-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Assassin's Creed Valhalla: PS5 vs Xbox Series X Graphics Comparison
- Thread starter Craig of War
- Start date
DonJorginho
Banned
Both look great, just need to patch the screentearing I keep seeing on videos covering this game.
DeadOblivion78
Member
Both are in 1080p which looks atrocious on youtube with compression. Both look literally the same.
GHG
Member
1080p so hard to compare.
Questionable legitimacy due to the fact that the PS5 version is still under embargo.
With that said, if its legit, they look very much the same to the untrained eye. We will need DF to do an analysis on the framerates etc and point out the differences.
OnThePathToWisdom
Member
I wish we could ban youtube for comparisons like these. The compression is atrocious. We need a new gaming focused streaming website that actually cares about image quality.
Mister Wolf
Gold Member
Waiting for digital foundry to say the average resolution of both since no one else will take the time to do it.
JawaSaysUtinni
Member
Ignoring the 1080p, why is it so hard to put a side-by-side comparison? My eyes are not discerning enough.
GHG
Member
I don’t know what res they are running, but PS5 don’t have tearing, Xbox sometimes you can see it
FullMetalx117
Member
As someone getting both consoles, I assumed XSX would always have the better looking multiplat games...this sort of changes my mind. Maybe it is all PS5 next gen...
Stuart360
Member
And before people go on about the differences in darkness, the game has a dynamic day night cycle, and this cutscene for me was at night (the thumbnail cutscene), as i went exploring before going for the main mission.
I mean there may be differences in colour and brightness between PS5 and XSX, there has been the last 2 gens, i'm just saying that the darkness differences may be just the time off day.
And yes, if you check the cutscene at 7:38, there are a few tears on XSX, and no tears on PS5.
I mean there may be differences in colour and brightness between PS5 and XSX, there has been the last 2 gens, i'm just saying that the darkness differences may be just the time off day.
And yes, if you check the cutscene at 7:38, there are a few tears on XSX, and no tears on PS5.
Last edited:
Black_Stride
do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
Holy shit the comments section of this video has made me appreciate even the most dogged GAF Playstation/Xbox fanboys.
This is going to be a long generation.
Fuck!
This is going to be a long generation.
Fuck!
sojuwarrior
Member
whats the consensus? do they look exactly the same just like all other game comparison videos lol?
Why so many just assumed this I have no idea. LIterally people saying they were going to get a Series X because it is more "Powerful"
Last edited:
azertydu91
Hard to Kill
Basically yes.
Black_Stride
do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
You what love?
Stuart360
Member
If i was chosing which version to buy, based soley on this video, i'd pick PS5 for the lack of screen tearing. I hate screen tearing with a passion, and would rather have the odd bit of judder over tearing.
Of course the video is only 1080p, and slightly different times of day for most of the gameplay. We need some proper 4k comparisons, and framerate/resolution tests.
I just thought i would try and be fair, based on this vid.
Of course the video is only 1080p, and slightly different times of day for most of the gameplay. We need some proper 4k comparisons, and framerate/resolution tests.
I just thought i would try and be fair, based on this vid.
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Stuart360
Member
Its actually a beautiful game, but yes opinions on its graphics are certainly different depending on the person.
Valued Gamer
Banned
Let's just wait till DF get their reviews out.
There will be plenty of opportunities to melt then.
There will be plenty of opportunities to melt then.
MasterCornholio
Member
I doubt its a real comparison. There's no way they look that close.
Last edited:
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
This is a waste of time. Wake me when the real comparisons come out.
Golgo 13
The Man With The Golden Dong
You playing on PC?
Stuart360
Member
What differences are you expecting?. Its a cross gen game, i'm sure the graphics will be identicle settings wise. There may be the odd difference in resolution and frame droppage though, and the XSX version def does have some screen tearing, mostly in its cutscenes but the PS5 version has no tearing from what i can see.
Bo_Hazem
Banned
From screenshots the game looks gorgeous. That ACG video seems like PC, and PC always have bad ports compared to consoles.
It's hilarious, PS5 lacking VRR now, and XSX having bad/no VSYNC implementation. Things should be fixed with later firmware updates.
Last edited:
Vae_Victis
Banned
The differences (if there are any) are way too small and the video way too shit to be able to really notice anything.
Only thing that stands out is that there is occasional screen tearing on SXS, but I didn't see any on PS5. If any other difference is there, it will probably be an imperceptible resolution thing (like one drops from 4K a bit more often) or very minor frame drops here and there.
This is still for all intents and purposes a cross-gen game, I don't think there is even ray tracing in the next-gen version? If that's the case, it's basically little more interesting than a comparison between backwards compatible games, as far as evaluating the two consoles goes.
Only thing that stands out is that there is occasional screen tearing on SXS, but I didn't see any on PS5. If any other difference is there, it will probably be an imperceptible resolution thing (like one drops from 4K a bit more often) or very minor frame drops here and there.
This is still for all intents and purposes a cross-gen game, I don't think there is even ray tracing in the next-gen version? If that's the case, it's basically little more interesting than a comparison between backwards compatible games, as far as evaluating the two consoles goes.
Stuart360
Member
Yes, and max settings, except vollumetrc clouds down to medium (becaue they are heavy on usage, and barely look different), and environment textures down one notch from ultra as the game was tapping out the 6gb of vram from my 980ti.
I was also playing at 1080p, so lower rez than the next gen consoles.
The game is def a lot better in person than in vids though.
geordiemp
Member
Black_Stride
do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
MasterCornholio
Member
geordiemp
Member
Its ubisoft, I had low equal expectations for both so ......... Just having some GiF fun.
Last edited: