-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Assassin's Creed Valhalla: PS5 vs Xbox Series X Graphics Comparison
- Thread starter Craig of War
- Start date
StrongGuy
Member
We're already seeing the consequences of it. PS5 is showing more stable framerates, less tearing, higher quality textures, and probably higher resolution. You can keep denying it all you want, but XSX is looking more like the PS3 than the PS4.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
It’s called vsync, turn it on devs and stop making excuses for developers not doing it.
VRR also doesn’t work if games become more demanding and dip below 48fps. Both options should be there. Not just VRR and no vsync.
Last edited:
MasterCornholio
Member
May I suggest waiting for the comparisons before coming to a conclusion?
Just seems a bit early to say anything about this to be honest.
Knitted Knight
Banned
It all depends on how much RAM the O.S for PS5 is using vs. that allocated to Xbox Series X, and how fast the PS5 I/O can stuff that RAM allocation.
If anything, it's in these early games.... with Ubisoft engines favoring the DirectX API that should theoretically show the lowest of differences. It will take time for devs to truly optimize their engines and rendering pipeline around PS5's I/O. Sony's first party clearly have a head start - just look at Spider-man Miles Morales or even Demon Souls from a 65-70 man team. Head above any third party offering on consoles.
If anything, it's in these early games.... with Ubisoft engines favoring the DirectX API that should theoretically show the lowest of differences. It will take time for devs to truly optimize their engines and rendering pipeline around PS5's I/O. Sony's first party clearly have a head start - just look at Spider-man Miles Morales or even Demon Souls from a 65-70 man team. Head above any third party offering on consoles.
Indeed.
Last edited:
Romulus
Member
What? One game and you've doomed it for the entire generation? lmao. You're clearly trolling. Even 10 launch games with superior(nothing has been proven yet) results isn't a forecast of an entire generation. That's a ludicrous thought process, and for you to even compare it to PS3 is a joke. Even "more like PS3" is just crazy. You have no idea if there's a day 1 patch or anything, you're just hoping to god your precious console of choice is the "winner."
Look, I like Sony, but you're ridiculous.
JackMcGunns
Member
Rubbish! Will have to wait for DF for a real comparison.
In the meantime, here’s a video showing Xbox One, SS and SX.
You’re welcome to start a new thread with it.
In the meantime, here’s a video showing Xbox One, SS and SX.
You’re welcome to start a new thread with it.
thelastword
Banned
Looking at it closer...
Xbox looks a tad clearer in parts, PS5 looks darker, so in these scenes the lighting pops on XBOX a bit more.
Other parts, PS5 looks clearer, like in the Eivor/Cassandra scene, PS5 pops more, has better DOF
Some scenes shows PS5 has better shadows and generally I think performance is better on PS5, smoother with no tearing....
Xbox looks a tad clearer in parts, PS5 looks darker, so in these scenes the lighting pops on XBOX a bit more.
Other parts, PS5 looks clearer, like in the Eivor/Cassandra scene, PS5 pops more, has better DOF
Some scenes shows PS5 has better shadows and generally I think performance is better on PS5, smoother with no tearing....
StrongGuy
Member
I've built up a catalog of over 30 games on the PS4, and I would prefer the PS5 being superior to the XSX so that I can feel at ease transitioning to the PS5. If the XSX performed better than the PS5, I would feel that my 7 years farming amazon gift cards would be a waste.
I think you should come to terms with reality. Efficient design > Bottlenecked design with slightly stronger GPU
Last edited:
Jaguar Victory
Member
What are you talking about? Stable frame rates only on games running a lower resolution?
StrongGuy
Member
PS5 also has much faster loading. It is the definitive console version. Everyone with XSX should return their console immediately.
bitbydeath
Member
C’mon man. Let people enjoy what they want to enjoy. It is of no concern to you.
StrongGuy
Member
PS5 has higher texture quality and less screen tearing with more stable frame rates. This means it is probably running at a higher average resolution than the XSX version. Devs will not intentionally lower resolution to boost other graphics quality. At worst, PS5 will match the XSX resolution, but the former having a lower average resolution is out the question now.
JackMcGunns
Member
Look at the video I posted.
Jaguar Victory
Member
Where? What game?
Knitted Knight
Banned
MasterCornholio
Member
.............
Last edited:
Romulus
Member
Theres just zero evidence to conclude anything. I know you want to believe you're getting the best experience over xbox fans. But you're reaching man. Theres no superior version until the retail patched versions come out on day1 or ever later, not to mention ps5 could have been the lead development platform, which is a clear advantage and doesnt mean "bottlenecks!"
XSX actually has alot more bandwidth too in addition to a clear gpu advantage.
Mr. PlayStation
Member
Looks identical to me, i mean 10.3 doesn't look identical in number to 12, but the efficiencies across both consoles makes the paper comparisons moot in real world games across both consoles. Enjoy them on whichever platform you're going for at launch!
Bruno_Arrais85
Member
Ugly on both
Bittermich
Banned
Or use VRR.
Traxtech
Member
That's just another cross gen game so I doubt it
Silent Viper
Banned
Lol pointless. Need indepth analysis to see the difference
Bernkastel
Ask me about my fanboy energy!
Welcome back.
Kagey K
Banned
I don’t remember Ghosts being substantially different between the 2 cross gen versions so I don’t expect much this time either, but they are promising Raytracing so it’s another chance to see what they can do and how much bandwidth it eats.
Bo_Hazem
Banned
Welcome back!
Agnostic2020
Member
If u cant see the difference In depth analysis is indeed pointless.
They look very similar with less screen tearing on ps5
And you fell for his bait, GG.
Quantum253
Member
I couldn't tell any difference either. I know if I were trying to sell someone on next gen, I wouldn't use that as proof.
Tranquil
Member
Been playing this game all day on the Series X, there is screen tearing but it's rare and almost all during cut scenes.
Traxtech
Member
Everything looks like ps3 animations to me after I played the last of us 2. I hope developers push things like that this upcoming gem, Ray tracing is great but if you can't get immersed by shit animations then what's the point
Mr. PlayStation
Member
How do we know Radbrad's video is PS5 version? Don't tell me it's because of PS controller prompts!
Sw0pDiller
Member
it's weird that they let the xbox version go with all this tearing? it is just an easy patch?
Shmunter
Member
It’s tearing when it cannot sustain its target framerate. More aggressive resolution scaling could mitigate it. Releasing it like this is bizzare.
Little Chicken
Member
We're going to see more unoptimized, cross-gen releases for the next year or more, but hats off to anyone doing cross-platform development in 2020.
It's going to be interesting to see which game really feels "next-gen" in the way that Gears 1 did in 2006 for the 360.
It's going to be interesting to see which game really feels "next-gen" in the way that Gears 1 did in 2006 for the 360.
Rean no Kiseki
Banned
Waiting for DF.
I'll wait to play it when I eventually get a PS5 6-12 months from now.
Hopefully by then the bugs and other issues will be ironed out plus it will be cheaper to boot!
I'll wait to play it when I eventually get a PS5 6-12 months from now.
Hopefully by then the bugs and other issues will be ironed out plus it will be cheaper to boot!
DonJorginho
Banned
Hmm that sounds good, it was really noticeable in the cutscenes I saw, hoping it gets patched soon as WD Legion had the same issue!
devilNprada
Member
How does one farm Amazon gift cards?
devilNprada
Member
If that's the case does the difference even matter?
Monkeygourmet
Banned
I would imagine it will be a repeat of Pro Vs. X but even more in favour of the PS5 this time round.
I would imagine MS to be bullheaded with attemtping full 4K whereas Sony will use adaptive 4K more often. That coupled with the faster streaming HD for textures / pop in and I think the PS5 multi plats will generally play better at maybe a slightly lower resolution.
Once again Sony's first party will continue to look the best overall in the generation.
I would imagine MS to be bullheaded with attemtping full 4K whereas Sony will use adaptive 4K more often. That coupled with the faster streaming HD for textures / pop in and I think the PS5 multi plats will generally play better at maybe a slightly lower resolution.
Once again Sony's first party will continue to look the best overall in the generation.