Support NeoGAF

[Tickle My Tendies]

Shoutout to VG Tech for the great content.




Timestamps
00:00 - Xbox Series S
05:49 - Xbox Series X
11:37 - PS5

Series S

Xbox Series S uses a dynamic resolution with the highest native resolution found being 1920x1080 and the lowest native resolution found being 1280x720. Native resolution pixel counts at 1280x720 seem to be uncommon on Xbox Series S. On Xbox Series S temporal upsampling is used to reconstruct a 2560x1440 resolution.

PS5

PS5 uses a dynamic resolution with the highest native resolution found being approximately 3008x1692 and the lowest native resolution found being 1920x1080. Native resolution pixel counts at 1920x1080 seem to be rare on PS5. On PS5 temporal upsampling is used to reconstruct a 3840x2160 resolution.

Series X

Xbox Series X uses a dynamic resolution with the highest native resolution found being approximately 3456x1944 and the lowest native resolution found being 1920x1080. Native resolution pixel counts at 1920x1080 seem to be very rare on Xbox Series X and were found less often than on PS5. On Xbox Series X temporal upsampling is used to reconstruct a 3840x2160 resolution.

In the scenes tested where both PS5 and Xbox Series X were not rendering at their maximum or minimum resolutions, the Xbox Series X rendered at a higher native resolution than the PS5.

PS5 and Xbox Series X have extra trees and foliage in some scenes compared to Xbox Series S. PS5 has improved texture filtering compared to the Xbox consoles

Platforms	PS5	Xbox Series X	Xbox Series S
Frame Amounts
Game Frames	20875	20872	20874
Video Frames	20890	20890	20890
Frame Tearing Statistics
Total Torn Frames	0	0	0
Lowest Torn Line	-	-	-
Frame Height	2160	2160	2160
Frame Time Statistics
Mean Frame Time	16.68ms	16.68ms	16.68ms
Median Frame Time	16.67ms	16.67ms	16.67ms
Maximum Frame Time	33.33ms	50ms	50ms
Minimum Frame Time	16.67ms	16.67ms	16.67ms
95th Percentile Frame Time	16.67ms	16.67ms	16.67ms
99th Percentile Frame Time	16.67ms	16.67ms	16.67ms
Frame Rate Statistics
Mean Frame Rate	59.96fps	59.95fps	59.95fps
Median Frame Rate	60fps	60fps	60fps
Maximum Frame Rate	60fps	60fps	60fps
Minimum Frame Rate	55fps	56fps	55fps
5th Percentile Frame Rate	60fps	60fps	60fps
1st Percentile Frame Rate	59fps	59fps	59fps
Frame Time Counts
16.67ms	20860 (99.93%)	20855 (99.92%)	20859 (99.93%)
33.33ms	15 (0.07%)	16 (0.08%)	14 (0.07%)
50ms	0 (0%)	1 (0%)	1 (0%)
Other
Dropped Frames	0	0	0
Runt Frames	0	0	0
Runt Frame Thresholds	20 rows	20 rows	20 rows

Summary:

Resolution advantage on XsX, framerate seems nearly identical, PS5 has better texture filtering

Pics he linked for texture filtering comparison

PS5 -

XSX -

Spoiler

 

[Insane Metal]

Platforms    PS5    Xbox Series X    Xbox Series S
Frame Amounts          
Game Frames    20875    20872    20874
Video Frames    20890    20890    20890
Frame Tearing Statistics          
Total Torn Frames    0    0    0
Lowest Torn Line    -    -    -
Frame Height    2160    2160    2160
Frame Time Statistics          
Mean Frame Time    16.68ms    16.68ms    16.68ms
Median Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Maximum Frame Time    33.33ms    50ms    50ms
Minimum Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
95th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
99th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Frame Rate Statistics          
Mean Frame Rate    59.96fps    59.95fps    59.95fps
Median Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Maximum Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Minimum Frame Rate    55fps    56fps    55fps
5th Percentile Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
1st Percentile Frame Rate    59fps    59fps    59fps
Frame Time Counts          
16.67ms    20860 (99.93%)    20855 (99.92%)    20859 (99.93%)
33.33ms    15 (0.07%)    16 (0.08%)    14 (0.07%)
50ms    0 (0%)    1 (0%)    1 (0%)
Other          
Dropped Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frame Thresholds    20 rows    20 rows    20 rows

PS5 wins this one. 60fps 99.93% vs. 99.92% of the time on Series X.

 

[Alright]

How does the 1x compare? I ain't giving up on you yet!

 

[Interfectum]

 

[darkleemar]

 

[cyen]

Another easy win for the green camp.

 

[RobRSG]

Whatever happens PS5 always wins for some people. Funny stuff.

 

[Entroyp]

Deja vu? We already knew it performed better on PS5 right?

 

[cyen]

Deja vu? We already knew it performed better on PS5 right?

Performed better? 0.01? We already knew that resolution wise Series X was trashing PS5 again.

 

[Tickle My Tendies]

Performed better? 0.01? We already knew that resolution wise Series X was trashing PS5 again.

I think that Entropy account is a bot. He only posts Sony propaganda.

They perform basically identically. I mean, the XsX even has better/higher minimum FPS if people wanna get nit picky. The framerate is practically the same.

 

[retsof624]

Nice improvement over the demo for Xbox consoles

 

[CatLady]

Has VG Tech joined forces with Digital Foundry to shill for Xbox?

 

[myharlequin]

XSX the best version I guess.

 

[Snake29]

Stable on both consoles is great! The texture filtering differences is kinda huge if you tell me (looking at the screen). The res drop on both is also huge.

 

[Mr Moose]

Seems pretty solid on all 3.

 

[Bonfires Down]

As an example, at one point in a cutscene the Xbox Series X rendered at a resolution of approximately 2792x1570 and the PS5 rendered the same scene at 2560x1440.

 

[M1chl]

GamePass > 60 bucks

 

[thelastword]

Picture quality and framerate better on PS5, XBOX has the higher resolution......XBOX increases resolution at the deficit of PQ.

 

[vaibhavpisal]

Can anyone make out any differences in screenshots posted?

or will i need to zoom 800% (its embarrassing how popular these comparison videos are getting)

 

[ethomaz]

PS5 better IQ.
Series X better resolution.
Framerate very similar.

 

[Zoro7]

GamePass > 60 bucks

Buying the games you want > forcing yourself to play shitty games because it’s value for money.

 

[Soulblighter31]

Are some people still having trouble accepting that the console with the more powerfull hardware outputs superior visuals in games ? The ps4 generation really tricked thos guys huh ? They forgot how sony had the weaker console for the entirety of its history for some reason and believed that ps4 is gonna be how things will stand forever ?

 

[ChuckeRearmed]

Guess that's 30% performance difference in resolution is a new norm right now between Xbox and PS5.

But I am curious more about the new generation of games.

 

[a multicultural team of v]

Can anyone make out any differences in screenshots posted?

or will i need to zoom 800% (its embarrassing how popular these comparison videos are getting)

If you open both images up in different tabs and click back and forth the ground texture is very obvious.

 

[bentanchorbolt]

PS5 better IQ.
Series X better resolution.
Framerate very similar.

And nobody playing the game that isn't pixel counting or running side by side will ever tell any difference. These games are the same. This is splitting hairs, IMO.

 

[ethomaz]

Can anyone make out any differences in screenshots posted?

or will i need to zoom 800% (its embarrassing how popular these comparison videos are getting)

On mobile without any zoom... the opposite the mobile page fits the pics to the screen and you can see the filtering difference.

In original resolution in the TV it will be obvious.

But of course it is not something will bother me while playing... it is not like tearing or artifacts in the screen.

 

[Mr Moose]

Can anyone make out any differences in screenshots posted?

or will i need to zoom 800% (its embarrassing how popular these comparison videos are getting)

The only difference I can notice flicking between them is the AF.

 

[Chessmate]

PS5 better IQ.
Series X better resolution.
Framerate very similar.

If this was the other way around you would just write "PS5 has the better version." Which makes your "opinion" kind of...boring.

 

[FlyyGOD]

Picture quality and framerate better on PS5, XBOX has the higher resolution......XBOX increases resolution at the deficit of PQ.

You really claiming a 0.01 framerate advantage?

 

[Aceofspades]

Platforms    PS5    Xbox Series X    Xbox Series S
Frame Amounts         
Game Frames    20875    20872    20874
Video Frames    20890    20890    20890
Frame Tearing Statistics         
Total Torn Frames    0    0    0
Lowest Torn Line    -    -    -
Frame Height    2160    2160    2160
Frame Time Statistics         
Mean Frame Time    16.68ms    16.68ms    16.68ms
Median Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Maximum Frame Time    33.33ms    50ms    50ms
Minimum Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
95th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
99th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Frame Rate Statistics         
Mean Frame Rate    59.96fps    59.95fps    59.95fps
Median Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Maximum Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Minimum Frame Rate    55fps    56fps    55fps
5th Percentile Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
1st Percentile Frame Rate    59fps    59fps    59fps
Frame Time Counts         
16.67ms    20860 (99.93%)    20855 (99.92%)    20859 (99.93%)
33.33ms    15 (0.07%)    16 (0.08%)    14 (0.07%)
50ms    0 (0%)    1 (0%)    1 (0%)
Other         
Dropped Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frame Thresholds    20 rows    20 rows    20 rows

PS5 wins this one. 60fps 99.93% vs. 99.92% of the time on Series X.

PS5 had better texture filling as stated

 

[ethomaz]

If this was the other way around you would just write "PS5 has the better version." Which makes your "opinion" kind of...boring.

My opinion is based in facts so it is really boring.
Fiction is more fun.

 

[ethomaz]

Platforms    PS5    Xbox Series X    Xbox Series S
Frame Amounts      
Game Frames    20875    20872    20874
Video Frames    20890    20890    20890
Frame Tearing Statistics      
Total Torn Frames    0    0    0
Lowest Torn Line    -    -    -
Frame Height    2160    2160    2160
Frame Time Statistics      
Mean Frame Time    16.68ms    16.68ms    16.68ms
Median Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Maximum Frame Time    33.33ms    50ms    50ms
Minimum Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
95th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
99th Percentile Frame Time    16.67ms    16.67ms    16.67ms
Frame Rate Statistics      
Mean Frame Rate    59.96fps    59.95fps    59.95fps
Median Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Maximum Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
Minimum Frame Rate    55fps    56fps    55fps
5th Percentile Frame Rate    60fps    60fps    60fps
1st Percentile Frame Rate    59fps    59fps    59fps
Frame Time Counts      
16.67ms    20860 (99.93%)    20855 (99.92%)    20859 (99.93%)
33.33ms    15 (0.07%)    16 (0.08%)    14 (0.07%)
50ms    0 (0%)    1 (0%)    1 (0%)
Other      
Dropped Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frames    0    0    0
Runt Frame Thresholds    20 rows    20 rows    20 rows

PS5 wins this one. 60fps 99.93% vs. 99.92% of the time on Series X.

There is a weird 50ms frame... it is basically imperceptible but I’m curious to know what happened to drop the render to 50ms for one frame.

Mainly when you can’t render in 16ms you automatically render the frame at 33ms... 50ms means you missed the time of the 33ms render too.

 

[reksveks]

You really claiming a 0.1 framerate advantage?

He is claiming a 0.01 framerate advantage

 

[squarealex]

Some people can notice 3008x1692 vs 3456x1944

but not this...

 

[SLB1904]

nvm. the difference is bigger than i thought

 

[CurtBizzy]

Textures>Resolution

 

[Mr.NiceGuy]

Another one?

Another one another one another one another, another another another another one.

What I'm trying to say is... another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one another one.


So in conclusion it's one another.

Thank you.

Edit: forget to say that it IS another one.

 

[SLB1904]

Some people can notice 3008x1692 vs 3456x1944

but not this...

oof thats bad.

 

[thelastword]

Some people can notice 3008x1692 vs 3456x1944

but not this...

As I said PQ vs Resolution......That's pretty massive...

 

[AgentP]

Some people can notice 3008x1692 vs 3456x1944

but not this...

PS5 on right? What is going on with the XSX, lower AF?

 

[Hendrick's]

 

[Physiognomonics]

The resolution difference will go unoticed by many but most will definitely notice the sharper looking textures on PS5.

 

[Renozokii]

Some people can notice 3008x1692 vs 3456x1944

but not this...

Thank you thought I was going crazy reading this thread lmao. One of these looks definitively worse and it’s not PlayStation,

 

[Chessmate]

My opinion is based in facts so it is really boring.
Fiction is more fun.

Of course fiction is more interesting than your upcoming 300 posts in this thread trying to convince people, the PS5 version is actually the winner here. If fiction was just as boring I'd never read a book or watch a movie.

Try to accept the facts: Series X usually has a higher resolution in games because it's the more capable machine. So move on and enjoy Outriders on PS5, if you've got 70 bucks left.

 

[Red-Town]

 

[RobRSG]

Gonna play something. Console wars these days are the most boring yet.

 

[SLB1904]

You really claiming a 0.1 framerate advantage?

look up

 

[ethomaz]

Of course fiction is more interesting than your upcoming 300 posts in this thread trying to convince people, the PS5 version is actually the winner here. If fiction was just as boring I'd never read a book or watch a movie.

Try to accept the facts: Series X usually has a higher resolution in games because it's the more capable machine. So move on and enjoy Outriders on PS5, if you've got 70 bucks left.

Your post doesn’t change any fact posted lol

 

[Plantoid]

Glad I choose the xsx, performs great and I experienced the game for "free"

 

[a multicultural team of v]

Gonna play something. Console wars these days are the most boring yet.

I'd rather play change the router DNS than Outriders or Soulstorm tbh