• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Dirt 5: Digital Foundry Console Comparison - PlayStation 5 vs Xbox Series X/Series S + Performance - Every Game Mode Tested

NullZ3r0

Banned
Well devs tend to think its the most mature tools they have used on xbox platform.at launch

Dirt 5 lead tech dev:

1mnloqR.jpg

I wouldn't believe words from few fans over senior lead technical devs
Says the guy with a marketing deal with MS. What the hell was he supposed to say?
 

Mr Moose

Member
Sure, you will find plenty of cases in YouTube, but that’s not the point. I don’t recall seeing that many reports at Neogaf during launch, and I was visiting daily. I sincerely didn’t feel it was a problem then, but now it’s surfacing more than I would like to be comfortable.
Social media is bigger than it was 7 years ago, its normal for hardware to fail especially at or around launch.
Why don't YouTube videos count? It shows the same issues around launch for both consoles. "I don’t recall PS4 or X1 having this issues at launch. " They did.
 

Great Hair

Banned
Xbox Series X is an up-to 4K console. Series S is an up-to 1440p machine. But there are exceptions. Some Series S games run in 4K or 1800p (Ori and the Falconeer) and most will run at around 1440p.

Like all consoles, it will depend on whether the developer favors prettier pixels or higher FPS.

Have to disagree.
The Series S is a blurry mess at $299. (Dirt5 120fps XvS, MHOW 60fps XvS)

 

FALCON_KICK

Member
Damn a lot of you must be really young or some hardcore fanboys to be this immature and toxic over something like this. Judging launch titles lol what a joke

This is perfectly demonstrated on the PS4 after the release day patch has been installed: 1080p visuals allow the intricate artwork to shine, while the rock solid 30fps update means that control is never disrupted outside of the game's somewhat erratic animation blending system and automated climbing mechanics. The Xbox One version unfortunately has a harder time delivering the same accomplishments, due to the lower 900p resolution and sharpening filter giving the game a much rougher look.

On that note it's clear that the PS4 game is the definitive release of Assassin's Creed 4 on the console formats.

Microsoft Xbox had to remove features from Xbox One and even Kinect within a year to close the performance gap.
 
Last edited:

Dodkrake

Banned
Loading on Sony's SSD is amazing, quick resume, which is just a name for fast loading is unneeded, gotcha!

This reminds me of how people say Game Pass sucks until Sony starts talking about maybe having an answer to it then all of a sudden it's "Sony's going for the kill!" So it is good?
Sony already has a gamepass like service. It's called PSNow and has 3x more games than gamepass
 

Greggy

Member
The MS PR lies has nothing to do with Dirt 5 others modes not being identical like you tried to claim.

PS5 has better AF, textures and performance in all modes expect 120hz where PS5 has better graphics, AF and textures with the unexpected better LOD models and worst framerate.

120Hz model on Xbox will be fixed to have parity in LOD models and so the framerate will tank because it will render more things.

You will come here to say.. I told you now it looks identical.
I will just say Yeap if you forget the worst performance.
You need to look up the definition of a bug. That’s what the developers will be addressing, a BUG. It’s not a reordering of their priorities.
 

freefornow

Gold Member
Wait, on Series X, am i supposed to have 3 settings for quality/resolution/framerate?? I only have quality/resolution?
Big update when i installed game, so assumed this was optimised for X version?
 

ethomaz

Banned
You need to look up the definition of a bug. That’s what the developers will be addressing, a BUG. It’s not a reordering of their priorities.
A big that makes the Xbox has better framerate.
Fixed the bug it will be probably like the 60fps mode.
 
Last edited:

Genx3

Member
Devs are being Lazy with the XSX version no doubt.
Horizon 4 looks way better than Dirt 5.
I wonder if they built the game around XSS and ported up to XSX.
Very lazy XSX version.
 
Last edited:

Traxtech

Member
Why are people comparing dirt to forza... First party VS third party multi platform game.

That's like comparing uncharted 4 to tomb raider in performance or graphics lol
 
Last edited:

Humdinger

Member
Hm, interesting! I was prepared for years of conceding that, "Yes, the XSX version (of any given multiplat) is a little better than the PS5 version, but it doesn't bother me." Interesting to see the shoe on the other foot.

Very surprising, actually. This is now the third multiplat with an edge for the PS5, right?

I expect that MS will eventually catch up, though, and then later pull ahead. We'll see how long it takes. In the meantime, if I had bought an XSX with the expectation of getting the best version of multiplats, I'd be disgruntled.
 
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏



A hint to Xbox FUD squad.
FUD worked before launch because anybody had the consoles in hands... so nobody could disprove your FUD.
It is useless now that everybody can see the reality at their homes.


Coping mechanisms starting to fail.....

And to think that dude was brought up here by the Xbox squad as a legitimate dev source earlier in the year spreading PS5 FUD..... :messenger_grinning_squinting:

So the PS5 version has better textures, much higher settings, performs at 120fps most of the time 90% to be exact. Yet John is talking about judder when the game performs better on PS5 even with higher settings, no need for vrs, much less tearing and of course at a higher average resolution. So John is telling me the Xbox version feels better with Vrr, even when it looks much better, performs much better and tears much less on 99% of gamer tv's. People are not interested in how this game is with features that are not standard, people are interested in the real framerates that they will play on their TV's.... This is a tech channel, people want to see the framerates, they want to see which tears more, not tech guys trying to hide these numbers behind Vrr..... Or a day when all tv's will have it. Even if I have Vrr, I want to know which console performs better.. That's the purpose of a face off...

I'd say, I've never seen a more apologetic video. Dark10x sounds nervous as if he has a gun to his head. So many deep sighs....."Oh this is strange", "This doesn't seem right", "Explain this to me Richard, it makes no sense"...... These guys sound like they need some counseling sessions after yet another surprise and shock.... Of course, as I said in the last thread, anytime a game performs worse on Xbox, DF contacts the devs, it's as if he is working for MS Pr and marketing... Any time there is a huge discrepancy "we contact the devs", clearly a lie Richard, you never contacted the devs for RER2, Xenoverse, Witcher 3, AC Unity for the PS4 versions.... You only contacted the devs for Titanfall 2 and now Dirt 2.....Yet I suspect they will be contacting many devs all gen long with this level of mental dissonance.

Also, we know Richard. VRR is a game changer for 1% of TV owners..... Funny, 1440p support was a game changer too because MS supports it, so the PR before the Series S launched was 1440p was so important by MS and DF, it was labeled as the series S resolution, yet since Series S is barely doing 1440p, hell, barely doing 1080p in this game with lows to 576p.....Richard resorts to... "there are not many if any 1440p tv's anyway" .... The way the wheels keep turning to cater to makes excuses at every turn where Xbox is deficient and to hype every obscure feature Xbox has as if were popular or standard.....

You could say you could feel their pain...
 
Last edited:

RoboFu

One of the green rats
I don’t get why it’s so heated? The biggest thing was the 120 hz mode and the dev confirmed it was a mistake and will be fixed soon. What else is there to talk about?
 
Last edited:

diffusionx

Gold Member
I don’t get why it’s so heated? The biggest thing was the 12o hz mode and the dev confirmed it was a mistake and will be fixed soon. What wise is there to talk about?

I agree - we should all just relax, go outside, hang out with some friends at the bar, maybe go see a movie, or go to the gym, or go to a restaurant and grab a bite to eat, stop focusing on this trivial stuff. Oh wait...

Okay then, we should just forget about all this and just go play our new video game systems. Oh wait...
 

RoboFu

One of the green rats
I agree - we should all just relax, go outside, hang out with some friends at the bar, maybe go see a movie, or go to the gym, or go to a restaurant and grab a bite to eat, stop focusing on this trivial stuff. Oh wait...

Okay then, we should just forget about all this and just go play our new video game systems. Oh wait...

What else is there people are talking about in this thread that pertain to the video that’s not about the 120 hz mode?
 

Shakka43

Member
Loading on Sony's SSD is amazing, quick resume, which is just a name for fast loading is unneeded, gotcha!

This reminds me of how people say Game Pass sucks until Sony starts talking about maybe having an answer to it then all of a sudden it's "Sony's going for the kill!" So it is good?
Game pass and PS now are the same shit with different names. All Sony has to do is put their games day one on PS Now to make it better than Game Pass.
 
This guy is truly pathetic. He hate fanboy but can't avoid to scream to the world how better he thinks to be compared them although he has exactly the same attitude if not worse. And the fuck it means remember neogaf? Jesus what a dickhead. I hate hypocrite like him

Who's he referring to lol? I have an idea. Battaglia absolutely hates NeoGaf doesn't he.

He is prone to childish outbursts and a massive fanboy himself. Pot. Kettle. Black.
 
Top Bottom