Urprobablyright
Banned
There are a lot of game series out there, and as a rule the latest titles tend to have more about them - in a technical, featured sense at least - than opening salvos. There are exceptions to this linear progression premise - Mass Effect famously peaked at 2, and was perhaps most complicated at 1, for instance - but on the ranking ladder of any series there is bound to be a title or two which fall a rung or two belong those leading titles.
What are some games which aren't generally accepted to be the best titles in their respective series, which you nevertheless have a lot of time for, and would state a case for?
Some of mine:
MGS2 - I think everyone can respect certain things about this game, but from Raiden, to what could be considered (by me, if nobody else) a rushed ending, to a - for some - impenetrable plot, a lot of people put this game below MGS3, and even perhaps MGS and MGS4 (does 5 count?) on their rankings. I for one love this title the most, though I probably enjoyed MGS 4 and (shock horror) 5 more, I still think this title was revolutionary (in terms of gameplay and graphics) on release, and later titles owe it a lot.
Far Cry 2 - I really can't stand any of the Far Cry titles after this one. I love the feeling. It came out at around the same time that I saw a little film called Blood Diamond and to me it allowed me to step onto those sunbaked plains and sunscorched forests myself. I thought the oppressive atmosphere and pacing was pitch perfect, the maps were technically impressive and varied, the story was just a light touch and gave you plenty of time for exploration, yeah I just liked it. The forced cinematic nature of later titles just totally failed to register with me.
Civilization 3 - Heaps of people adore Civ IV and beyond (I loved Leonard Nemoy's narration of Civ IV, no doubt) for me Civ 3 was the ultimate refinement of the original format of the game, and it holds a higher place in my gaming pantheon than other, more modern titles. Civ 3 was the last 2D version, and man that art style really caught my imagination. It looked great in every age, even when you got to modern times and railways covered your zones... I just loved it mightily.
Operation Flashpoint - vs. the ARMA games, I still think OpFlash was the best of the bunch. It was bare bones and pretty indy, but at the time the graphics were pretty artful (with some decent lighting and draw distance making up for bad models and textures) and it was one of the only titles in the entire pantheon of games (including Dragon Rising) that had not one, but three, coherent and stable, scripted campaigns to enjoy. Get your hands on the demo, play the 'Assault' mission on hard, and yeah tell me it doesn't have a little je ne sais quois to it.
Empire: Total War - when I look back at my favourite games in series, I have to think about what emotions they gave me at the time of playing them... And really, besides RTW, Empire was the one that most blew my mind. It was so much bigger, smoother, prettier than Medieval 2 (I auto resolved any sieges, so to me that whole combat bug never happened), it felt more chill, it felt like i was really the head of an Empire, it had a huge number of factions and really beautiful graphics~ Yeah, I just loved this game a lot. Of course, Warhammer 2, with it's third party turbocharge, is to my mind the best of the series, but I just really have oodles of time for this title.
What are some games which aren't generally accepted to be the best titles in their respective series, which you nevertheless have a lot of time for, and would state a case for?
Some of mine:
MGS2 - I think everyone can respect certain things about this game, but from Raiden, to what could be considered (by me, if nobody else) a rushed ending, to a - for some - impenetrable plot, a lot of people put this game below MGS3, and even perhaps MGS and MGS4 (does 5 count?) on their rankings. I for one love this title the most, though I probably enjoyed MGS 4 and (shock horror) 5 more, I still think this title was revolutionary (in terms of gameplay and graphics) on release, and later titles owe it a lot.
Far Cry 2 - I really can't stand any of the Far Cry titles after this one. I love the feeling. It came out at around the same time that I saw a little film called Blood Diamond and to me it allowed me to step onto those sunbaked plains and sunscorched forests myself. I thought the oppressive atmosphere and pacing was pitch perfect, the maps were technically impressive and varied, the story was just a light touch and gave you plenty of time for exploration, yeah I just liked it. The forced cinematic nature of later titles just totally failed to register with me.
Civilization 3 - Heaps of people adore Civ IV and beyond (I loved Leonard Nemoy's narration of Civ IV, no doubt) for me Civ 3 was the ultimate refinement of the original format of the game, and it holds a higher place in my gaming pantheon than other, more modern titles. Civ 3 was the last 2D version, and man that art style really caught my imagination. It looked great in every age, even when you got to modern times and railways covered your zones... I just loved it mightily.
Operation Flashpoint - vs. the ARMA games, I still think OpFlash was the best of the bunch. It was bare bones and pretty indy, but at the time the graphics were pretty artful (with some decent lighting and draw distance making up for bad models and textures) and it was one of the only titles in the entire pantheon of games (including Dragon Rising) that had not one, but three, coherent and stable, scripted campaigns to enjoy. Get your hands on the demo, play the 'Assault' mission on hard, and yeah tell me it doesn't have a little je ne sais quois to it.
Empire: Total War - when I look back at my favourite games in series, I have to think about what emotions they gave me at the time of playing them... And really, besides RTW, Empire was the one that most blew my mind. It was so much bigger, smoother, prettier than Medieval 2 (I auto resolved any sieges, so to me that whole combat bug never happened), it felt more chill, it felt like i was really the head of an Empire, it had a huge number of factions and really beautiful graphics~ Yeah, I just loved this game a lot. Of course, Warhammer 2, with it's third party turbocharge, is to my mind the best of the series, but I just really have oodles of time for this title.
Last edited: