in starfield at least you get factions you can be apart of. there is more progression in these factions
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Is Cyberpunk much better than Starfield?
- Thread starter BootsLoader
- Start date
Ass of Can Whooping
Gold Member
Those are literary just quest lines
Last edited:
Have you even played CP? You realize there are central gangs depending on where you are on the map, and the reason you don't "join" them is because you are a mercenary, right? lol
ReBurn
Gold Member
I'm not sure it's about preference as much as it is impression. No Man's Sky isn't the same game it was when it released. But at release it failed to live up to standard Sean Murray set for it and that's the impression most people were left with. There are so many new games releasing all the time that it's not surprising that people would want to try new ones before they go back and try an old one that they didn't like the first time. Plus, not everyone who plays games follows them in discussions like this. People who played NMS at launch may not know that the game is better now.
So I don't think it's as much liking to play average games over good games as much as it is developers blowing their opportunity to create a memorable experience the first time around. CP2077 is going to suffer from that with this update and Starfield will as it receives updates. Old games that get fixed aren't going to get the same attention as new games.
graywolf323
Member
Last edited:
tmlDan
Member
im sorry to hear that, FF16 has a far better soundtrack.
Drizzlehell
Banned
Last edited:
BootsLoader
Banned
I also thing the same. It looks like an action game because the gameplay is fast paced maybe?
GymWolf
Member
I'm gonna be super real here.
What they did with the new system was just remixing most of the elements that were already there in a better way and with some cool addon like the long dash or some cool melee moves.
But like, most of the melee was already there, the hacking was there, the gun personalization was there etc, now it just make more sense, even the new relic system in the dlc with cool stuff like applying hacks with the monowire is just combining 2 elements that were already in the game, monowire+hacks.
If you didn't liked how gunplay and melee felt at launch, you are not gonna find much difference with 2.0, IA is still hit and miss (but better).
Police system is still all kinda of clunky and clearly not designed from the core.
It is a way better system but hardly a revolution.
They fixed some builds but also broken others like total stealth hacking not being feasible anymore and no suppressors on magnum so you have less option for one-shot weapons during stealth.
Last edited:
CatLady
Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Ah thank you. I said I didn't remember the quests very well. I KNEW there was some damn lesbian trying to get in my pants, just screwed up their names.
Hoddi
Member
I'd just try to play both. The cost of entry isn't high these days and I think both are damn great.
If you're playing on PC then it might be a good idea to start with Cyberpunk and wait for more Starfield patches/mods. It's already shooting up the ranks on Nexusmods and will only get better once the Creation Kit is released next year.
If you're playing on PC then it might be a good idea to start with Cyberpunk and wait for more Starfield patches/mods. It's already shooting up the ranks on Nexusmods and will only get better once the Creation Kit is released next year.
Punished Miku
Member
I haven't heard the entire FFXVI OST yet since it's not on streaming services and it's so huge. FF always has top tier music. It's a huge downside though that he didn't record any of it with live instruments. Pretty surprising honestly given some of the high quality audio stuff they put even into stuff like FFX HD, which sonically sounds 100x better than XVI.
Starfield OST is really unique to gaming. Reminds me at times of a classic Alfred Hitchcock movie melody, or 70s sci-fi and it all sounds great. I was just checking out a full live concert for it yesterday they already put on youtube. It's the best OST Bethesda has had in a game since Morrowind. So many timeless themes and strong melodies that are blended into atmospheric, soundscape-ish orchestration that fits with a more open world setting. Combining those two things well is difficult and he does it over and over. Easily the best OST of Inon Zurr's entire career.
If you're into XVI that's fine. I literally just said what I like. You can keep your sympathy lol.
Last edited:
Drizzlehell
Banned
I think half of GAF is now under an impression that if you don't roll a dice for every action and fuck bears in the woods then it's not an RPG anymore.
MagiusNecros
Gilgamesh Fan Annoyance
Pretty sure the meat of both games are in the dynamic sidequests. Witcher 3 was the same way. I enjoyed Witcher Contracts more then the actual main quest.
Faction Questlines and key "Missions" in Starfield set up lore and Universe building. Stuff like Terrormorphs, Derelict Ships, Alien Life on O2 filled planets, cross faction skirmishs in Space all serves to flesh out the Universe.
Sidequests in CP serve to increase your reputation but also flesh out what Night City is like and how Nomads, Street Gangs, Police Forces, Corporations, Netrunners all interact with each other. Kinda wish I could play as a NCPD Officer though. Would be fun to just be a Cybernetic Supercop instead of Mercenary.
Not sure why we need to play this game of "my game is better then your game".
Faction Questlines and key "Missions" in Starfield set up lore and Universe building. Stuff like Terrormorphs, Derelict Ships, Alien Life on O2 filled planets, cross faction skirmishs in Space all serves to flesh out the Universe.
Sidequests in CP serve to increase your reputation but also flesh out what Night City is like and how Nomads, Street Gangs, Police Forces, Corporations, Netrunners all interact with each other. Kinda wish I could play as a NCPD Officer though. Would be fun to just be a Cybernetic Supercop instead of Mercenary.
Not sure why we need to play this game of "my game is better then your game".
Madserb2023
Member
Cyberpunk is objectively a better game on just about any metric I can conceive but I would rather play Starfield. I have no idea why.
cinnamonandgravy
Member
both looked pretty lame though.
starfield has enemies just standing in the open and shooting and overall looks tame.
cyberpunk's mech has terrible aim and a bunch of scripted events where you're invincible.
havent played either, but gonna play both.
starfield has enemies just standing in the open and shooting and overall looks tame.
cyberpunk's mech has terrible aim and a bunch of scripted events where you're invincible.
havent played either, but gonna play both.
JohnnyFootball
GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
On my new playthorough I’m playing as a dude for that reason.
Panam! My dude looks like Keanu Reeves, so i know the ending I’m going for.
You really have nothing better to do than come in a thread about two games, neither of which you've played, just to say "they look lame"?
Gamer_By_Proxy
Member
Gavon West
Spread's Cheeks for Intrusive Ads
I can't really say but, I do know that I have NEVER witnessed a game talked about or compared to as Starfield - especially for this long. It's genuinely suprising to me.
Topher
Gold Member
Someone said the update nerfed all the Cyberpunk mods. Sucks if true.
Kacho
Member
Jermey Soule did the Oblivion soundtrack
random side quests arent a actual
cyberpunk gameplay loop is do mission get bigger gun repeat ,there is zero exploration unlike starfield that at least breaks up the autonomy of it all, also most npc in starfield you can talk to while cybperunk npsc are all props
Gambit2483
Member
Starfield's music is good/great but honestly imo it just comes across as "generic space epic fluff." It doesn't stick with me or feel like it has distinct themes the way other games like FF16 or TOTK does.
Ass of Can Whooping
Gold Member
Oh so Zur's new? Thought it was all the same person. Lol wild since this soundtrack is so similar to F4
Random sidequests? Bro, there is an entire storyline involving multiple quests and street races lmaoooo
Punished Miku
Member
I wouldn't be surprised if most people feel that way honestly. But I am just stunned by the amount of memorable melodies and themes in the game. As I said above, they are purposefully blended into more soundscape orchestration so they don't interfere with immersion in an open world setting and risk oversaturation, but the melodies are there and there's a ton. The main theme, and a dozen more tracks. The New Atlantis track instantly transports me to that area. Been listening to it in my car a ton, and even that has a really nice melody hidden in the middle / end of the song blended in.
Ass of Can Whooping
Gold Member
It's a quest line just like Bethesda's factions
BigLee74
Member
Exactly. Both games are great, do different things that scratch different itches, and I recommend nobody sleeps on either if they have the means to play them!
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
Jeremy Soule did Oblivions music fam
His work crushes anything Invader Zur has done in my opinion.
Last edited:
James Sawyer Ford
Gold Member
Starfield has a great theme song and that is it
Everything else is generic and unmemorable
Punished Miku
Member
He did Fallout 4, Soul Calibur V, parts of Dragon's Dogma, Dragon Age, dozens of games. An extremely prolific composer. My previous favorite of his was Prince of Persia (2008).
Inon Zur - Wikipedia
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
I like the chill and ambient atmospheric stuff in it.
But yeah, nothing touches Soule's work he did with Howard & co. His compositions really gave those games identities and feels in ways I cant put into words.
JohnnyFootball
GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
Witcher 3 and Fallout 3 are better games than both of them.
Punished Miku
Member
1) Morrowind
2) Starfield
3) Oblivion
4) Everything else from BGS
That's my personal OST ranking from them. I'd have to revisit Fallout 3. Been a long time.
DragonNCM
Member
I will agree with this but I have more fun with Starfield then Cyberpunk, there is so much to do in Starfield then CP 2077. I have 5 days played in Starfield & even didn't scratch main story, I'm doing random faction/mission quests, have fun with Starship builder/outpost builder & exploring planets/moons. There is strange magics in Starfield what I cant find in CP 2077.
KingXtreme81
Member
Immeasurably so, in every single way.
Topher
Gold Member
No magic in CP, but you have the cyberwar and quick hacks.
Fredrik
Member
I’ve just played it too much can’t say anything particularly negative about it, was my GOTY and is on my all-time top 10, definitely a RPG.
Starfield just released though and it’s strangely addictive and I have more stuff to do and I just enjoy it more right now.
No idea what I would think if both were unplayed.
Kacho
Member
Not new but he did the Fallout games which also had lame, forgettable soundtracks.
Last edited:
Antwix
Member
At least I can actually play Starfield. I played Cyberpunk at launch and don't remember my game crashing at all. Maybe once or twice, I don't know, but that fact that I don't remember it means it probably was rare for me. This latest trash they just put out crashes more than it works.
Guess I'll wait a bit longer to experience the so called "greatest redemption arc in gaming".
Guess I'll wait a bit longer to experience the so called "greatest redemption arc in gaming".
Punished Miku
Member
Gambit2483
Kacho
I'll just post one last time on it since I haven't really had much chance to discuss the OST in detail with people yet. I don't expect most people to really agree with me though so no worries.I've played the entire game on headphones so far, and it's just so cool to be playing really long and immersive sessions with a lot of background ambience, and then out of nowhere a strong melody like this just floats in. You barely even notice it start it's so well blended into the rest of the sound, but he just really leans into simple and catchy and then blends back out before you even fully stop to mentally take note of it.
Or just exploring the surface of Mars next to that giant landing pad and out of nowhere you get this pseudo Interstellar-lite melody at 1:17 while you're just out exploring and you're just like damn where did that shit come from? Then fades back out seamlessly.
New Atlantis is like an ambient Mass Effect Presidium style track, and then out of nowhere he just drops this catchy Morrowind style melody in your ear at 2:50 and then it floats away before you mentally stop to take you out of the moment.
Almost every track is like this. Just tons of super catchy melody perfectly blended in all over, but still serving the purpose of immersion. I posted the Triumvarate track earlier, but that has a sick melody just drop once at 1:45 that really catches my ear, and then it floats away. Peaks and Valleys has a sick, super subtle flute part that I love at around 2:00 where they change to a new line with the rest of the orchestra cutting out, and then they just slowly lay into the heavy, darker melody overlapping. Just sick as fuck. And then it changes again after that to another really cool melody at 3:00. A masterpiece of a track.
Last edited:
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
To me, Starfield felt like some of the most awesome shit ever for about 15 hours. Then I was all of a sudden like "Okay I get it" and just rapidly lost interest to continue.
But Cyberpunk Im playing 2.0 and the DLC right now for my 3rd play through, and its still awesome the whole way throughout. Actually even better than ever with the 2.0 improvements.
But Cyberpunk Im playing 2.0 and the DLC right now for my 3rd play through, and its still awesome the whole way throughout. Actually even better than ever with the 2.0 improvements.
DeepSpace5D
Member
Just visually Cyberpunk looks objectively much better in that comparison video.
SEGAvangelist
Member
Whether you like Starfield or not, it has one of the greatest soundtracks in gaming history, IMO.
Clintizzle
Lord of Edge.
Cyberpunk has better female modelling. Easy win.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
- Poll