There's plenty to bring up against Joel to judge if he's a moral person or not, his hunter days alone where he had to do things that still gives Tommy nightmares practically excludes him from being a "good" person. That's not to say he wasn't on path of redemption.I feel like the people who say Joel is not a good person played a different game... I wanna ask - the Joel haters - did you hate yourself and your actions as the protagonist in TLOU? So freaking bizarre.
When people say Joel was being evil at the hospital is indeed puzzling when you lay out all the events that escalated the situation.