• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
  • The Politics forum has been nuked. Please do not bring political discussion to the rest of the site, or you will be removed. Thanks.

News Xbox Game Studios head Matt Booty on acquiring studios and planning for the future | Polygon

Bernkastel

Member
Mar 8, 2018
7,666
16,236
960
In terms of teams, we really looked at — are there studios where the team has stuck together? I personally believe that one of the most precious assets in all of the game industry is a game team that has been through things and has shipped games together and has been through multiple cycles, and also a team that’s been through some adversity. Maybe it’s one thing to have a game team — you know, I’m all for luck, and I’m all for having the first thing out of the gate be an amazing big hit. But I think you learn a lot by dealing with adversity, and the fact that a game team can make it through multiple generations of hardware can stick together. What that tells me is that they really orient around what they’re building, and that they’re more focused internally on what they’re making than a lot of the noise that can exist in our in our industry. So that’s where the teams come in.

Then with ideas, really we tried to look at studios that have a creative process, that we know that they have a process for making multiple ideas. Again, I am all for the dream of “the first game that I ever made is a giant hit” — you know, you hit it big the first time, I love that. But at the same time, somebody like Tim Schafer at Double Fine, he clearly has a creative process. Tim has made many games. I think he’s got many more games in him. And our goal, hopefully, is that if we can remove the stress and the pressure of constantly having to go out and find a publisher and that next source of funding, that Tim can relax a little bit, and whatever game has always been floating around in the back of his head that he would want to make, that we empower him to make that.

I look at our studio in Montreal at Compulsion Games, what they did with Contrast and what they did with We Happy Few, and now I’ve got visibility into how the new game that they’re working on is coming together, that they’ve got a process. And I trust that over time, they’re going to have a steady output of new stuff, and it wasn’t just that they got lucky. And, again, I’m all for luck. But we’re looking to really build a steady stream of content, and that’s what we indexed on with these studios.

So, the people — people that we knew and we’ve worked with before; teams — teams that have stuck together, and have been through some good times and some adverse times; and then, ideas — in terms of a steady flow of new things that we could bring to our players.
You’ve said your goal is to allow each of the acquired studios to keep their company culture. But that seems like it would pose a management challenge for you and for Microsoft, because you’re going to be managing all these teams with these very different cultures and possibly very different workflows, right?

Yeah. Well, first and foremost, it’s great insight that you’ve got there on the management. We are very lucky that each of these studios has very seasoned, tenured, professional studio managers. So, in no case do they need my help on how to run their studio day-to-day. Feargus [Urquhart] has been running Obsidian for quite a while. Brian Fargo [of inXile Entertainment], obviously, very tenured. When you think about everything that Ninja Theory has been through with Nina [Kristensen] — probably the last thing they need my help doing is running their studio day-to-day, right? So then, to your question, it becomes what do we do to try to add value? We try to err on the side of caution there. We don’t want to add any structure, unless that structure adds value.
So I wanted to ask you a little bit about The Initiative, and what the goal is there. What was the philosophy behind opening a new studio, as opposed to another acquisition, and what’s the state of that studio?

Well, if you go back to the “people, teams, and ideas” thing, we are very fortunate to have some pretty big franchises. We’ve got things like Halo and Minecraft and Forza, Gears of War, Age of Empires, Flight Sim. In many cases, these are franchises that are a decade or more established, which is fantastic. A big franchise like that comes with its own things that you can do. There’s a lot of room within a big world to innovate on its own. But it’s a separate thing when you think about how you manage that production. And then we’ve got some of the studios that we’ve acquired that came with their own culture. And when we think about — how are we going to keep ourselves from sitting still, and how are we going to kind of mix things up a little bit?

We had a unique opportunity with The Initiative that Darrell Gallagher, who’s obviously had a lot of success in the industry, became available. And we thought, where can we build the studio, which we haven’t done in a while? And how would this work? And what does it mean to go create a new studio from ground zero, where we’re going to bring in people very deliberately around a product idea? And what does it mean to build a studio in a location that we really haven’t had a presence? I think you’ve seen some of the hires that Darryl’s made, where there’s just a lot of activity in that area where we can hire really great talent. We decided, let’s try something new. We’ve got these big franchises. They sort of have their own way of doing something. We acquired some studios that came with their own culture. How do we start something from ground zero?

I don’t want to get into too much, particularly with our showcase coming up, in terms of what The Initiative is doing. But I’ll just say that obviously we spent a lot of time talking with them and reviewing and seeing what’s going on. I think people are going to be pretty excited when we start to talk about what’s going on there.
Could you speak to whether you think the acquisitions are going to continue, or whether you’re going to take a pause on acquisitions, since you’ve just done a slate of them?

There’s no playbook or timeline pressure there. We’re in a great spot. Microsoft as a company has supported us very strongly in these acquisitions. I mean, to be able to go out and do everything from acquiring something as big as Minecraft to then being able to go out and acquire studios, which don’t come with sort of that pop culture awareness as a Minecraft, but still are important to what we’re doing. So I feel very supported there.

Phil [Spencer] has always been super supportive in terms of how this fits into Xbox. I think it’s more a case of, if we felt that there was a developer out there that we thought made sense to become more integrated and part of Xbox Game Studios, that we would be well-supported to go do that. Things happen with an ebb and flow. Right now, we’re just very focused on supporting, making sure that we’re ready for the launch of the new console later in the year.
One last question about finding success on Game Pass. I’m just curious what the conversations have been like with some of the studios that you’ve acquired, who say, “Hey, maybe this is most appropriate as a Game Pass game.” Do they feel more empowered or enabled to make stuff that’s smaller, more experimental?

Yeah, it’s a great question, and we’ve had a lot of conversations about this. I don’t mean this to be at all sarcastic, but it’ll frame so the way I think about it, which is — I don’t know what a “Game Pass game” is. Because right now I can go look at the things that are being played the most inside Game Pass, and it ranges from everything from Gears 5 to Human: Fall Flat. And I love that. One of the things that folks have said to me: “What makes a good Game Pass game?” I come back and say, to me, that’s a little bit like saying, “Go write me a song for Spotify.” [laughs]

I know that it seems a little broad, but I really stick more to, “Go make a good game.” And if you make a good game, we’ll figure out the best place for it. Like, Sea of Thieves. Sea of Thieves was designed — it started production before Game Pass really even existed. But it was a game designed to be about community, and it just so happened that as Sea of Thieves was the first first-party game to go day-and-date into Game Pass, that that intersection of what it was about, which was community, was a great match-up. But we didn’t set out ahead of time to say, “Go design Sea of Thieves to be this launch title for Game Pass.” It’s just that Sea of Thieves is a great game.

Game teams — I love them, because they will always try to seek the path to success and they always want to ask a bunch of questions, like, “Tell me what makes a great Game Pass game.” And I say, “I don’t know, I can’t tell you. So you got to go make a good game.” And I think things that make a good game are interesting worlds, new characters, new things to do, things that you can build a community around. You do those. We’ve seen great success with Minecraft inside Game Pass. I might not have predicted that. Because you could say, “Wow, everybody on the planet’s already got Minecraft.” Yet it’s got a whole new community of players that’s come up inside Game Pass.

So when teams start getting down that line of thought, I just say, “Time out. Please, just go make a great game.” And I guarantee that if you make a good game, we can adjust and steer in the last few months and figure out what the best thing for this is. But I would never want somebody using the distribution platform as the way to think about game design.
I don’t mean this to be at all sarcastic, but it’ll frame so the way I think about it, which is — I don’t know what a “Game Pass game” is.
The article has been removed but for now you can still read it in MSN.
 
Last edited:
Apr 19, 2019
9,171
15,123
780
Away with the fairies
Good interview. Not sure about

"we only add structures that add value"

Because recently (10 years) Microsoft doesn't know how to add value to a studio like it once did.

I'd like Microsoft, and Sony, to really focus on b tier games for gamepass. It's a market that has been swallowed by 2d indies which, if we're honest, are starting to rehash themselves. I want more money dedicated to experimental games that aren't 2d or pixel art.

On the whole, Microsoft seem to going in the right direction.

Let's see what happens 23rd July
 

Bernkastel

Member
Mar 8, 2018
7,666
16,236
960
Good interview. Not sure about

"we only add structures that add value"

Because recently (10 years) Microsoft doesn't know how to add value to a studio like it once did.

I'd like Microsoft, and Sony, to really focus on b tier games for gamepass. It's a market that has been swallowed by 2d indies which, if we're honest, are starting to rehash themselves. I want more money dedicated to experimental games that aren't 2d or pixel art.

On the whole, Microsoft seem to going in the right direction.

Let's see what happens 23rd July
Its more of a recent strategy under Matt Booty
 

Bernkastel

Member
Mar 8, 2018
7,666
16,236
960
Sounds like he's trying to hint that the initiative is going to make a new IP that will rival stuff like gears and Halo.
Drew Murray liked this tweet.


Now we are getting somewhere
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ascend
D

Deleted member 775630

Unconfirmed Member
They took the interview offline? I'm getting a 404. Good thing you've already copy/pasted stuff
 
S

Steve.1981

Unconfirmed Member
Sounds like he's trying to hint that the initiative is going to make a new IP that will rival stuff like gears and Halo.

That's how I read it as well. "...mix things up a bit" "...bring in people deliberately around a product idea"

Sounds like maybe they're doing something completely new. Which would be very cool.
 

smithg5

Member
Nov 4, 2014
287
384
455
We are not. Its too soon for them.

I guess there are two reads on this quote:

I don’t want to get into too much, particularly with our showcase coming up, in terms of what The Initiative is doing. But I’ll just say that obviously we spent a lot of time talking with them and reviewing and seeing what’s going on. I think people are going to be pretty excited when we start to talk about what’s going on there.

One is that they don't want to spoil the tease/reveal of the Initiative game on the 23rd. The second is that they don't want some big news from this interview to distract from the 23rd showcase (which in that case wouldn't relate to that).

The second interpretation seems much more awkward to me. I'm not saying there's no way that is what he means, but I think the plain reading would be that we should expect to see or hear something on the 23rd.
 

Bernkastel

Member
Mar 8, 2018
7,666
16,236
960
I guess there are two reads on this quote:

One is that they don't want to spoil the tease/reveal of the Initiative game on the 23rd. The second is that they don't want some big news from this interview to distract from the 23rd showcase (which in that case wouldn't relate to that).

The second interpretation seems much more awkward to me. I'm not saying there's no way that is what he means, but I think the plain reading would be that we should expect to see or hear something on the 23rd.
 

Gavon West

Member
Jan 12, 2018
2,153
2,419
405
It was backed up by Jez, Klobrille and others.
They still might be wrong. Grubbs chimed in on Era. He still doesnt think TI will be there, but he acknowledges its possible. And if it is, it may be a small teaser or something of the sort.
 

Murder187

Member
Nov 19, 2018
99
146
245
Just a hunch Microsoft will acquire wb gaming and will show the new batman which will be coming to all consoles
 

pasterpl

Member
Feb 8, 2020
1,911
3,641
540
They still might be wrong. Grubbs chimed in on Era. He still doesnt think TI will be there, but he acknowledges its possible. And if it is, it may be a small teaser or something of the sort.

i wouldn’t be surprised if they show some teaser/trailer, at least
 

Jubenhimer

Member
Nov 11, 2018
1,694
2,238
560
24
I'd like Microsoft, and Sony, to really focus on b tier games for gamepass. It's a market that has been swallowed by 2d indies which, if we're honest, are starting to rehash themselves. I want more money dedicated to experimental games that aren't 2d or pixel art.

Indie games aren't just 2D pixel games anymore. Indies have significantly increased in scope and graphical styles that many of them can be almost as good as a AAA production.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Murder187

quest

Not Banned from OT
Jul 17, 2004
6,170
3,158
1,695
It is a shame people don't get how much things have changed with new management. Under old management they would of told obsidian or inexile what games to make. That old culture just does not work. People are just caught up on how come inexile is not showing new games with out understanding they are wrapping one up. This direction should give everyone hope that fruit will eventually be harvested by allowing these studios to do their thing Microsoft is there to help staff them up, payroll and technical support if needed. The studios have the freedom we have all been talking about for years. That is a recipe for success.
 
Apr 19, 2019
9,171
15,123
780
Away with the fairies
Indie games aren't just 2D pixel games anymore. Indies have significantly increased in scope and graphical styles that many of them can be almost as good as a AAA production.
I respectfully disagree. Indie games have taken over B-tier games, with none of the charm or uniqueness, generally speaking. That isn't to say Indies can't be charming or unique, they've just overgrown their area and out-stayed their welcome.
 

Jubenhimer

Member
Nov 11, 2018
1,694
2,238
560
24
I respectfully disagree. Indie games have taken over B-tier games, with none of the charm or uniqueness, generally speaking. That isn't to say Indies can't be charming or unique, they've just overgrown their area and out-stayed their welcome.
I'm just saying they're not all 2D pixel art titles. That's such an outdated view of indie games. Many of the best indies in recent years have moved beyond that aesthetic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Slings and Arrows