlefield 1
Devil May cry 3-5
Sekiro
Ninja Gaiden
Vanquish
God Hand
RE4
Kill zone 2
Returnal
Nex machina
Gears Of war 1
FEAR

I still have might left few more.

 

[JC 1080P CRT]

My picks, by decade.

1980s:
Tetris (GB)

1990s:
DOOM/Ultimate DOOM/DOOM II

2000s:
Resident Evil 4

2010s:
DOOM (2016)

2020s:
Neon White

Spoiler: Full list of nominees

1980s:
Super Mario Bros. 3
Tetris (GB)

1990s:
Street Fighter II (every edition)
DOOM/Ultimate DOOM/DOOM II
Chrono Trigger
Super Mario RPG
Duke Nukem 3D
Quake
Super Mario 64
Saturn Bomberman
Unreal Tournament

2000s:
Metal Gear Solid 2
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3
WarioWare
Mario & Luigi
Resident Evil 4
Gunpey (PSP)

2010s:
Undertale
DOOM (2016)

2020s:
Huntdown
Neon White

 

[SeraphJan]

 

[mcjmetroid]

That's a really solid list, OP. I'd consider Resident Evil 4 Remake to be up there, as well. Some may say that Leon is a little sluggish, causing frustration, and to them, I say:

He's a bit too slow for my tastes. It's funny because it depends on the area and environment but near the beginning of the game the dude needs to be a little faster.
Otherwise perfect

 

[Goon_Bong]

It’s not my favourite game but Shadow of Mordor just felt absolutely buttery. Everything from the combat to traversal was just creamy smooth.

 

[bellome]

 

[Black_Stride]

And Bat Within, my dodging timing's always off whenever I start a new playthrough until I unlock it.

I was gonna mention Bat Within as well, but I thought Moon is such a good feeling when you parry multi hit attacks or quickly repel attacks from two or three directions.....you just feel like such a boss.

Moon makes you feel like Evo 37

 

[Sub_Level]

My man.

 

[mcjmetroid]

Some people weirdly complain about the controls but:

Super Mario Sunshine with the GAMECUBE controller. It controls like an absolute dream but weirdly some people had issues with it.

Don't understand why.

 

[PSYGN]

 

[GenericUser]

So's I compiled my own list

whats yours?

Could be 3D or 2D.

MGSV
Doom Eternal
Returnal
Bloodborne
Warhawk
BOTW
Metroid Dread
Ninja Gaiden Black
Halo 3
Wave Race 64
Fzero GX

MGSV - incomplete
Doom Eternal - Trash
Returnal - Sony Trash
Bloodborne - 30fps
Warhawk- whos dad posted this?
botw - didn't play
Metroid Dread - didn't play
Ninja Gaiden Black - wanna be from game
Halo 3 - come on man
Wave Race 64 - legit
Fzero GX - legit

 

[GenericUser]

Mario 64
Unreal Tournament
Street Fighter II
Tekken 3
Super Metroid
A Link to the Past
Half-Life 2
Final Fantasy 6 & 7
Ninja Gaiden Black

It just feels right.

whenever alttp is mentioned, I wanna replay that game. Never made it past the shadow world - lol.

 

[Ogbert]

Destiny 2.

Ori.

Hate to say it, but Fortnite is where it is for a reason.

 

[Bond007]

Alot of stuff i agree with in this thread for sure.
But Insomniac games always been like just a well oiled machine- butter.

 

[Elitro]

From the top of my head...

Everything Blizzard. Even D3, for all its woes it still had the best gameplay feeling in the biz.
Elden Ring is great (or From Soft games in general)
Valve (Dota 2/CS) - Just tried Valorant recently and it's crazy how cs 1.3/1.4 felt vastly superior to that.

 

[Humdinger]

• Burnout 3
• Morrowind
• Halo: CE
• Wipeout series
• Horizon Zero Dawn
• Skyrim
• Max Payne 2
• PS4 Spiderman

 

[Utherellus]

Red Dead Redemption 2
Just Cause series
Flatout 2

I can play these for decades. Absurdly satisfying experience.

 

[Poplin]

dead island 2 has the best first person melee hit feel ive experienced to date. amazing physics, damage modelling, and sound design make it feel fresh every time you kill a zombie, which you do a lot.

 

[SnapShot]

Warframe? Destiny 2? heck even OG RE4?

tbh there's tons of games I could list here that have super satisfying gameplay, why even bother asking.

 

[BossLackey]

Really great list, OP. These are all mighty high on my own list.

I think Rainbows Six Siege has criminally underrated gunplay/gamefeel. I've played a LOT of multiplayer shooters and I always come back to Siege for the 1 shot headshots. Very satisfying.

 

[TexMex]

No game feels as good to play as Dead Cells to me.

 

[StueyDuck]

In term of raw game feel its always been housemarque... so returnal

 

[AtomicStarving]

Some good ones listed.

Gonna add more - some of my favorites:

Diablo Series
The Last of Us P2
Deus Ex HR + MD
Hitman Modern Series
Bioshock Series
Ghost of Tsushima - The best AC ever made imo< amazing controls
Battlefield 4
COD Black Ops 2 + Black Ops 3 (last one I liked, after that > trash)
Destiny 2

 

[HazukiSensei]

3D mario titles
Tony Hawk Pro skater
Spiderman ps4
Bayonetta
Doom Eternal
Jak and Daxter
God of war 1-3
Black Desert for mouse MMO combat

 

[cinnamonandgravy]

smash melee

 

[Hugare]

Ohh, I would like to add Furi

That game felt gooood

 

[Pimpollo818]

Thumper
Doom Eternal
Rayman Origins

 

[GigaBowser]

TOTK has replaced BOTW on my list

 

[NomadicAsiatic]

Doom 16
DMC V
Mario Odyssey
Streets Of Rage
God Of War(both sagas)
Need For Speed Hot Pursuit

 

[iorek21]

Sekiro
Hollow Knight
Rayman Legens
Doom Eternal
Crash 4 (level design is aweful though)
Death Stranding

 

[Represent.]

SIFU

THE LAST OF US: PART II

My top 2.

 

[H4ze]

Counter Strike, pure gaming perfection

 

[GigaBowser]

SIFU

THE LAST OF US: PART II

My top 2.

I gotta gets SIFU is it really that goord?

 

[Represent.]

I gotta gets SIFU is it really that goord?

Absolutely. Arguably the best combat ever. Play it on hard(est)

 

[NightmareFarm]

Bayonetta 3 or Metal Gear Rising

 

[Darchaos]

I can pic and shoose from sooo many,there is alot of good gameplay out there. But right here right now:

SSX, what and awsome game it was and i miss it so much! Its tricky its tricky

 

[Pimpollo818]

Doom Eternal
FEAR
Rayman Origins