• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Star Wars Eclipse has development issues

KyoZz

Tag, you're it.
unknown.png


Reliable games industry insider Tom Henderson is bringing some bad news, as it seems like Quantic Dream is struggling with it's next project, Star Wars Eclipse:



  • Eclipse originally started as an MMORPG nicknamed Project Karma that Sony rejected for Detroit. Quantic Dream then used the assets from Karma to pitch Lucasfilm a new Star Wars game.
  • Quantic Dream was looking to sell itself after Detroit to get more resources but the workplace accusations drove away all the buyers.
  • QD's engine is causing problems for Eclipse cause it was only designed for confined levels and limited amount of NPC's.
  • Studio is struggling to create the multiplayer side of the game.
  • Game has been in development for over 18 months but the studio still has no playable version.
  • QD is having staffing problems due to allegations.
Source
 
Disney needs to just stop giving out Star Wars licenses to just anyone. There are millions of fervent Star Wars fans, and we all deserve a few good Star Wars games. The Fallen Order was the last one, and hopefully the Kotor Remake will be a good one as well.
 

Men_in_Boxes

Snake Oil Salesman
How to create a fake inside scoop in 4 easy steps...

1. Pick a game that's 4 years away from release so no one remembers your fake inside scoop when it nears release.

2. Make sure the game has a big name (Star Wars) so your fake scoop draws traffic.

3. Pick a company that people hate so that they more readily believe the bad news.

4. Profit.
 
Last edited:

wipeout364

Member
Why would quantic dream make a MMORPG. They can’t even nail down decent mechanics in their choose your own adventure “games”.

Anyway at least somebody at Sony had enough brains to step away from that dumpster fire.
 

KyoZz

Tag, you're it.
"News" doesn't mean what you think it means.

News = officially confirmed
Something some dude on the internet says without presenting any evidence or backing whatsoever = shaky weak rumor to take with the usual big grain of salt.
Stop It GIF by GIPHY News


If it's just bullshit as you said, why you care? It is marked as RUMOR. Not to mention that Tom Henderson is one of the most reliable insider.
Now if you just wanna argue against a word you won't get any more reply from me
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
What Twitter outrage?
That they chose the “evil” David Cage’s QD for a Star Wars game. From the same ole purity test cultist crazies.

I feel tremor in the force, as if this game will be attacked from all angles with “rumors and speculation” over the next few years.
 
Last edited:

mckmas8808

Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
That they chose the “evil” David Cage’s QD for a Star Wars game. From the same ole purity test cultist crazies.

I feel tremor in the force, as if this game will be attacked from all angles with “rumors and speculation” over the next few years.

Oh I see what you're saying. Do you personally think David Cage did any of those things or is running a bad ship over there at QD?
 
Sony’s forthcoming MP offerings do need to embrace colour, randomness and variety. As much as I loved Killzone, Resistance etc, things have moved on a bit.

Blink 182 Reaction GIF


Did you just wake up from a coma for the past 15 years or something?

Killzone, Resistance? What...What years is this?

In case you missed the past the past few years, here's a quick recap of actual new games from Sony's offerings.

61a8845b19ac7c894701c930ae5197c5f065a489.jpg

kena-bridge-of-spirits-how-long-does-it-take-to-beat-ps5-ps4-guide.large.jpg

976a6e51-cded-11eb-afbe-8677d96619ae.cf.jpg

astro-bot-insights-and-artwork.jpg


I have zero clue as to why you somehow sit there saying we've been stuck in piss color filter, and brown shit tones for the past decade.
 

Abriael_GN

RSI Employee of the Year
is one of the most reliable insider.

People spreading around these silly rumors always say their source is a "reliable insider" 😂

Keep rumormongering if that floats your boat. I'll keep pointing out that news is something else, bad or otherwise.
 

Spaceman292

Banned
"News" doesn't mean what you think it means.

News = officially confirmed
Something some dude on the internet says without presenting any evidence or backing whatsoever = shaky weak rumor to take with the usual big grain of salt.
"Dude trust me"

That being said this all sounds like things someone could easily deduce.
 

cyberheater

PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
I don’t know why devs don’t all use the Unreal engine.
 

Polygonal_Sprite

Gold Member
What SW games are in development just now. Jedi Order 2 and isn’t Ubisoft making one?

I remember a rumour about BioWare making basically ME Star Wars RPG aswell.
 

kyussman

Member
I'm kinda over Star Wars anyway at this point......I was kinda over it in 1983 if I'm honest(although I did have a lot of fun with that first Battlefront reboot,it wasn't an amazing game but it did give me a lot of nostalgia and made me feel like a kid playing with his action figures again).
 

yurinka

Member
  • Eclipse originally started as an MMORPG nicknamed Project Karma that Sony rejected for Detroit. Quantic Dream then used the assets from Karma to pitch Lucasfilm a new Star Wars game.
  • Quantic Dream was looking to sell itself after Detroit to get more resources but the workplace accusations drove away all the buyers.
  • QD's engine is causing problems for Eclipse cause it was only designed for confined levels and limited amount of NPC's.
  • Studio is struggling to create the multiplayer side of the game.
  • Game has been in development for over 18 months but the studio still has no playable version.
  • QD is having staffing problems due to allegations.
Source
Almost everything here sounds as fake news.

Why would quantic dream make a MMORPG. They can’t even nail down decent mechanics in their choose your own adventure “games”.

Anyway at least somebody at Sony had enough brains to step away from that dumpster fire.
They are the best ones making these cinematic adventure games, I suggest you to play Detroit. It's a great game, their gameplay and mechanics are totally fine, there's nothing wrong with them.

The game got good reviews and is the best selling QD game ever. Sony didn't step away, they decided to make multiplatform games and become a publisher to be more profitable, opened a new studio and got the Star Wars IP so got -and will be- busy for a while. But when they went multi also said that weren't closing the doors to work again for Sony somewhere in the future.

So maybe they have a 2nd project for Sony, or they could sign a game with Sony after the Star Wars game.


What SW games are in development just now. Jedi Order 2 and isn’t Ubisoft making one?

I remember a rumour about BioWare making basically ME Star Wars RPG aswell.
There's the KOTOR remake and a F2P that I'm not sure if it's for mobile.

Lol... wut.

18 months is not a long time at all, especially if they're including pre-production. So this doesn't sound atypical at all.
According to the game's website it's in early development, which means its development started a few months ago after completing its pre-production and that it's years away from its release.

Development is considered production, not pre-production. Early development doesn't mean 18 months of production, so at least this part is fake news.

If we add a few months of development/production and a year or so of preproduction (which would be normal for a AAA based on a licensed IP where they have to negotiate and double check many lore and licensing stuff) then yes, they could have been working on it for 18 months or so.
 
Last edited:

KyoZz

Tag, you're it.
People spreading around these silly rumors always say their source is a "reliable insider" 😂

Keep rumormongering if that floats your boat. I'll keep pointing out that news is something else, bad or otherwise.
K, grumpy kid
Keep acting like he didn't leak a tons of information about games, and like he didn't put a BIG disclaimer at the beginning of this video.

I suppose you have to be mad about something 🤷‍♂️
 

Fbh

Member
Shame, the vibe of the trailer was nice.

Then again it's quantic Dream so I never had high hopes.
 

wipeout364

Member
Almost everything here sounds as fake news.


They are the best ones making these cinematic adventure games, I suggest you to play Detroit. It's a great game, their gameplay and mechanics are totally fine, there's nothing wrong with them.

The game got good reviews and is the best selling QD game ever. Sony didn't step away, they decided to make multiplatform games and become a publisher to be more profitable, opened a new studio and got the Star Wars IP so got -and will be- busy for a while. But when they went multi also said that weren't closing the doors to work again for Sony somewhere in the future.

So maybe they have a 2nd project for Sony, or they could sign a game with Sony after the Star Wars game.
So after suffering through Fahrenheit, Heavy Rain, and Two Souls all of which had terrible gameplay. They really have quite bad story beats if you take a step back and look at them. So now you tell me to play another one of their games. No thanks, I have been more then generous with my time and money for those guys.
 
Last edited:

EverydayBeast

thinks Halo Infinite is a new graphical benchmark
Star Wars games will start clicking soon I want another next gen battlefront game from Dice minus the loot boxes.
 

ReBurn

Gold Member
Good Question

No one asked for this I can't even bring myself to get hyped for a QD Star Wars game
I mean we don't ask for most of the games that are announced. Except maybe for the incessant begging for remakes of games we just played a few years ago I guess.

Who knows, press x to "Vader!" and pul back on both sticks to force choke could be just what we need. lol
 
Good.

Fuck David Cage and fuck Quantic Dreams. I never understood why people like their so called "games" they are nothing but a bunch of highly interactive novels with cringe dialogue, bad writing and non existing gameplay.

When it was revealed this game was being made by them I knew it was already a shit show.

Sorry to sound negative, I just dislike this developer.

Besides isn't the Bioware Star Wars MMO still doing decent and has an expansion coming?
 
Last edited:

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
Like every game at some point?

Or is it just easy for the hyperbole train to hear one thing and make mountains out of mole hills?
 
"Dude trust me"

That being said this all sounds like things someone could easily deduce.

Tom Henderson has pretty much been 100% on everything he’s leaked over the past year.

Out of all the fake twitter insiders i actually have no reason to doubt him at this point. Everyone was calling bullshit on his twisted metal 2023 tweet then a couple weeks later VGC and Grubb said they also heard about it and now it pretty much confirmed through Lucid’s linkedin and job postings. Not even Jaffe knew

Same with all his battlefield info
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom