• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

ManofOne

Plus Member
mewtwo GIF
 

Piku_Ringo

Banned
Dick, you’ll understand one day when you’re my age. When your dick has shriveled into nothing, your balls pendulums of pain.. when your man tits sag past your navel and your sphincter looser than grain.. you’ll understand

Aren't you like in your 30s or some s***
 

Nobody_Important

“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
This thread was the best thing about GAF post-split. Now it’s the worst. Compare the first 5 pages to the last 5. Nothing but gravedancers and sycophants now. Glad to see O-N-E O-N-E pardoned though. Whatever is going on now, I hope we can one day get back to the original spirit of this thread.
It still is one of the best things. People are still allowed to come here and argue for or against bans. Or simply just voice their opinion about whether or not a ban was justified. Several bans have been shortened or repealed here just recently. There is nothing remotely like this on any other sites that I frequent. The only way to discuss or argue a ban on most platforms is in private and often can only be made by the person who was banned. Nobody can lobby on your behalf. Gaf is unique in that way.


The problem is that several of the bans here in the last month or so were completely justified and people are upset to see people they knew or even considered friends go. They get heated. They may take it out on others or the staff and if they take it too far they can catch a ban too. Which starts a snowball effect. But it doesn't make the original decision wrong. Especially in cases where the offense was completely over the top and very much crossed a line.
 
Last edited:
This thread was the best thing about GAF post-split. Now it’s the worst. Compare the first 5 pages to the last 5. Nothing but gravedancers and sycophants now. Glad to see O-N-E O-N-E pardoned though. Whatever is going on now, I hope we can one day get back to the original spirit of this thread.
I thought the best thing about GAF was talking about games and community threads like Meta GAF.

Seems like you are only interested in the ban thread nowadays.
 

Redneckerz

Those long posts don't cover that red neck boy
The only way to discuss or argue a ban on most platforms is in private and often can only be made by the person who was banned. Nobody can lobby on your behalf. Gaf is unique in that way.
So... You want to be a banspokesperson and are referring to yourself in the third person.... What kind of power do you possess, fellow citizen?
 

ManofOne

Plus Member
I thought the best thing about GAF was talking about games and community threads like Meta GAF.

Seems like you are only interested in the ban thread nowadays.

Can't speak for Matt but I think I get what he's saying. This thread is about coming together regardless of political and social philosophy and providing a justification for a second chance. You don't

get that in other threads. I don't see Nobody_Important Nobody_Important in Meta-GAF or gaming, or any of the usual political contributors but there is a gloating by some users (not accusing

Nobody_Important Nobody_Important of this incase anyone gets that idea). This thread for me at-least is either letting the dead rest and saying your goodbyes or trying to revive them.
 
Last edited:

CatLady

Plays on Xbox Purr-ies X



Calling people wankers, and then insinuating people who took issue with the change just wanted to treat games like porn is not having a genuine discussion, so you were reply banned. You were also warned that if you continued to make stupid reductive takes and be overly hostile then you would be reply banned in the future.




So that was the first instruction and guidance for you. You then follow up with these:




For which you've been reply banned. Again. Word to the wise, if you're going to put on this facade of IDGAF and call people assholes and wankers, we're not going to look on you sympathetically when you cry about being called one yourself. Take the warnings and grow up, or let us know if you want the perm please.









Ain't going to save you here

OMG that post history after being here 2-3 whole weeks. Yeah you Mods are really unreasonable 🤣:LOL:🤣

This line is priceless though:
I don't know. What did i do wrong? I don't cursed and didn't insult anyone. And as far as i know i didn't treat you any of you assholes with disrepect. So i don't know what the fuck did i do?
 
Can't speak for Matt but I think I get what he's saying. This thread is about coming together regardless of political and social philosophy and providing a justification for a second chance. You don't

get that in other threads. I don't see Nobody_Important Nobody_Important in Meta-GAF or gaming, or any of the usual political contributors but there is a gloating by some users (not accusing

Nobody_Important Nobody_Important of this incase anyone gets that idea). This thread for me at-least is either letting the dead rest and saying your goodbyes or trying to revive them.
You're right, this thread is about letting the dead rest, saying your goodbyes, or advocating for a more lenient punishment.

I disagree with his notion that we're all sycophants and gravedancers though.
 

ManofOne

Plus Member
I thought the best thing about GAF was talking about games and community threads like Meta GAF.

Seems like you are only interested in the ban thread nowadays.

Key word there is "all" though. i don't think he was in insinuating that all of us were, like if you go through the last 5 pages you do see some of that grave dancing and there were ppl being called out for it.
 

ThatGamingDude

I am a virgin
Give it a rest for a bit guys; it's close to after 5PM even on the west coast

Open up a notepad and work on your post until tomorrow during normal business hours

Give these mods a rest and some time to drink some beer eh?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom