It depends, some would say the FP lineup of the Xbox One is the only reason why its going to sell 50-60 million in its life. When you look at 2013 until now and look at the official and leaked sales figures of games, third party exclusives did much worse than first party exclusive on average. Killer Instinct, Gears, Forza, Horizon, Halo, Sea of Theives, Ori, and State of decay are pretty much the only reasons people brought the Xbox One outside Titanfall, Ryse, and Dead Rising 3 in the earlier days. One could argue that shows how strong those brands are.
But I would personally choose the first Xbox and 360 over the Xbox One myself.
Eh, they had Sonic, Ty, and the other crossplatform stuff, and Blinx and Voodoo were ok.
They also had Oddworld exclusive for a bit and that was a big one.
On that note, don't forget that Microsoft had Forza and Sega GT to go after GT as well as a few PC simulation racers that weren't on the PS2.