• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Oscar Isaac to play solid snake in metal gear solid movie

Metal Gear Solid does not need a movie. It is already a movie with the an awesome slice of gaming on the side. Why would I go to a cinema stream a 2-3 hour cutscene, when MGS4 has 3 hour cutscenes between every 2 minutes of gameplay?


quick sidebar... we are all on the same page that this movie is probably going to suck, right?

normally i would agree with you but if you hear the director talk about it, i think it has a chance, he seems like a great fit and is actually a huge fan of the source material. It seems he actually understands what makes Metal Gear Solid so unique and interesting.

check it out:



as a lotino i really dont like this sorry but i was specting a white person to do this. some one like him:

naa just trolling love Oscar


He was awful in Star Wars but that likely wasn't his fault - fingers crossed this is good, an MGS film has the potential to be great fun


so wait, doesnt that mean he’ll also play Liquid Snake as well? or they gonna just have some other actor do it


I can't imagine this being good. He's not tall enough and doesn't have the right voice. Suits these days think checking off like 2 boxes is enough.

Also when these kinds of developments happen on Twitter, it's not a good sign. A lot of shows/movies suck because everyone making them is too busy caring what people on Twitter think.


Does anyone know the question asked that made him say he wants to play Snake? Link to full interview?
He was asked what video game movie he would like to be in if I remember right. I'm going to be a bit disappointed if he doesn't play Liquid and Big Boss too. I don't think he will but it would be great.

I hope we get Metal Gear anime too:
Last edited:


Christian Bale would've been better. Even Tom Cruise 15 years ago, or even better Clint Eastwood 50 years ago, man that would've have been something. Oscar looks like an ant - he doesn't have the physical stature, can't see him pull it off and being a latino makes his complexion too dark I believe.


Idk, he better bulk up. His roles in Annihilation and Triple Frontier showed he has what it takes to play a convincing operator and has been a proven oscar worthy caliber actor given the right material...but he definitely doesn't look like the tall, broad shouldered, chiseled solid snake we all love. I truly hope this turns out great I have such high hopes with Roberts enthusiasm and clear knowledge of the series and he seems to have a real grasp on what it takes to direct a great videogame adaption and I believe he has developed a personal relationship with kojima . That being said, the writer hasn't written anything I would say gives him the right to do this massive adaption but perhaps he too is a huge fan of the series. Avi Arad is not a.terrible producer and he just won an oscar for Into The Spider-Verse so give him a break at least.

I am also hoping they give us a great adaption that totally stands on its own while totally capturing tone of the games. Military realism mixed with sort of a sci-fi/fantasy mix. Pleasseeeeeee get it right.
Last edited:


thinks Halo Infinite is a new graphical benchmark
Movie has a chance now we know game movies aren’t successful they’re gonna try to take his role from Bourne and apply it to this metal gear movie, some of that Star Wars mojo.


Him pitching himself sounds good - because it then suggests he doesn't need the entire backstory explained to him which is massive - as he's probably played all the games; especially as he made the distinction of which snake he wanted to play.

I guess this how Sony sign off on getting 8K cinema grade assets for UE5 nanite/Atom view tech for a PS5 game, cinema picks up the tab for the background stuff, and gaming does the extras to make stunning game/s.

He said "snake". I bet he doesn't know the difference between solid snake and big boss.


Gold Member
Eric Bana makes Keanu Reeves look charismatic. I'm probably coming off as a real jerk in this thread, but I seriously wonder how many movies some gamers actually watch. I have the fortune/misfortune of having watched more than I can count, and some of these suggestions just seem ill-advised, to put it politely. Has anyone come away from an Eric Bana performance and felt that he contributed to the movie in a positive way? I certainly can't mention a single Bana role that was even decent. Nero in Star Trek was probably his best, and he was extremely limited in speaking parts in that movie. For very good reasons too.
eric bana is a far superior actor compared to keanu reeves IMO
Last edited:


Doesnt need recognition
He said "snake". I bet he doesn't know the difference between solid snake and big boss.

Well I was cynical at first.. but after some nternal kneejerk reactions and seeing his sincere heartfelt interaction/response in that clip I'm okay with this. Point is, the end result (movie) would probably suck anyways so I cant help feeling but apathy towards it all.. : (
Couldn't get Keifer Sutherland huh?

Too old, but they said the movie will span across all the series timeline
He could play an older Big Boss

The problem is Isaac as Solid, even at his best it's hard to imagine much more than a not so resembling cosplayer

100% true look is not everything, acting is infinitely more important ( the reason why I think Eastwood would be a bad choice) but you also need to mantain an aesthetic fidelity

One thing is, for example, bringing on screen a novel 's character, who maybe has never been on the screen, but a main character from one of the most important franchises ever is completely different

Btw, for example I also greatly disliked movie Carlos Oliveira
Last edited:


Are we really saying someone can’t play the part because they aren’t tall enough? Wtf lol. You guys have heard of camera angles, right? And like, how often do you think about Snake’s height when you play Metal Gear? How much would you think about it while watching the movie? He’s not exactly Peter Dinklage.


Street Fighter IV World Champion
Doesn't feel right to me. Either way, if it's happening, I'll strap in and see what they come up with.

The New Guy

Unconfirmed Member
I don't mind the choice, but it wouldn't have been my first. I've enjoyed some of his performances, but he's not an actor I've ever been hugely crazy about. He was really good in A Most Violent Year.

I can see him pulling it off, it's just whether everything else works as well. I feel like a Metal Gear film will be hard to get right. I'll watch it either way. I just wish Video Game films came out better, a lot of them turn out to be disappointing.
Top Bottom