• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Polygon -Sony’s silence on PS5 has done wonders for the next-gen Xbox

LMJ

Member
Wait?? Is this anything like when Xbox fans wanna discuss Xbox stuff in Xbox threads but Sony fans become "concerned" so they intervene?

If so, yeah. Time to get over . Lol


There in lies the rub Gavon West Gavon West , I dislike fanboys (or loyalists if you want to be kinder) of all shades...

If you like xbox that's fantastic, they have brought us
A standard online experience (paid or not)

A phenomenal controller that many have copied...
Trophies/gamer score which I genuinely like lol,
A home button, and many truly fantastic games, hell I could spend at least a week on the Rare collection alone lol

That having been said what I have noticed especially as of late is xbox loyalists inability to recognize criticism from fanboyism...

The fall of the xbox thread is perfect example of this, most realists would tell you Sony completely bungled last generation with the playstation 3, Only the most devoted die hard would argue otherwise...

Microsoft is no angel they too have made some major mistakes and some boneheaded moves, but try to explain that or take a rational look at it and people are losing their mind...

Hell the AMD announces RDNA2 for XbSX and PS5 thread Is a pure example of the kind of silliness and stupidity I'm referring too.
 

Gavon West

Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
The fact of the matter is this, until Sony actually announce something, Microsoft have the more powerful console. And also until then, Microsoft have a little game called Halo infinite on day one. Let me tell you something, I know exactly where my money is going on day one. And it’s not on a PlayStation5.
You know what they call this ^^^

The narrative. This is what happens when Sony goes quiet. Being silent ain't doing them any favors.
 

Pallas

Member
Or just patch the games like they do retroactively with Pro-versions.

The reason for the PS4 Remasters was because there was a mass exodus on the Xbox front, all jumping ship to PS4.
And with no BC, they brought the best Playstation games to PS4 so people who missed out could enjoy them.


Anyone with even half a brain can understand that much.

Good guy Sony.
 

Gavon West

Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
There in lies the rub Gavon West Gavon West , I dislike fanboys (or loyalists if you want to be kinder) of all shades...

If you like xbox that's fantastic, they have brought us
A standard online experience (paid or not)

A phenomenal controller that many have copied...
Trophies/gamer score which I genuinely like lol,
A home button, and many truly fantastic games, hell I could spend at least a week on the Rare collection alone lol

That having been said what I have noticed especially as of late is xbox loyalists inability to recognize criticism from fanboyism...

The fall of the xbox thread is perfect example of this, most realists would tell you Sony completely bungled last generation with the playstation 3, Only the most devoted die hard would argue otherwise...

Microsoft is no angel they too have made some major mistakes and some boneheaded moves, but try to explain that or take a rational look at it and people are losing their mind...

Hell the AMD announces RDNA2 for XbSX and PS5 thread Is a pure example of the kind of silliness and stupidity I'm referring too.
Oh, I agree completely. It makes no never mind if the PS5 has RDNA2 as well. Not even sure how anyone could have a problem with it.

And I agree, when Microsoft wasn't backing Xbox back a few years ago, the platform was in desperate need of new IP's. What it was surviving on was dire. Clearly, CLEARLY that's not the case now.

But as of now, I couldn't criticize the Xbox platform aside from adding new Japanese devs to the fold and allowing BR headsets to work with the system. Right now, Xbox is as strong as its ever been. And that will continue to happen.
 

Klayzer

Member
The bravado these hardcore Xbox fans have is something to behold. If you didn't know anything about gaming, you would swear Microsoft is absolutely dominating the industry by their posts. I hope the PS5 is less powerful, just for their own mental health. Its morbidly fascinating how much of their gaming self worth is tied to that.
 

Aion002

Member
Well, E3 is coming up, so....
And I mean, seriously, Sony hasn't shown ANYTHING compelling. Like, at all. Unless you're just riveted by stylish fonts! Sheesh!
They just announced that Ghost of Tsushima, a triple A exclusive, it's coming in june.

The PS4 in the end of the gen is getting/got: Dreams, Nioh 2, FFVII Remake, The Last of Us 2, Granblue Fantasy Versus , Disaster Report 4, Iron Man VR, Predator, Sakura Wars 4, Yakuza 7 and many more...

And guess what? Some of those might be released on PC or Switch, but none is announced to Xbox One...

Sony is screaming: Hey guys! We supported the PS1, PS2 and the PS3 until the end, and we are going to support the PS4 in the same way! Have fun!

While MS is saying: Fuck the One, here is the series X! Trust us! We won't fuck it up again... ok?

Why are you acting like the PS4 is dead? This is getting ridiculous.
 
474779.jpg

You better buy it day one because it will be DOA in less than a week. Well, lets not forget about that "roadmap" that will come along with that release.
 

Gavon West

Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
They just announced that Ghost of Tsushima, a triple A exclusive, it's coming in june.

The PS4 in the end of the gen is getting/got: Dreams, Nioh 2, FFVII Remake, The Last of Us 2, Granblue Fantasy Versus , Disaster Report 4, Iron Man VR, Predator, Sakura Wars 4, Yakuza 7 and many more...

And guess what? Some of those might be released on PC or Switch, but none is announced to Xbox One...

Sony is screaming: Hey guys! We supported the PS1, PS2 and the PS3 until the end, and we are going to support the PS4 in the same way! Have fun!

While MS is saying: Fuck the One, here is the series X! Trust us! We won't fuck it up again... ok?

Why are you acting like the PS4 is dead? This is getting ridiculous.
Who said the PS4 was dead? In fact, I suggested otherwise. Still no excuse to be dead silent with next gen upon us. Fuck sakes, even Google is communicating more than Sony and they haven't even unpacked yet. Stadia is handidly taking their lumps right this second, and they still have the brass to speak to gamers, even if they look belly up right now. Jesus!
 
Last edited:

JORMBO

Darkness no more
I don't think it matters much that they are quiet. Once they announce things people will decide if they like what they see or not and all the stuff that led up to it won't matter.

Now if it gets to be something like August and they are still quiet then I think it is ok to worry about what they are doing.
 

Aion002

Member
Who said the PS4 was dead? In fact, I suggested otherwise. Still no excuse to be dead silent with next gen upon us. Fuck sakes, even Google is communicating more than Sony and they haven't even unpacked yet. Stadia is handidly taking their lumps right this second, and they still have the brass to speak to gamers, even if they look belly up right now. Jesus!
So... You really think that is smart to promote your new product while your older one is still being worked on and selling well?

If you can't see the flaw in that logic there's nothing I can tell you.
 

Klayzer

Member
I don't think it matters much that they are quiet. Once they announce things people will decide if they like what they see or not and all the stuff that led up to it won't matter.

Now if it gets to be something like August and they are still quiet then I think it is ok to worry about what they are doing.
The real reason why they want Sony to disclose information is:

The e-peen, chest beating, lottery winning, green wave of destruction, they want to unleash on message boards, if the PS5 has less flops than the SEX. That's the real reason for the concern.
 

LMJ

Member
Oh, I agree completely. It makes no never mind if the PS5 has RDNA2 as well. Not even sure how anyone could have a problem with it.

And I agree, when Microsoft wasn't backing Xbox back a few years ago, the platform was in desperate need of new IP's. What it was surviving on was dire. Clearly, CLEARLY that's not the case now.

But as of now, I couldn't criticize the Xbox platform aside from adding new Japanese devs to the fold and allowing BR headsets to work with the system. Right now, Xbox is as strong as its ever been. And that will continue to happen.


So it seems we agree then :)

I agree with pretty much everything you've said (dont get me started on abandoning the Japanese studios, not a headset guy, so didn't even know that lol)

Always good to find common ground, I just get concerned when these talks get heated like this because we tend to lose posters like Pana (at least only a week this time)
 

Gavon West

Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
So... You really think that is smart to promote your new product while your older one is still being worked on and selling well?

If you can't see the flaw in that logic there's nothing I can tell you.
But, gee! Didn't they do that with the PS4 Pro???
 

JLB

Banned
Come off it and just state the reality. You only care that your console of choice is slightly more powerful so you can feel better about your purchase. All the while ignoring the long and storied history of power not equating to console success.

The consoles are going to be more powerful than the previous generation. Fact. That is all we need to know. Does one output .4 more teraflops? Maybe, but it literally makes no difference. Do you know what does? The games. A console is nothing without the games and even a weak system can be massively successful as long as there are good games releasing on it.

Im a tech enthusiast.
Im an early adopter.
Im a software developer, and love videogames since my Commodore64.

Of course I care and love gadgets. And that has nothing to do with console wars.
 
Last edited:

Norse

Member
They just announced that Ghost of Tsushima, a triple A exclusive, it's coming in june.

The PS4 in the end of the gen is getting/got: Dreams, Nioh 2, FFVII Remake, The Last of Us 2, Granblue Fantasy Versus , Disaster Report 4, Iron Man VR, Predator, Sakura Wars 4, Yakuza 7 and many more...

And guess what? Some of those might be released on PC or Switch, but none is announced to Xbox One...

Sony is screaming: Hey guys! We supported the PS1, PS2 and the PS3 until the end, and we are going to support the PS4 in the same way! Have fun!

While MS is saying: Fuck the One, here is the series X! Trust us! We won't fuck it up again... ok?

Why are you acting like the PS4 is dead? This is getting ridiculous.
MS is saying: fuck the ONE!? Make up your damn mind. Xsx won't have any exclusives because MS is having devs support the ONE according to Sony fans. Now MS is saying fuck the ONE? You guys need to get your strategy in sync.


On the topic of the OP, I don't think MS has said all that much. We know it's 12tf rdn2 with Ray tracing and 3d audio. And we know what the xsx looks like. We also know ps5 is rdna2 with Ray tracing and 3d audio. So, tf # and what retail will look like is all that's missing. They'll both have fast ssd drives so that's a wash too. Heck, we even know what the ps5 Dev unit looks like. Have we seen the xsx Dev unit?

So, imo ms hasn't really gained anything yet due to lack of ps5 info.
 

Panajev2001a

GAF's Pleasant Genius
Well deserved for MS. They've been open and engaged with gamers unlike Sony. In my opinion either there are big problems with the PS5 or this is Sony at their most arrogant.
One is working on PS5, a bit quietly perhaps, but giving users tons of big first party PS4 games late in the generation while the other is talking a lot online and yet another first party games draughts before the new box launch if you want to see things under that Vs. light.

Who is exactly engaging with gamers?
 
Last edited:

Aion002

Member
MS is saying: fuck the ONE!? Make up your damn mind. Xsx won't have any exclusives because MS is having devs support the ONE according to Sony fans. Now MS is saying fuck the ONE? You guys need to get your strategy in sync.


On the topic of the OP, I don't think MS has said all that much. We know it's 12tf rdn2 with Ray tracing and 3d audio. And we know what the xsx looks like. We also know ps5 is rdna2 with Ray tracing and 3d audio. So, tf # and what retail will look like is all that's missing. They'll both have fast ssd drives so that's a wash too. Heck, we even know what the ps5 Dev unit looks like. Have we seen the xsx Dev unit?

So, imo ms hasn't really gained anything yet due to lack of ps5 info.
Nah, they did the contrary.

One games got moved to series X.


Imagine if Sony had delayed and released GT6 as a cross game between Ps3 and Ps4... Or the same now had happened with TLU2 or GOT.


That's what MS did. Fuck the one, bring his games to Series X, let's spin this shit and say we're Pro consumer.

Also, "you guys", what are you talking about? Are you really gonna come up with this "us against them" shit... I am out, this thread reminds me of 2013 all over again.
 

Klayzer

Member
Well, I think that's enough for me of this console circle-jerk episode #100. Off to dinner, later friends
 

KiNeMz

Banned
I would assume that Microsoft is doing the smart thing and keeping it's new 1st party IP for reveal with full reveal of xsx. It will require some hard hitting games out the gate. Hope they bring the goods. The switch sold well initially due to Zelda. Sony hasn't given us a thing yet and thats ok. They shouldn't have to force their hand just because Xbox wants to move to next gen. Sony has solid current gen sales to make. Still interesting times. Hopefully Nintendo will release a brand new home console with 17TF and blow them all out of the water.
 
Last edited:

Iorv3th

Member
Wait, wha?? Not being disingenuous at all. The base PS4 was selling like hot cakes. They still introduced the Ps4 Pro, regardless. Did that slow anything down for Sony?

PS4 Pro wasn't competeing with regular PS4. Regular PS4 still outsold the pro after the pro came out..... I don't know what your talking about.
 

HeresJohnny

Member
The industry leader dictates the tone of the coming generation. Microsoft is like Apollo Creed talking all kinds of shit before getting KTFO. And hey, if Sony fucks up then props to Microsoft. I don't see that happening, though.
 

thelastword

Banned
MS had a hard time this gen.....

2013 XBONES will be more powerful Hype: PS4 smoked it in specs and games

2016/2017 XBONEX, Highest Quality Pixels, 4K native, No compromises: PRO smoked it in sales and Framerates

2019/2020 XBOX Series X Hypetrain, the most powerful console box and spec reveal: Jim Ryan says, we will crush them with a logo, it's all we need atm....In the meantime, release LOU 2 to many 10/10's, Have them salivating for FF7 and Release Tsushima in June to commemorate how we sliced up the competition this whole gen.....Everybody will be talking about these games and their quality.....

And then, when people have platinumed said games and spoken about them long enough and XBOX fans have trolled these games enough online, you know there will be something...Spiderman=Puddles, Ellie is a Lesbian, they will bring something up for Tsushima as well.....Ohhh and don't forget +30 on Meta for Sony games....Cerny will come walking on Stage and do what he does best destroy Fake hype and FUD dreams.....The event will be called DejaVu 2.0, only this time Cerny's mastering of the Tiger-Crane technique will be even more vicious and lethal.....One hit, One kill...….November 2020, book it...

Bruh... First off:

1) Penello would know an ass load more than any Gaffer here. I'd take his word above the armchair specialists on this forum any day of the week and twice on Sundays, Taco Tuesdays and Freaky Fridays!

2) I cant swing the"right now, the games are on Playstation" as I simply dont share that perspective. At All. Sony games dont interest me. If you do, thats great! I just dont share your sentiments on the matter. And there are many, many more who feel the same way.

3) I suppose you're attempting to foreshadow your thoughts about power by naming off past generations? Yea, not buying it. Power is a big deal. It's not the only metric by which to gauge success for a specific console, but it plays a huge role - if it didn't - we wouldnt have new generations to begin with. And if Sony believed that themselves, they'd just outright cancel the PS5 instead of making excuses for it. Cause guess what; POWER MATTERS. And it'll matter among the majority of the gaming community if the PS5 happens to be 9TF in light of Series X 12Tf. This is the start of a NEW GENERATION. Power is always one of the first bullet points they touch on in the initial pitch when introducing new generations. Check your history.

You also forget, Power isnt just for the fans, its also for devs. They need more power to create better games. So, yeah broski. IT MATTERS.

4) You're HOPING Sony is just biding it's time before revealing the PS5 by way of just allowing the current generation to play out. I can understand that. You dont know that though, though I'll admit you could be right. But I dont believe that to be the only reason. Literally, when they could've just offered to display a digital release of the GDC conference, but instead, said nothing, and still haven't.......that tells me they took that out for a reason and it wasnt just the Corona Virus. That says they aren't ready. And when you add in they showed their fans a god damn logo -- that's just sloppy.
Power matters, like it did in 2013 right....I hope you were a power matters guy in 2013 and not a "balanced console" and TV TV TV guy......

When PS5 is revealed to be more powerful than Series X, I want to see more of that powerplay from you....

Sony is probably doing whatever revisions they can. Probably caught off guard by MS specs. Nothing major probably just tweaking clock speeds. They sure as hell not gonna release a 9.2 and have that prophecy come true. Probably 10tf.
MS is caught off guard by Sony specs, just like in 2013.....It's too low......Cerny is grinning....He is saying. these foos never learn....Deja Vu 2.0....
No doubt.

I stopped playing HB after the first hour. It was easily the most overhyped piece of crap I played. I'd estimate in that hour, there was about 10 minutes of actual gameplay walking around, doing those red sign things and a couple fights.

The rest was mandatory cut scenes.

Wouldn't be as bad if I could skip the cut scenes and move on. But you couldn't.

It was a perfect game for a sub plan like GP. If I paid even $5 for it, I'd feel ripped off. It was barely a game. Watching videos later on, the rest of the game isn't much better. More cut scenes and repetitive fights against the same mob of raggy vulture men.
Really and people beat on The Order 1886 so, beyond the stealth sections and the early claustrophobic levels, 1886 was more game than Hell Blade will ever be....
 
The bravado these hardcore Xbox fans have is something to behold. If you didn't know anything about gaming, you would swear Microsoft is absolutely dominating the industry by their posts. I hope the PS5 is less powerful, just for their own mental health. Its morbidly fascinating how much of their gaming self worth is tied to that.

I don't think people are acting like Microsoft is absolutely dominating the industry, but more that Microsoft is exuding a great deal of confidence and acting like a company who believes they aren't anything less than a market leader. What you're experiencing is Microsoft in a very comfortable place with all their next gen plans.
 
There does indeed seem to be a lot of salt in this thread.

But most of it isn't from Ponies. Yeesh. :messenger_tears_of_joy:

OT: I don't quite think it worked wonders yet. People are still looking more at games than they are the Tflops of a console they can't even touch for a few years, and hardly anyone's even talking about MS's version of Cross-Buy anymore.

Besides, Sony's clearly got more pertinent things to talk about at the moment. I'd be more focused on setting up the successful launch of 5 big games (P5R, RE3 which they have the marketing deal for, FF7R, TLOU II, and Ghost of Tsushima) in the next 4 months than a console launching in 9 months as well right now.
 

Iced Arcade

Member
Probably not much to say... these 2 consoles are probably identical.

But we will still get "MS wizards" and "Mark Cerny is great" even though they are made by AMD lol
 
Wait, wha?? Not being disingenuous at all. The base PS4 was selling like hot cakes. They still introduced the Ps4 Pro, regardless. Did that slow anything down for Sony?
They did, BUT they also didn't heavily market the Pro and treated it as a niche product rather than making it their focus. They still focused on the PS4 as a whole, not just the latest version.

This is a console in an entirely new gen though, so it's not really comparable to the Pro. You don't want to get eyes off the product you already have out too soon.
 
Probably not much to say... these 2 consoles are probably identical.

But we will still get "MS wizards" and "Mark Cerny is great" even though they are made by AMD lol
The parts are manufactured by AMD, but the consoles themselves, as well as their internal and custom architectures, are made by the architects.

In this case, Mark Cerny and... I'm actually not sure who has that role at MS, tbh. :/
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Ya know, CyberPanda CyberPanda , You shouldn't have posted that article and I admit I shouldn't have an opinion that could possibly be construed as praising Xbox and/or questioning anything about Playstation. It's kind of like the SJW garbage over at the asylum, there is an accepted narrative and you shouldn't say, think or post anything to the contrary. Thank God for the Mods here, at least we don't get banned for posting an opinion that goes against the accepted narrative.

You have a TON of Sony fans howling at Sony for their silence in the NextGen Spec thread, but in this thread you've got a ton of Sony fans in full damage control, criticizing everything about Xbox while making excuses and defending Sony's silence.

BTW: Sony fans in case you weren't aware, the PS5 is said to be BC with the PS4 games so the games they are releasing can be bought and played on the PS4 now and also later on the PS5 maybe even with free upgrades like MS & CDPR are doing for the XsX so that excuse seems a little weak.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
These kind of articles were always going to happen. This is all on Sony and they ridiculous need for silence and secrecy.

They are content with giving literally months of news cycles away to MS. MS since x019 have talked about their cross gen plans, revealed the console form factor, showed two games, hinted at tflops then confirmed it along with a lot of features without Sony saying a goddamn word.

Its shocking how Sony is content with leaving ms with years of free press. They refuse to attend e3 and hold their own yearly psx conferences. They refuse to talk specs. They refuse to show games. They are canceling conferences left and right without any piece of good news to manage the blowback.

Meanwhile github leaks have gone mainstream gaming press like df and ign. Sony doesn't say a word. They are acting just like ms did last gen when there was a three month gap between Sony and ms conferences and all we heard was how online drm would hurt used game sales and forced kinect would hurt the games.

Ms never replied because it was all true. I'm really hoping that's not the case for Sony but they sure are acting like the guilty party.
 
These kind of articles were always going to happen. This is all on Sony and they ridiculous need for silence and secrecy.

They are content with giving literally months of news cycles away to MS. MS since x019 have talked about their cross gen plans, revealed the console form factor, showed two games, hinted at tflops then confirmed it along with a lot of features without Sony saying a goddamn word.

Its shocking how Sony is content with leaving ms with years of free press. They refuse to attend e3 and hold their own yearly psx conferences. They refuse to talk specs. They refuse to show games. They are canceling conferences left and right without any piece of good news to manage the blowback.

Meanwhile github leaks have gone mainstream gaming press like df and ign. Sony doesn't say a word. They are acting just like ms did last gen when there was a three month gap between Sony and ms conferences and all we heard was how online drm would hurt used game sales and forced kinect would hurt the games.

Ms never replied because it was all true. I'm really hoping that's not the case for Sony but they sure are acting like the guilty party.
Github leaks said RDNA1 and no Hardware Raytracing too. Both of these were already debunked, my guy.
 

Kagey K

Banned
They just announced that Ghost of Tsushima, a triple A exclusive, it's coming in june.

The PS4 in the end of the gen is getting/got: Dreams, Nioh 2, FFVII Remake, The Last of Us 2, Granblue Fantasy Versus , Disaster Report 4, Iron Man VR, Predator, Sakura Wars 4, Yakuza 7 and many more...

And guess what? Some of those might be released on PC or Switch, but none is announced to Xbox One...

Sony is screaming: Hey guys! We supported the PS1, PS2 and the PS3 until the end, and we are going to support the PS4 in the same way! Have fun!

While MS is saying: Fuck the One, here is the series X! Trust us! We won't fuck it up again... ok?

Why are you acting like the PS4 is dead? This is getting ridiculous.
There are 12 MS Game studios games announced as coming out this year with 2 of them coming this month. Of the other 10 only one is announced for Series X, and I’m sure there are more games to be announced (Either at E3 or their alternative event should it be cancelled.)

This idea that MS has dropped the one for the series X is a fallacy.

Most of the games you listed for Sony aren’t made or published by Sony, so they show 3rd parties are supporting Sony at the the end, not Sony themselves. I don’t know why people give them credit for games they don’t make.
 
Last edited:

HolyTruth

Banned
There are 12 MS Game studios announced as coming out this year with 2 of them coming this month. Of the other 10 only one is announced for Series X, and I’m sure there are more games to be announced (Either at E3 or their alternative event should it be cancelled.)

This idea that MS has dropped the one for the series X is a fallacy.

Most of the games you listed for Sony aren’t made or published by Sony, so they show 3rd parties are supporting Sony at the the end, not Sony themselves. I don’t know why people give them credit for games they don’t make.

plus they had plenty of time to reveal stuff in January and February.
So saying that games are the reason of being so quiet is invalid.
I mean they even started talking about PS5 with two wired articles in October - right when holiday season started. Why did they start then? Doesn’t make any sense.
 
Top Bottom