Nocty
Currently Steaming
I mean Starfield was the no.1 wishlisted game on Steam for over a year, and it had what?, 360k ccu or something?.
I believe Balders Gate and Hogwarts both had under 500k ccu, and they are 2 of the biggest SP games on Steam in recent memory.
It just doesnt happen that often, even with MP games. When you have a store with literally tens of thousands of games available, its just the way it is.
Yeah wishlisting at best is quite the red herring.
Review embargo seems to matter more than people realise. My theory is that, Often with games that get announced early, people will hit the wishlist on steam and wait for reviews. If the embargo is on release date or shortly thereafter, the Steam user scores dictate the sales for obvious reasons. Games that are reviewed early before release and get good ones naturally people maintain the wishlist to buy, rather than games that get bad early reviews and people cancel to buy later in a sale. Often, FOMO sets in before reviews and people pull the trigger.