One can make educated guesses. No different than predicting who will win a football game (between two evenly matched teams) or whether or not a movie will be good based on trailers, directors, writers, etc...Impossible to say if the game is "GOTY material" or not at this point. We haven't played the game yet. I think that's a fundamental requirement for any such statement like GOTY.
My prediction is that this will not be in the majority of conversations for GOTY.