I'm not shy about my dislike toward TLoU2, but It's less a bout TLoU2 and more about how the guy who ran GoTY Tracker in 2020 handled that year, and the standards of who gets counted toward the aggerate.
I've argued for a prestige Game of the Year award for years now, to separate that award from the rest of them. Obviously there's TGAs, but they still title their award Game of the Year. There's only one Best Picture every year, but there's 400-600 (depending) Game of the Year awards every year. It's stupid and something should change. Cyberpunk 2077 is getting a Game of the Year Edition. I really love Cyberpunk, but game of the year it was not, and most people know that. But it technically won a game of the year award, so now they can release the game and call the game that.