-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Science has determined which pet is smarter, cats or dogs. It's dogs. By a long shot.
- Thread starter Chairman Tickles
- Start date
Heebie Jeebies
Banned
My cat likes to sleep under car wheels, she isn't the brightest. At 19 years old though, it's just pure luck.
petran79
Banned
If you mean humans used to urban tech environment, I highly doubt it. Our generation will go hungry.
Musky_Cheese
Banned
Both have figured out how to lick their own genitalia. That’s pretty smart.
Geki-D
Banned
That was literally my point...?
petran79
Banned
In this case I'd say a cat is more intelligent too
Sorcerer
Member
Hardly scientific, never claimed it to be, just my personal observation.
CatLady
Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
This. People train dogs, cats train people.
Solomeena
Banned
Fuck this study. As the resident Cat aficionado on Neogaf and long time owner of many cats i can easily tell you that your average cat is leaps and bounds more intelligent then dogs. I mean i have had multiple cats over the years that figured out how to work a goddamn door knob to a closed off room. A dog would just try to dig a hole under the door.
Ecto311
Member
Dogs are known to open doors and do tons of stuff as service dogs. No service cats. Well ones that do shit. They just lick their paws and wait for food.
Winchester
Member
As much as I love my yellow lab, she's dumber than my cat. By far. But I still love her more than my cat. Because my cat is a little B.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Or maybe the dog quickly figures out that the doorknob is meant for humans to turn and it will simply ask or beg human to open door when required. Dogs actually understand pointing to objects. Cats do not. So dogs can guide humans to place of interest, such as doorknob.
A crow can do far more complex things with tools than even gorillas. Doesn't make the crow smarter than gorillas.
And now we pay homage to the best domesticated animal of all, the humble goat.
Last edited:
Solomeena
Banned
Cats have evolved humans to service them, why would cats be "service cats"? I mean, isn't that the ultimate sign of intelligence, that we humans serve cats? I will be right back, my cat needs his weekly cat nip served on fine china.
ipsi2
Member
So did Marilyn Manson.
Death Dealer
Member
I think there is a wide range of intelligence depending on the dog. Poodles and German Shepards are very smart. Chihuahuas and bulldogs, not so much.
The cats I've owned that I raised from a kitten seemed to be smarter than ones I acquired later in their lives. I think if they get a lot of human interaction as kittens, they will be more personable and outgoing.
The cats I've owned that I raised from a kitten seemed to be smarter than ones I acquired later in their lives. I think if they get a lot of human interaction as kittens, they will be more personable and outgoing.
What I like about cats is that they tend to have very big variations in personality, even in the same breed. One golden retriever is pretty much just as goofy as the next. Cats vary a lot more. I have two and they couldn't be more different.
In that regard, rats are also very similar to cars. I owned pet rats a couple of years and every rat had a unique personality and quirks.
It is rather flimsy. Making a claim based on evidence intended to substantiate an unproven idea. Though I guess that's just the state of modern science.
In that regard, rats are also very similar to cars. I owned pet rats a couple of years and every rat had a unique personality and quirks.
It is rather flimsy. Making a claim based on evidence intended to substantiate an unproven idea. Though I guess that's just the state of modern science.
Last edited:
kraspkibble
Permabanned.
dogs are dumb animals
cats are the superior intelligent pets.
cats are the superior intelligent pets.
Torrent of Pork
Banned
Um, buddy, I think you got that a little backwards.
5secondrulesucks
Banned
no i dont think i do. i lick peanut butter off my dogs balls all the time. cats will run
Torrent of Pork
Banned
Just so we're clear.
llien
Member
Interesting fact: while humans have about 16 billion neurons in cerebral cortex, Long-finned pilot whales have two times more, gorillas/orangutans are at around 9 billion:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_by_number_of_neurons#Cerebral_cortex
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_by_number_of_neurons#Cerebral_cortex
DESTROYA
Member
I’d love to see you try to put peanut butter on a cats balls, that would be comedy gold.
#Phonepunk#
Banned
dogs are wholly domesticated. they have been trained to see humans as superiors, not equals. they are dependent on humans, and this dependency has made them subservient. in some way perhaps this puts them into a human mindset. at the very least they have bought into this arrangement.
by contrast cats still live like they are in the wild. they look at humans as just another animal, as equals, this is why their behavior is the same as their behavior towards other cats. they kind of have a dgaf attitude towards humans, wheres dogs are almost pathetically dependent on them.
it makes sense that dogs would do better at a human test because they have been trained for it for thousands of years.
by contrast cats still live like they are in the wild. they look at humans as just another animal, as equals, this is why their behavior is the same as their behavior towards other cats. they kind of have a dgaf attitude towards humans, wheres dogs are almost pathetically dependent on them.
it makes sense that dogs would do better at a human test because they have been trained for it for thousands of years.
Last edited:
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Dogs don't see all humans as superiors. Dogs develop an inter-family social hierarchy with humans. Your dog will see just the one it perceives as the alpha male or female as the superior. Sometimes it will see itself as the sole alpha, typically if paired with a passive owner.
Pilot Whales weigh ~15-20x more than the typical human. The typical dog weighs ~3-4x more than a typical cat.
Pilot Whales weigh ~15-20x more than the typical human. The typical dog weighs ~3-4x more than a typical cat.
Last edited:
haxan7
Volunteered as Tribute
Duallusion
Member
Call me lacking in number of neurons but... how exactly did this experiment prove her theory?
EDIT: Not that I necessarily object to the underlining (pre-)assumption that dogs in general are - or at the very least seem - smarter but still.
Last edited:
ipsi2
Member
He can deny it all he wants. We all know it's true.
I_D
Member
As a side note: This rumor was started before the internet, yet we all know it.
I find the propagation of rumors in the pre-internet age to be rather fascinating.
On-topic: While I do think dogs are smarter than cats, coming from a person who owns cats and not dogs, I don't know if the number of cortical neurons is an accurate measurement. It could simply mean that cats have become more streamlined than dogs. The whale mention is a perfect example; a larger number of neurons does not necessarily imply intelligence.
SoulUnison
Banned
Was this ever really in doubt?
Cats are cool, but: Dogs. They're better(tm).
Cats are cool, but: Dogs. They're better(tm).
danielberg
Neophyte
kittoo
Cretinously credulous
Holy shit I concur
S
SLoWMoTIoN
Unconfirmed Member
Border Collie.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked