• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Overwatch - Review Thread

T

thetrin

Hail, peons, for I have come as ambassador from the great and bountiful Blueberry Butt Explosion
Siege.exe said:
In defense of those people, not everyone finds it fun to play as multiple characters. I played almost exclusively as Soldier 76 during the beta, and I don't see that changing when I eventually get the full game. If I had to play a support or tank character just to fill a role, I'd probably hate this game.
Click to expand...

I mean, that's how the game works, though. It's about counterpicking and balanced team make up. Have you tried to get to know all the characters? I found it's one of those games that will surprise you with how much you end up liking characters you don't think you'd like.
 
T

thetrin

Hail, peons, for I have come as ambassador from the great and bountiful Blueberry Butt Explosion
Renekton said:
It has a singleplayer campaign though.
Click to expand...

I honestly wonder who actually played the single player. I definitely totally skipped it. it was billed as a multiplayer game.
 
P

psyfi

Banned
SmartWaffles said:
It is the prime example of pure gameplay goodness with goodwill free update triumphs over initial backlash, Overwatch will be the same.
Click to expand...
Overwatch doesn't need to triumph over anything. The hype for this game is unreal, I'm seeing people talking about it everywhere. The people upset over the amount of content seem awfully minuscule in comparison.
 
T

TheYanger

Member
Renekton said:
Poster above you :D fantastic timing
Click to expand...

GOT EEM!

The single player campaign in Splatoon was a ncie surprise. It's not why people kept going back to the game or really bought it in the first place, but yes, shocker, some shooters do ahve campaigns and those are sometimes enjoyable and liked. Flipside, you had almost no multiplayer maps at launch. Somehow the game still did fine.
 
R

robotrock

Banned
thetrin said:
I honestly wonder who actually played the single player. I definitely totally skipped it. it was billed as a multiplayer game.
Click to expand...

Splatoon's single player campaign is actually fantastic. Didn't expect it at all, but it's very well paced, and features the greatest final boss this gen.
 
T

thetrin

Hail, peons, for I have come as ambassador from the great and bountiful Blueberry Butt Explosion
Renekton said:
Poster above you :D fantastic timing
Click to expand...

One person! :p jk

But seriously, I would've been 100% okay if they'd cut the single player from Splatoon and instead multi had more maps. I was buying a multiplayer shooter after all.

robotrock said:
Splatoon's single player campaign is actually fantastic. Didn't expect it at all, but it's very well paced, and features the greatest final boss this gen.
Click to expand...

I played about 7 levels and gave up on it. I found it pretty boring compared to the "meat" of the game. But to each their own!

TheYanger said:
GOT EEM!

The single player campaign in Splatoon was a ncie surprise. It's not why people kept going back to the game or really bought it in the first place, but yes, shocker, some shooters do ahve campaigns and those are sometimes enjoyable and liked. Flipside, you had almost no multiplayer maps at launch. Somehow the game still did fine.
Click to expand...

Which is fine and all, but I think they made the right choice with Overwatch, just like I wish they hadn't bothered with multiplayer in Doom.
 
T

Triggerhappytel

Member
Slixshot said:
Yup. Game is damn near flawless.
Click to expand...

Yeah, for what it's trying to be it's close to perfect. So well balanced, incredibly well optimised on all platforms, good netcode, and so on. The only real flaws one could level at it are the comparatively thin content, but that depends whether they're going to give Blizzard the benefit of the doubt, considering there's no Season Pass and all updates will be free. I can definitely see this having a high metascore.
 
T

thetrin

Hail, peons, for I have come as ambassador from the great and bountiful Blueberry Butt Explosion
Triggerhappytel said:
Yeah, for what it's trying to be it's close to perfect. So well balanced, incredibly well optimised on all platforms, good netcode, and so on. The only real flaws one could level at it are the comparatively thin content, but that depends whether they're going to give Blizzard the benefit of the doubt, considering there's no Season Pass and all updates will be free. I can definitely see this having a high metascore.
Click to expand...

I still think "thin content" is a logical fallacy when it comes to multiplayer, because it supposes that people treat multiplayer like single player (in that original content has a finite number of playthroughs for the average player).

Multiplayer is just inherently far more replayable than single player, and can survive on less content for a longer period of time (especailly when the focus of the moment-to-moment gameplay is more about character vs. character than the maps and modes, like a fighting game or a MOBA).

Now, where the longevity of the game goes in a few months will depend on how quickly Blizzard releases new modes and content. I have a feeling the weekly brawl will keep things lively until legit new modes are introduced.
 
K

KrawlMan

Member
DonMigs85 said:
I'll be honest, I get the feeling that many of these perfect or near-perfect review scores were bought. Not that the game is bad, of course.
Click to expand...

Do you really think so little of journalists and the game?Honestly not since the occasional university LAN party have I played and enjoyed a competitive shooter. Yet I gave this beta a shot and to my surprise, was enjoying it more than almost any game I've played in recent memory.

Your cynicism is offensive. The game deserves the praise, even if you don't see it.
 
H

HariKari

Member
Siege.exe said:
In defense of those people, not everyone finds it fun to play as multiple characters. I played almost exclusively as Soldier 76 during the beta, and I don't see that changing when I eventually get the full game. If I had to play a support or tank character just to fill a role, I'd probably hate this game.
Click to expand...

76 is a solid pick every time, but if you insist on maining anybody else, play another game. It really hurts your team if you wont switch.
 
T

truestatic

Member
HariKari said:
76 is a solid pick every time, but if you insist on maining anybody else, play another game. It really hurts your team if you wont switch.
Click to expand...

Someone who wants to play suboptimally will just get matched lower, assuming that matchmaking is a thing. That doesn't have to stop them from enjoying the game, though.

Although it does dramatically reduce the game's breadth.
 
P

PreyingShark

Member
thetrin said:
I honestly wonder who actually played the single player. I definitely totally skipped it. it was billed as a multiplayer game.
Click to expand...
Pretty much everybody who's really into the multiplayer plays through the single player at some point. You can't get the Dynamo Rollers, generally considered one of the best weapon types, without beating the final boss. You also need to beat like the fourth boss to get the Kelp chargers, which are also extremely good.
 
L

Lyng

Member
Played the closed beta and the open beta, and the game didnt really grab me.

Still due to the massive praise on here, I decided to buy it for me and a friend. Played it last night and it finally clicked.

I am not addicted, to the point where I am sitting at work and cant stop thinking about Overwatch.
 
R

Rodin

Member
SmartWaffles said:
Funny that no one shittalks about Splatoon's lack of content at launch now, it was a $60 title too. Why? Because it is exactly what Overwatch is doing right now: all content updates are free. And if I remember correct, Splatoon's multiplayer content is even less at launch, with 5 maps and 2 modes.
Click to expand...
It was 40 in Europe and Japan, it had a sp mode and still EVERYONE was shitting on it. Reviews absolutely destroyed the game for its lack of content at launch despite knowing about the free updates plan, but they aren't doing that with Overwatch. So yeah, bad example.
 
K

Kolx

Member
The game is fun no doubt about that, but reviews should have punished the game for selling a 30-40$ content for 60$ on console.
 
T

TheYanger

Member
Rodin said:
It was 40 in Europe and Japan, it had a sp mode and still EVERYONE was shitting on it. Reviews absolutely destroyed the game for its lack of content at launch despite knowing about the free updates plan, but they aren't doing that with Overwatch. So yeah, bad example.
Click to expand...

Again, Splatoon launched with less than half of OW's number of maps, and significantly less weapon/ability variety. Splatoon WITH all the DLC maps has the same number as OW is launching with, for comparison.

Kolx said:
The game is fun no doubt about that, but reviews should have punished the game for selling a 30-40$ content for 60$ on console.
Click to expand...

It might shock you that most people find a game they're going to play for hundreds of hours to be worth 60 dollars.
 
T

Trace

Banned
Kolx said:
The game is fun no doubt about that, but reviews should have punished the game for selling a 30-40$ content for 60$ on console.
Click to expand...

Multiplayer game the average player will probably spend hundreds of hours playing, only worth $40. Single player game the average player will spend ten to forty hours on, no problem $60. Come on buddy, the game having 12 maps or 20 maps doesn't change that the game is fun and doesn't get boring.
 
R

Rodin

Member
TheYanger said:
Again, Splatoon launched with less than half of OW's number of maps, and significantly less weapon/ability variety. Splatoon WITH all the DLC maps has the same number as OW is launching with, for comparison.



It might shock you that most people find a game they're going to play for hundreds of hours to be worth 60 dollars.
Click to expand...
My point is that Splatoon didn't get any free pass, it was harshly criticized both by reviews and gamers, much more so than Overwatch (which wouldn't deserve that treatment either, it's a fantastic game). Fortunately the gameplay was beyond amazing, the art, concept and setting were super-charming and Nintendo decided to push it, so it still was a huge success.
 
S

Spacecowboy77

Member
Game is crazy fun and considering Blizzard's policy of supporting and updating games, 60$ is imo, very reasonable.

They're still supporting Diablo 2 and that came out 16 years ago
 
S

SmartWaffles

Member
Rodin said:
My point is that Splatoon didn't get any free pass, it was harshly criticized both by reviews and gamers, much more so than Overwatch (which wouldn't deserve that treatment either, it's a fantastic game). Fortunately the gameplay was beyond amazing, the art, concept and setting were super-charming and Nintendo decided to push it, so it still was a huge success.
Click to expand...

I did say "now". No one pulled out Splatoon as a bad example of thin MP launch content in this thread because we all see how a good sustain update roadmap benefit that. Splatoon turned out to be very successful, how Overwatch can't? In terms of consistently supporting the game with rich content, Blizzard is second to none in this industry.
 
DonMigs85

DonMigs85

Member
Permanently A said:
Why do you think so? Like do you think that in general about near perfect scores, or is it just in overwatch's case?
Click to expand...

Depends on the game. I think it was well deserved in Ocarina of Time's case, in this case the super positive reviews aren't all that critical. I'm not saying the game doesn't deserve the praise it's getting, I just get this uneasy feeling from some of the reviews, especially from the larger outlets.Gives me IGN GTA IV vibes, and I liked GTA IV. Reviews from small-time sites/users or people we know have no connection to gaming media or publishers might paint a better overall picture.
 
S

Spring Drive

Banned
Fox News: 8/10

Verdict: Overwatch is a beautifully created world with great back stories and depth to its characters. Losing or winning, you will have a great time indulging in all the fun and new aspects about the game that makes it unique from other first-person shooters. So find a hero you love and prepare to get sucked into countless hours of battle.
Click to expand...
 
S

Spring Drive

Banned
Forbes - No score

Overall

Overwatch is an amazing game. It is beautiful to look at, plays well and has oodles of charm. What Blizzard has made here is a great base game and with the company promising that future levels and characters will be free of charge it seems that this is one game with plenty of staying power. If you are looking for a great game to sink your time into, look no further than Overwatch.
Click to expand...
 
breakfuss

breakfuss

Member
Lol @ Splatoon having a good single player campaign. Stop it. I played it for like 15 minutes before never returning.

I keep hearing wonderful things about Overwatch. Several of the Best Buy associates tried to sell me on it today but I told them I wanted to wait a little bit before jumped in. This was completely off my radar...didn't even bother trying the beta. But these reviews and GAF's reception is making it difficult. I'd love something to sink my teeth in for a few minutes here and there and nothing's been doing it for me lately. Had this been $40 on PS4 I wouldn't haven't even thought twice.
 
A

Always-honest

Banned
breakfuss said:
Lol @ Splatoon having a good single player campaign. Stop it. I played it for like 15 minutes before never returning.

I keep hearing wonderful things about Overwatch. Several of the Best Buy associates tried to sell me on it today but I told them I wanted to wait a little bit before jumped in. This was completely off my radar...didn't even bother trying the beta. But these reviews and GAF's reception is making it difficult. I'd love something to sink my teeth in for a few minutes here and there and nothing's been doing it for me lately. Had this been $40 on PS4 I wouldn't haven't even thought twice.
Click to expand...

Well then... ok.
 
P

Permanently A

Junior Member
DonMigs85 said:
Depends on the game. I think it was well deserved in Ocarina of Time's case, in this case the super positive reviews aren't all that critical. I'm not saying the game doesn't deserve the praise it's getting, I just get this uneasy feeling from some of the reviews, especially from the larger outlets.Gives me IGN GTA IV vibes, and I liked GTA IV. Reviews from small-time sites/users or people we know have no connection to gaming media or publishers might paint a better overall picture.
Click to expand...

Why would a perfect score give criticism? Doesn't that defeat the point of a perfect score?
 
S

Spring Drive

Banned
DooMAGE said:
Why is this game geting free pass?
Full price multiplayer only game with balance problems.
Titanfall, sfv, sw battlefront was massacred...
Click to expand...

If there's one thing I think should be criticized about Overwatch, it's the microtransactions while the game is not free-to play
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Overwatch 2 will stop locking new heroes behind a battle pass with season 10
News
1
294
The Skull replied
Overwatch 2 Players Are Getting Banned For Swearing, And They’re Not Thrilled
Drama Community 2
66
3K
Kamina replied
Blizzard announces new Overwatch Esports League
News
23
2K
Dorfdad replied
Microsoft may lose $120 million due to the Overwatch League shutdown
Business Game Dev 2
99
6K
systemr123 replied
Despite The Ongoing Negativity, Overwatch 2 Exceeds Forecasts & Achieves Over 50M Active Players
Sales-Age
14
983
StueyDuck replied
Top Bottom