• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Who won E3 Week 2026?

Who won E3 Week 2026?

  • Total voters
    285
analog_future said:
Nearly all the Sony games shown at the State of Play are also coming to Xbox though.
Click to expand...
???
Every Sony first party game shown is not coming to Xbox. Until Dawn 2, Tokon, Wolverine, God of War Laufey.

Meanwhile with Xbox, all first party games shown except for E-Day (which was coming to PS5 and dropped at the last minute given the trailer still had the PS5 logo in some versions) and Clockwork Revolution are all coming to PS5.
 
HerjansEagleFeeder said:
People who voted Nintendo

Doc Rivers Basketball GIF
Click to expand...
8UcocoI.gif
 
Witchilich said:
Considering the State of Play showed actual Playststion exclusives, its funny that you think Xbox is above Sony. You even put Nintendo below Xbox, you can't be serious.
Click to expand...
By my count, the State of Play featured two new Sony exclusive announcements: Until Dawn and GoW:L. I'm sure both will sell well and please fans, but I can see how, as a show, people felt let down.

At least Laufey got gameplay, unlike Ocarina, which was a joke of an announcement.
 
Last edited:
SGF and Nintendo were both solid.

A couple things I'm interested in for Sony and MS.

Overall, there's a ton of games I'm interested in, so I'm just happy to be a gamer
 
SGF
State of Play
Nintendo
Xbox (Most of their stuff will be found elsewhere- so it props up other brands more than their own)

Overall, its a good year.
 
Last edited:
Zannegan said:
By my count, the State of Play featured two new Sony exclusives announcements: Until Dawn and GoW:L. I'm sure both will sell well and please fans, but I can see how, as a show, people felt let down.

At least Laufey got gameplay, unlike Ocarina, which was a joke of an announcement.
Click to expand...
Also Wolverine. I myself didn't claim Sony's show was the best. I am just asking Adam how he thinks Xbox show was better than Sony and Nintendo. Because a new Gears and Fable?
 
SGF -> Nintendo -> Xbox ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->Playstation
 
People voting for Nintendo must be trolling ;d Microsoft, Sony and Summer Game Fest were all decent even good but Nintendo Directo was like 4/10 max.
 
Last edited:
You cannot seriously vote Nintendo. Even I'm one of the biggest Nintendo fan since fucking gaming-age 99 in this place.

It was trash. Borderline Partner / Indie direct material. ~0 footage of Duskblood, ~0 footage of Zelda.

Announcing OOT with nothing to show for it doesn't move the needle, even worse that its 2026 and that's all you could muster.
 
Last edited:
The only reasonable way to quantify who won is by viewing figures, but who really gives a shit who won?

There are plenty of games from each show that I am pumped about. There's really no need to segregate them.
 
Dorito Pope's show was the most tradional show and I like most of it. These shows need a bit of pretentious glamour and terrible big name appearances. Those breaks are good, to make the actual stuff shine.
The PC Gamer show was also quite insane from its pacing. Way too many games trying to compete with our attention. Decent quality overall though and not at all a borefest past PC Gamer shows have been.
PS and Xbox quite on par imho. Not super great, hate the uninspired trailer dumping, but nothing was truly terrible.
Nintendo though. What a shitshow. I hate that Direct format since its inception, which others copied. And the games... many late ports or total crap.
Can't wrap my head around the taste of especially japanese people who prefer that offering. If I'd actually wanted a mobile gaming device I'd certainly choose among the Steamdeck alternatives or try Game Native etc on my phone.
 
Summer Games Fest was the best. Geoff finally made a worthy show. Nintendo had a lot of what I like. Sony was pretty boring to me. I am interested in Wolverine, but the blood and how it washes off constantly were distracting for me.
 
Witchilich said:
Also Wolverine. I myself didn't claim Sony's show was the best. I am just asking Adam how he thinks Xbox show was better than Sony and Nintendo. Because a new Gears and Fable?
Click to expand...
MS announced a fair number of upcoming projects too. Most aren't my bag, but if you're into shooters, there was a lot of future content shown. That Magicians game tickled my brain.

My idea of a good show is biased towards new announcements too, which is why SGF takes the cake this year.
 
It's strange, there was a lot of interested games getting announced, but the events and trailers were so bland that blew a lot of excitement that they could generate. Everyone forgot that those events were supposed to be developers talking with the player, not marketing botox based people.
 
Geoff i think, his best show for a considerable time . The others had some nice moments but SGF was comfortably the most enjoyable imo.

Not feeling the adulation for Xbox's show at all but I kind of expected that because some of the same folk did it when Phil was there and Sony's was pretty meh to say the least.
 
Last edited:
FoxMcChief said:
Well, that depends….
Click to expand...
Dunno what you mean I've seen more games to be excited about that I was hoping for (which was 0 lol)

Just with Stellar Blade 2 looking amazing, Dragon's Dogma 2 getting a DLC and OOT getting a remake (that I really hope they don't fuck up) is enough for me.
 
1. SGF - A-. The pacing, announcements, and Tupac made it wonderful.

2. State of Play - B+. Their first-party is (mostly) clocked out this gen, so the person who signed their third-party deals deserves a big fat bonus. Ill looks fantastic, Ace Combat 8 looks like it's leaning into the right kind of silly, Tomb Raider looked great, etc. UD2 could be something special, and Laufey — after rewatching the entire gameplay thing — is waaaaay more interesting than I initially thought.

3. Xbox Show - C-. Gears looked like Gears, Fable is delayed yet again, Fallout is still a snoozer, Persona 6 trailer wins the award for the most useless trailer since the first announcement of Concord (the space bobblehead trailer), list goes on. Metro and Spyro looked great as did that one game where you play as a bird. Their post show messaging is yet again a clusterfuck of he say/she say. Odd stuff happening over there.

4. Nintendo Direct - F. Could've been an AI email.
 
there is only one answer it's the SGF

the other shows were all terrible (like it's often the case)
 
Last edited:
From a multiplatform perspective:

1. SGF
2. Xbox
3. PlayStation
4. Nintendo

Based just on exclusives Nintendo/PlayStation were bad and Xbox was terrible.
 
Mownoc said:
From a multiplatform perspective:

1. SGF
2. Xbox
3. PlayStation
4. Nintendo

Based just on exclusives Nintendo/PlayStation were bad and Xbox was terrible.
Click to expand...
What???
Most/many of the (non first party) games Nintendo shown is coming to PC. In fact, the following already have Steam pages:
- Final Fantasy Resonance
- One Piece: Grand Gourmet
- Muramasa
- Pikuniku 2
- Atelier Karia

And these are confirmed to be released on PC as well:
- Kingdom Hearts 4
- Dragon Quest Monsters
- Tales of Eternia Remastered
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Famitsu Sales: Week 21, 2026 (May 18 - May 24)
33
475
Sohurmk833 replied
Famitsu Sales: Week 22, 2026 (May 25 - May 31)
Sales-Age 
30
178
S0ULZB0URNE replied
  • Poll
Who "won" in the 7th Generation of consoles?
2 3 4
162
865
Deerock71 replied
Famitsu: Week 17, 2026 (Apr 20 - Apr 26)
Sales-Age 
19
526
LordOcidax replied
Famitsu: Week 16, 2026 (Apr 13 - Apr 19)
Sales-Age 
47
945
Impotaku replied
Top Bottom