• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Favorite "bad" game?

Drizzlehell

Banned
Now, "bad" is a relative term obviously, and the definition of it may vary from person to person. But in general let's agree not to post things like Call of Duty or <insert any PlayStation game here> and be like "oh aren't I clever, I named a game that's not really bad but everyone loves to dunk on it for laughs, har har har" - that'll just make you a cunt.

In general, this is about video games that were either panned or received universally mixed response from critics and audiences alike, but for some reason you really love it and played it a lot. It could be because you were a kid and didn't know any better, therefore you played the shit out of it because it was the only game you had at the time, or because it was based on a movie or a comic book that you are really into. A lot of movie tie-in games or some crappy comic book adaptations are the perfect examples of games that I have in mind here. Or even games that managed to gain a cult following, despite being painfully mediocre, yet uniquely charming (eg. Bloodrayne or Deadly Premonition).

My pick is this:
The_phantom_menace_video_game.jpg




In a lot of ways, it's a game that is primarily responsible for developing my gaming tastes at a very young age when I was just getting into more complex 3D games. It was a bit janky, a lot of its elements feel rushed and unfinished, it had an infuriatingly large amount of buggy escort quests, but on the other hand, it's one of the first games that I remember which had things like 3rd person melee and gun combat, environmental puzzles, inventory management, and even graphic adventure-style dialogue trees and dialogue puzzles. When it comes to specifying what are my favorite game genres, all of the features of those genres can be traced back to this one, crappy Episode I game and how it managed to shape my tastes forever.

And yeah, I still enjoy playing it from time to time. I spent countless hours playing this thing as a kid because for the longest time, it was one of the 4 games that I had installed on my dad's PC and it was all that I could play at the time. The other games being Star Wars Racer, Quake 3, and Unreal Tournament. Naturally, I managed to get insanely good at all of them, and I could probably even speedrun The Phantom Menace if I bothered to get into that scene. I remember watching a speedrun of this game on during a GDQ a few years back and to my amusement, a lot of the tricks used during that speedrun were the same glitches and shortcuts that I managed to find by myself when playing this game as a kid (there were even some that the speedruner himself didn't know about that I found).
 
Prey.

Lowest metascore in my top 10 favourite games.

Recieved 6/10 from my favourite reviewers. Never trusted them again after playing it.
 

Laptop1991

Member
Daikatana got torn apart back in the day, but i thought it was a good game when i played it at the time, not great, but didn't deserve all the hate, i think the expectation's were too high because it was John Romero.
 

WoJ

Member
I look forward to this thread turning into people naming stuff like God of War 2018, Horizon Zero Dawn or Breath of the Wild.

People tell me Mass Effect Andromeda is a bad game but I liked it quite a lot. I was told Dead Space 3 was awful but I enjoyed it despite its flaws. Days Gone also fits into this bucket for me although the negativity around that game seems to have died down.
 

Drizzlehell

Banned
Daikatana got torn apart back in the day, but i thought it was a good game when i played it at the time, not great, but didn't deserve all the hate, i think the expectation's were too high because it was John Romero.
Yeah, plus the cocky marketing and Ion Storm's reputation didn't help either. People were probably glad when it turned out to be not so great and happily tore it to shreds in a collective schadenfreude.

I played through it a couple of years back when it received a fan patch that allowed you to tweak your companion AI to be less of a nuisance, and I actually loved it. Bizzarely enough, the first episode of that game is the only one that's kinda mediocre, and the game opens with literally the worst level in the entire campaign, but once you get past that initial hump, it's a really fun boomer shooter. I was surprised.
 

Laptop1991

Member
Yeah, plus the cocky marketing and Ion Storm's reputation didn't help either. People were probably glad when it turned out to be not so great and happily tore it to shreds in a collective schadenfreude.

I played through it a couple of years back when it received a fan patch that allowed you to tweak your companion AI to be less of a nuisance, and I actually loved it. Bizzarely enough, the first episode of that game is the only one that's kinda mediocre, and the game opens with literally the worst level in the entire campaign, but once you get past that initial hump, it's a really fun boomer shooter. I was surprised.
Yeah same, if you ignored all the hype, it was a good game, and i liked going to the different time period's in history, it was fun, but it was one of the Doom and Quake dev's, they were untouchable gods back then lol and couldn't fail as far as the PC media were concerned.
 

Drizzlehell

Banned
I look forward to this thread turning into people naming stuff like God of War 2018, Horizon Zero Dawn or Breath of the Wild.

People tell me Mass Effect Andromeda is a bad game but I liked it quite a lot. I was told Dead Space 3 was awful but I enjoyed it despite its flaws. Days Gone also fits into this bucket for me although the negativity around that game seems to have died down.
Tbh I don't hate Andromeda either. It's just that the story is such a bland rehash and they completely wasted the potential that this premise held. But when it came to exploring the maps, engaging in combat, and even doing some of the side missions or interacting with your companions, it was pretty fun. I liked some of the ideas that it had, just wish they were used for a more captivating main story.
 

LordOfChaos

Member
People tell me Mass Effect Andromeda is a bad game but I liked it quite a lot.

I finished it as well, and I don't finish many games I'm not liking. Was it the worst mass effect game? Yes obviously. But had it been any other game, I think it was perfectly ok, though I got it after all the patches were in.

Didn't hate the game at all, but did hate that its reception put off the future of ME so far back. And it was clearly setting up DLC with the missing arc ship which will never come and will probably never have its story resolved alas.

If it's on sale for like sub 10 bucks folks, go ahead and play it. Seems to frequently hit 8-9 dollars.

 
Last edited:

fermcr

Member
Football Manager.

It's a love-hate relationship. When a new version of the game releases every year, it consumes a lot of hours of my time. I hate that fu**ing game...
 
My Time at Portia. Critics didn't like it, and I've never seen people post positive things bout it, but I really enjoyed the world, characters, mining, building, adventure, music and atmosphere of this little game. Can't wait for Sandrock to come to consoles... maybe... one day... hopefully.
 

intbal

Member
Yeah, plus the cocky marketing and Ion Storm's reputation didn't help either. People were probably glad when it turned out to be not so great and happily tore it to shreds in a collective schadenfreude.

I played through it a couple of years back when it received a fan patch that allowed you to tweak your companion AI to be less of a nuisance, and I actually loved it. Bizzarely enough, the first episode of that game is the only one that's kinda mediocre, and the game opens with literally the worst level in the entire campaign, but once you get past that initial hump, it's a really fun boomer shooter. I was surprised.
It's still installed on my PC. Fully updated.
There's some fun to be had in the game, but it could really use the "Quake RTX" treatment.

Just popped off a quick screenshot:

UzUGkSS.jpg
 

Kurotri

Member
Prince-of-Persia-2008-Remake-Ubisoft.jpg

Prince of Persia 2008.

This reboot was canned after people complained about not being able to die or whatever else, which led to Ubisoft returning to the original Sands of Time trilogy with Forgotten Sands, which they also fucked up. The series then went into a long slumber, until the sudden announcement of a Sands of Time remake, which they also fucked up. Well, atleast they went back to the drawing board with that one.

Anyway, this was one of my first games I played when I was a kid, on my new shiny 360. This game, alongside the original Assassin's Creed, were completely magical to me. Coincidentally AC1 was also panned by most people lol. I fell in love with this game, I liked the art style, the music, the characters and the puzzles, the atmosphere and everything that encompasses it really. It never getting a sequel was pain. The only solace I had was that I wasn't alone. Way back then I was actually browing the Ubi forums for this particular game and we had our own small community crying out for Ubi to make a sequel. Forum members even got together to print out a long letter in the style of the game's art, asking project leaders at Ubi to reconsider a return to it, but alas, it was not meant to be. I look back fondly on it.
 

Punished Miku

Gold Member
Hey, that actually looks dope as fuck. Why does it have mixed reviews?
It has a steep learning curve. When you first play the game, you would swear on your life it is irredeemably broken beyond repair. Then if you learn how it all works, you can fly through it without much issue on normal.

The game does have inconsistent balance though, throughout with big difficulty spikes at times.

I encountered a few minor glitches.

Definitely AA graphics.

Despite this, I'm a giant fan of the game. Just feels like a lost PS3/360 game and in many ways is the spiritual sequel to Ninja Gaiden 2 (the combat director is the director of this game). Also the game has a very cheesy B-movie, 80s aesthetic on purpose that makes me love it even more, but lots of people will hate it.
 

Drizzlehell

Banned
Prince-of-Persia-2008-Remake-Ubisoft.jpg

Prince of Persia 2008.

This reboot was canned after people complained about not being able to die or whatever else, which led to Ubisoft returning to the original Sands of Time trilogy with Forgotten Sands, which they also fucked up. The series then went into a long slumber, until the sudden announcement of a Sands of Time remake, which they also fucked up. Well, atleast they went back to the drawing board with that one.

Anyway, this was one of my first games I played when I was a kid, on my new shiny 360. This game, alongside the original Assassin's Creed, were completely magical to me. Coincidentally AC1 was also panned by most people lol. I fell in love with this game, I liked the art style, the music, the characters and the puzzles, the atmosphere and everything that encompasses it really. It never getting a sequel was pain. The only solace I had was that I wasn't alone. Way back then I was actually browing the Ubi forums for this particular game and we had our own small community crying out for Ubi to make a sequel. Forum members even got together to print out a long letter in the style of the game's art, asking project leaders at Ubi to reconsider a return to it, but alas, it was not meant to be. I look back fondly on it.
I also remember this game fondly. I remember that when it came out a lot of reviews were ridiculing it for being overly simplistic (1-button platforming, easy combat, not being able to die, etc.) but idk, I didn't feel the same about it at the time. It had a really nice flow to it and I liked the story.
 

Drizzlehell

Banned
It has a steep learning curve. When you first play the game, you would swear on your life it is irredeemably broken beyond repair. Then if you learn how it all works, you can fly through it without much issue on normal.

The game does have inconsistent balance though, throughout with big difficulty spikes at times.

I encountered a few minor glitches.

Definitely AA graphics.

Despite this, I'm a giant fan of the game. Just feels like a lost PS3/360 game and in many ways is the spiritual sequel to Ninja Gaiden 2 (the combat director is the director of this game). Also the game has a very cheesy B-movie, 80s aesthetic on purpose that makes me love it even more, but lots of people will hate it.
You know, mere fact that it's supposed to be a throwback with a more steep learning curve already has me interested because so many modern games are just dumbed down cinematic affairs for absolute normies and there's not enough stuff that would actually try to kick your ass.

I'm gonna check it out.
 

Punished Miku

Gold Member
You know, mere fact that it's supposed to be a throwback with a more steep learning curve already has me interested because so many modern games are just dumbed down cinematic affairs for absolute normies and there's not enough stuff that would actually try to kick your ass.

I'm gonna check it out.
It's very divisive so I don't like the idea of encouraging people to waste money. Maybe check it out on sale for sure.

For me it's one of my favorite action games of all time. For others, it's one of the worst games ever made apparently.
 

MrA

Banned
Daikatana got torn apart back in the day, but i thought it was a good game when i played it at the time, not great, but didn't deserve all the hate, i think the expectation's were too high because it was John Romero.
but did you play the 64 version, now that's spectacularly bad
for me, fatal fury and Street fighter, I don't know why I subject myself to those games when I could easily play any of their sequels, like right now I've got fatal fury plugged into my neo geo when I have garou mark of the wolves sitting on the shelf, why am I doing this? I really don't know.
 

The Stig

Member
If a racing game has rubber banding I flat out refuse to even CONSIDER playing it.

In fact is a game has rubber banding it is NOT A RACING GAME.

Fucking evil, lazy, shitty mechanic.

ignore me, i thought this was a different topic
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom