• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Microsoft Brasil downsizes Xbox News show, fires presenter and staff

I genuinely wonder, given his history, if OP thought this was a fascinating story, or wanted to score some points with one side of a 'harassment' story (we know how those go in 2020), against Xbox, lol.

I recall seeing this elsewhere on the board where Xbox said they were scaling down on news, and just wanted Xbox Wire from now on.

They are scaling down and that's exactly what happened. The thread implies causation when there's barely correlation. I do think however that most brazilian gamers are very crass, come on man we all know this it's not like I'm discovering the wheel here. But it's very disingenuous to suggest this is an Xbox issue, as I've met a gigantic amount of PS players who are absolute dickheads.

Nintendo fans in Brazil, on the other hand, are usually very polite and well endowed gentlemen. You guys can take my word for it.
 
Ethomaz and DGhost always doing their best with anti-MS thread titles. Literally a two man crew of click bait threads.

For my fans in the Xbox community, and god knows I have many, it's Codename: Classified now.

As for the topic, I think this has been discussed before. Maybe? The claim is suspect. At the same time I don't think we've gotten a denial from Microsoft about it. Just a counter narrative from fans of the brand trying to make Microsoft's case in the court of public opinion. Who needs lawyers then?
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
My understanding is that they let the whole crew go as they cancelled the show, completely unrelated to her abuse.

Then she's trying to spin it so she sounds like a victim for some sort of compensation.
She doesn't asked compensation (at least until today).
She just told what happened.
MS Brasil did not deny it and avoided to talk about the subject... all the big sites asked them with no response.
 
Last edited:

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
My understanding is that they let the whole crew go as they cancelled the show, completely unrelated to her abuse.

Then she's trying to spin it so she sounds like a victim for some sort of compensation.
Woudn't be surprised.

Gaming a wacko industry.

IN every company I've worked at, people get let go all the time. I've never seen or heard one of them go for revenge in social media, or call out bosses or anything like that.

In gaming, it's s fucking free for all of brats, where if something doesn't go their way, the first thing they so is........ hmmm..... call a labour lawyer? Settle things quietly?

Oh wait. Let's go on Twitter.

WTF?
 

sincarra

Member
So, if I’m getting this right, she was being harassed and Microsoft decided it would be in her best interest to remove her from that position. Regardless, though, it’s messed up that she was harassed in the first place and had to deal with all that shit. I
 

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
My reply was in regards to him saying what should we do, should we all cancel our pre-orders now?

all i was stating was he is a massive fanboy and would take more than an article for him to cancel his preorder. Nothing more, nothing less,

If people are going to be upset about PHIL SPENCER OF ALL PEOPLE ~Kidnapping their family and find that offense
Something is very very wrong.

Its clearly a joke and if people are being over sensitive and ridiculous for the sake of it.

My comments had nothing to do with Brazil's crime rate. jeez
Fair enough and not the mention, I don't know if the person is from Brazil or not, so I guess that was bad call on my part.
 

Fake

Member
He presented the facts without bias.... and I don't think you will get any of the Xbox community here posting negative news about the business.
It's just the way it has to be at the moment.

He is also fluent in Portuguese and he has more possible insight than the rest of us.

Ethomaz don't have a good history here and after his recent bans I can understand why people really don't trust his posts.
But ignoring all this bullshit and console wars around the GAF, people can't deny this information.
Anw, unfortunately all this is true. This is my main language as well. IDK why Microsoft Brazil took this decision. Is kinda weird.
 

sircaw

Banned
Fair enough and not the mention, I don't know if the person is from Brazil or not, so I guess that was bad call on my part.

It's my own fault, I need to stick to the spec thread, need to remember that not everyone has a sense of humor about things like this.

Just the thought of Phil spencer busting into a house talking people hostage, well i thought it was kinda funny and extremely mild for someone to get so upset about.
 
My reply was in regards to him saying what should we do, should we all cancel our pre-orders now?

all i was stating was he is a massive fanboy and would take more than an article for him to cancel his preorder. Nothing more, nothing less,

If people are going to be upset about PHIL SPENCER OF ALL PEOPLE ~Kidnapping their family and find that offense
Something is very very wrong.

Its clearly a joke and if people are being over sensitive and ridiculous for the sake of it.

My comments had nothing to do with Brazil's crime rate. jeez
Speak for yourself please.

I was being sarcastic with the cancel thing obviously, i'm not going to cancel the console i've been excited for over an Ethomaz news piece.

I am a fan of Xbox, and of gaming in general, not a "fanboy" and on top of that, i am an actual man and not a boy either so fanman would be more appropriate thank you.

Your jokes are terrible, clearly. I come from Britain with some of the best and funniest comedians on this planet, and you aren't one of them.

The end.
 

sircaw

Banned
Speak for yourself please.

I was being sarcastic with the cancel thing obviously, i'm not going to cancel the console i've been excited for over an Ethomaz news piece.

I am a fan of Xbox, and of gaming in general, not a "fanboy" and on top of that, i am an actual man and not a boy either so fanman would be more appropriate thank you.

Your jokes are terrible, clearly. I come from Britain with some of the best and funniest comedians on this planet, and you aren't one of them.

The end.

And that's why i said it. you're being over sensitive and ridiculous, crying about a little but of spilt milk.

What an absolutely ridiculous thing to get offended about.

Grow a spine and a sense of humor.

Phil Spencer is not going to steal your xbox

Have a good night.

The end.
 
The anti-Xbox propaganda you continue to unleash that has turned friend into foe, brother. :messenger_crying:

Got nothing against Xbox. It's easy to throw labels around when people hide their raw opinions from public scrutiny. I simply don't subscribe to the corporate decisions and direction, nor the vision for the Brand and its trajectory as headed by division head Phil Spencer. I make my voice heard on that very loud and very clear. Unfortunately a clash of ideas is inevitable with those that follow that corporate suit like a herd. Long gone are the days of Peter Moore at Xbox. Those were the days. I'll say my piece on any hot topic, and I won't shy away from it for anybody.

As for friend.... those are always very, very few.
 
Last edited:
And that's why i said it. you're being over sensitive and ridiculous, crying about a little but of spilt milk.

What an absolutely ridiculous thing to get offended about.

Grow a spine and a sense of humor.

Phil Spencer is not going to steal your xbox

Have a good night.

The end.
I know, he’s going to give me one on the 10th of November :messenger_tears_of_joy:
 

Xaero Gravity

NEXT LEVEL lame™
I genuinely wonder, given his history, if OP thought this was a fascinating story, or wanted to score some points with one side of a 'harassment' story (we know how those go in 2020), against Xbox, lol.

I recall seeing this elsewhere on the board where Xbox said they were scaling down on news, and just wanted Xbox Wire from now on.
I think the answer is fairly obvious lol
 

Piku_Ringo

Banned
4j32kh.jpg
QpUVkfx.jpg
 

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
It's my own fault, I need to stick to the spec thread, need to remember that not everyone has a sense of humor about things like this.

Just the thought of Phil spencer busting into a house talking people hostage, well i thought it was kinda funny and extremely mild for someone to get so upset about.
Nah it's fine, guy is from Britain, bad take on my part. I though it was directed at a Brazilian guy and that made me cringe, dut to reason. Still my voice is no louder than yours, so like obviously humor is agree to disagree.
 

AllBizness

Banned
But she was a hottie I dont understand the hate unless they dont want a woman doing the show or whatever? American men like hot girls in our media just like in the hot rod magazines. They different in Brazil I guess different culture.
 
Last edited:

diffusionx

Gold Member
They probably realized that no matter how many resources they sink into Brazil they cannot and will never outsell the Genesis.
 
Last edited:

Barnabot

Member
According to what I head in that interview. Some guys were harassing her because she is either:

  • A woman
  • Her gamescore is not big enough
  • She doesn't play godlike Xbox games
  • "Lula roubou meu coração" (some politics meme made sometime in the past)
  • All of the above​

Now this is some bad behavior and if Xbox keeps cattering to those people this may backfire splendidly to them. But were they stupid enough to lay off her and not offering any other job at Microsoft?
 
There is nothing being lost in translation except how the Brasil culture is.
Here these things happens and the people accept and move on... it is not the first time that happened with a woman here and neither the last.
They tell their story/reason of the demise but they don't talk bad about the company because if you do you won't get any other job in any other company at all... you will be black listed.
Hands down best part of this thread is you whining to a Mod because somebody said you probably had an agenda, only to find out you left out MS's response, which didn't fit your narrative. Hilarious.
 

ethomaz

Banned
Hands down best part of this thread is you whining to a Mod because somebody said you probably had an agenda, only to find out you left out MS's response, which didn't fit your narrative. Hilarious.
I did not even read the MS reply to be fair before the guy asked... they did not deny the accusations too.

Now what is fun is the people on this thread in denial just because it was me posting what happened :D :D :D
That is hilarious.

Imagine you having a true news and people not believing it because the poster lol
 
Last edited:
But she was a hottie I dont understand the hate unless they dont want a woman doing the show or whatever? American men like hot girls in our media just like in the hot rod magazines. They different in Brazil I guess different culture.

They wanted to rape her, which is how Brazilian gamers show affection apparently.
Gaming culture is weird like that.
 
I did not even read the MS reply to be fair before the guy asked... they did not deny the accusations too.

Now what is fun is the people on this thread in denial just because it was me posting what happened :D :D :D
That is hilarious.
So you saw a story that looked bad and jumped on GAF to paint a picture of victimization without looking for the whole story?

Victim of your own history. People expect trolls to do trollish things.
 

ethomaz

Banned
But she was a hottie I dont understand the hate unless they dont want a woman doing the show or whatever? American men like hot girls in our media just like in the hot rod magazines. They different in Brazil I guess different culture.
The hate come from a wrong misconception here that woman don't know or play games... so some part of the community started saying a girl can show a youtube show about video games because she never took a controller on hands... from that the comments start to become worst to the points of death and rape threats.
 

ethomaz

Banned
So you saw a story that looked bad and jumped on GAF to paint a picture of victimization without looking for the whole story?

Victim of your own history. People expect trolls to do trollish things.
Nope.

I posted because I know portuguese so I was asked to post the thread.
I did not even give my opinion.

Now what the people here on GAF jump on conclusions is not of my concern.

The truth is... the story is real... and the harassment happened and the girl was fired to avoid to resolve issue (like it happens here in Brasil)... I find important to post to show more exposure and change how the Brasilian culture is today because that I think it is worth to talk.

It is really a big issue in Brasil.
 

ZZZZ

Member
There is nothing being lost in translation except how the Brasil culture is.
Here these things happens and the people accept and move on... it is not the first time that happened with a woman here and neither the last.
They tell their story/reason of the demise but they don't talk bad about the company because if you do you won't get any other job in any other company at all... you will be black listed.

Similar situation for another girl related to games less than a year ago:



What that has to do with anything about Xbox pre-orders?
LOL, i live in Brazil and i have no clue about Xbox Mil Grau or Isadora Basile, i'm not part of any Brazilian communities, but even i know about who Gabi Catuzzo is, some of my friends brought it to my attention what was happening back in the day.
She's the streamer that called men, misogynists, sexists, and SOB, and all kinds of other stuff, it was no surprise to me that Razer decided to stop sponsoring someone that insults a big part of their audience.
Gabi was defended to the last breath by left-wing militants, so i'm not surprised you are defending her here.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom