For me it was Order 1886, I really enjoyed both GOW Chain of Olympus and Ghost of Sparta, they were almost as good as console version of God of War games and I absolutely couldn't wait what they bring to console, but in the end they were more interested giving me pretty graphics rather than proper game.
I still don't understand how can anyone be disappointed by Fallout 76? Bethesda cant make functional SP let alone going full online mode, even themselves make fun of the fact how broken their own games are.
My question is what hell did you guys expect!? I would have been more surprised if it wasn't broken mess.