Support NeoGAF

[SlimySnake]

Microsoft just finished their E3 conference. 30 games shown. Pretty much everything on Gamepass. Forza Horizon and Halo are 2021 holiday titles.

How would you rate it?

I would've liked to see Fablo, Hellblade, Avowed and Perfect Dark so it was kinda disappointing.

 

[VN1X]

C. And I'm being generous.

Too many shooters, Not enough gameplay. Not enough truly riveting titles. I own a Series X but I wish I had a PS5...

 

[LordCBH]

B. Would’ve been an A if they showed more things for this year. (Or if they showed me fucking avowed goddammit.)

 

[vaibhavpisal]

Smashing.

Killed it.

 

[FunkMiller]

C Plus. Very strong start, fell flat as it went on, nice upturn for Forza and then ended on some utter dogshit.

 

[LQX]

I'll say this. Everything they showed I actually want to play, so it's a good thing I have game pass.

 

[DavJay]

Good show but no megaton. B+

 

[Dr.Morris79]

Was there no more BC titles added? Or the Minecraft update?

 

[Yselacrey00]

They had only one great game and it was Forza. So that tells you a lot about their conference.

Halo? So they delay the game to improve the campaign and a year later they show us multiplayer instead, these guys are genius.

 

[Arun1910]

B.

Better than expected and that is thanks to Starfield and Battlefield.

Forza peaked my interest for the first time ever. They shouldn't have shown MP for Halo seeing as they have Campaign damage control to do. I'm looking forward to A Plague Tale again.

 

[Stuart360]

I was going to say B, but Forza Horizon turned it for me, a big fat A.
Best Microsoft conferencre in years, and one of the best overall E3 conferences in years.

 

[TrumpacShakur]

Not great, not terrible.

 

[Coolwhhip]

6 ish. If this was supposed to be the one where they show the world you need to own an Xbox instead of a Playstation, it failed for sure. Still the same old first party problem. During the Horizon Zero Dawn 2 reveal I was on the edge of my seat and during this thing I was mostly

 

[iQuasarLV]

Those rating a B~A range. You must be out of your goddamn minds. Almost all of the stuff they showed could easily be shown 1-2 E3 conferences away. I counted 5 games that are releasing the 2021 calendar year. Pathetic.

 

[bender]

The lineup for the year and Gamepass really make the back half of this year great. It does seem like a lot of the more interesting, new stuff they are working on is pretty far off. Solid B.

 

[VinnyMac]

D for me honestly ot was your typical Ms conference everything looked good but alot of 22 dates and even 23s like what's the point?

 

[begotten]

C for Craig

 

[.Pennywise]

Sorry, I only do numbers.

7/10

Was an ok conference, a lot of gamepass games, not so much gameplay as always, but the pacing was on point.

And too much 2022 too

 

[Wandering Leopard]

Great show, probably MS' best ever showing. I don't believe in perfect scores, but it was very good.

 

[LordCBH]

Halo? So they delay the game to improve the campaign and a year later they show us multiplayer instead, these guys are genius.

And still can’t give a concrete date for it. My confidence in that 2021 tag is low.

 

[azertydu91]

I don't know how to rate it honestly.
From a ps/PC gamer it was a great conf with lot of things to play...But way too much timed exclusives and CGI.
They barely showed anything of Starfield, I still don't know what the game is and the one more thing was disapointing.
So a great conf for games but for Xbox not so much.

The high note for me was Forza which is by far the best looking upcoming MS game.

Edit: It is still the best conference yet, of a very disapointing E3.

 

[iorek21]

B

Not a lot of gameplay and I didn't really find most things interesting. Gamepass was the star of the show with its huge amount of content being released day one, but that's it.

A great show for Gamepass, but not so much for games individually.

Forza Horizon 5 and Battlefield are the highlights for me.

 

[IbizaPocholo]

B, good but not outstanding.

 

[Banjo64]

100% a B or 8/10.

Anyone saying otherwise has a motive.

 

[Renozokii]

C.
Everything is next year or further, cgi up the ass with Microsoft continuing to announce games that are barely done with a cgi trailer, halo doesn’t look great, and they really didn’t show anything new and exciting.
Only reason for a c and not lower is forza looks pretty good, even as a non fan of racing games I recognize that looked good. And some of the indies looked pretty legit.

 

[Chiggs]

B+

Sold on:

• Forza Horizon 5
• Stalker 2
• Replaced
• Flight Simulator
• Game Pass
• Halo Infinite multi-player
• Far Cry 6

Interested in:

• Redfall
• Starfield

Concerned, yet intrigued, by:

• Halo Infinite single-player

 

[odhiex]

I have enjoyed a couple of it's announcements, could have been better. B or B+ for me.

 

[Kilau]

They covered a lot of stuff so it was good but no bombs so keeps it from next level amazing.

 

[Craig of War]

C+ for the show but in terms of Games coming to gamepass it a A the crazy amounts of games coming to gamepass day 1 is too good.

 

[Yselacrey00]

And still can’t give a concrete date for it. My confidence in that 2021 tag is low.

Well, I did say last year that
If they wanted to make it right then this game wasn't coming in 2021.

Maybe that's what's happening? They are making it right and that's why they didn't show anything? It's a least two years of reworking if they plan on fixing it.

 

[BootsLoader]

it’s a very very solid B, their best effort so far. Not much talking, many games. They learned from their last mistakes. Bravo!

 

[Jack Videogames]

C+/B-. Too much of a multiplayer focus and most games were very samey. ESVI, Fable, Fallout, Avowed absent. Not for me.

 

[Captain Toad]

It seemed decent, but the only games I personally see myself playing are Diablo 2 and Eiyuden Chronocile both of which are multi-platform and the later not releasing until 2023.

 

[Nezzeroth]

It's a C from me. Way too many shooters. I felt like I was seeing the same game over and over (even same kind of trailers).

Outer Worlds 2 was funny and I liked Redfall, but there was no gameplay for either.

 

[Chukhopops]

Really good but surprised at some missing games. Forza 5 looks out of this world though, true next gen for sure.

 

[Cert.in.Death]

Handful of standouts, but too many updates via DLC packs, CG trailers, and extended gameplay cuts (Forza and Redfall felt way too long). Also 2022 much?

Maybe I’m jaded and want to pick apart gameplay segments over all else.

Best of show: Stalker 2

 

[Salty Popsicle]

Those rating a B~A range. You must be out of your goddamn minds. Almost all of the stuff they showed could easily be shown 1-2 E3 conferences away. I counted 5 games that are releasing the 2021 calendar year. Pathetic.

Didn't Sony come out last year saying GOW2, GT7, and Horizon 2 would be 2021 titles and PS5 exclusive? What happened?

 

[Elios83]

A disappointment relatively to the expectations.
Insiders were talking about mega exclusives, Kojima, 3 studios acquired, Battlefield on Gamepass...and so on.
The reality is that Halo needs a new dev team that makes the brand justice and the rest is late 2022 onwards.

 

[SaturnSaturn]

B-

Lots of cool shit, but ending it with redfall was a mistake

 

[reinking]

A. They showed enough to close out this year and saved some for next. Their goal is to keep us on Game Pass. Glad they didn't waste any more time with games that will not be out in the next 24 months. Of course there were the filler titles but that is to be expected.

I might be easily pleased though since I am just sitting here waiting to play 12 Minutes.

 

[Ass of Can Whooping]

5/10

Would have been a 6/10 if they didn't end with that travesty Redfall

I can't believe Arkane has been reduced to trash like that and Deathloop. Shows how much of a lie #SavePlayer1 was

 

[sunnysideup]

felt like a bunch of free to play games.

 

[Inxes]

This is the definition of low 7 out of 10. It's good, solid, knows what the thing is about, it presents itself well, it has rhythm... but yeah, nothing special came out of it.

 

[Renozokii]

100% a B or 8/10.

Anyone saying otherwise has a motive.

Depends on your standards. With the e3 being so next year or later heavy it’ll mean Xbox fans from launch 2020 to end of year 2021 only get 2-3 first parties which is pretty ridiculous. And how can you like the bullshots and cgi? I mean cmon with our worlds 2. Not even a generic 2022 or 2023 release time frame. That’s another game added to the list of Microsoft announcements with no gameplay or release anywhere on the horizon. Stalker 2 was not gameplay. Starfield still having no gameplay. I thought the show sucked. I don’t need to be marketed to for games coming at an unspecified time somewhere in the future.

 

[RoboEight]

B for me, lot's of cool stuff shown but I really would have liked to see some more JP games. Some of the shooters were kind of meh. Halo needed a gameplay demo of the campaign. Starfield looks nice but my rule of thumb is until I see the game running I don't get my hopes up. Still a big win for Gamepass you certainly can't complain with all these titles coming to it. I'm personally not a huge Bethesda fan so it was like the games look cool and if you are a fan of Bethesda you'll certainly get a nice catalogue of games so that's nice.

 

[SlimeGooGoo]

.

 

[Banjo64]

It seemed decent, but the only games I personally see myself playing are Diablo 2 and Eiyuden Chronocile both of which are multi-platform and the later not releasing until 2023.

You not interested in Psychonauts Toad? I think that game is shaping up very nicely.

 

[Represent.]

D.

Way too many shooters.

Too much CGI

Not enough gameplay

THEY DIDNT RE-REVEAL HALO SP.

STARFIELD no gameplay

NO HELLBLADE

No in depth gameplay deep dives for ANYTHING BUT FORZA.

Come on.

Changing my rating to

F.

 

[Salty Popsicle]

Sorry, I only do numbers.

7/10

Was an ok conference, a lot of gamepass games, not so much gameplay as always, but the pacing was on point.

And too much 2022 too

Most of the titles shown today will release before God of War Ragnarok or GT7 release...

 

[jakinov]

7/10
- forza was purty
- Indie games were interesting
- some indie games were not
- Halo MP trailer was cool
- liked that they didn't show too much gameplay, live gameplay demos sucks and like every E3 there's hoursof dev walkthrough after that get posted, they are long and slow they only work well for gameplay that's highly cinematic like games from Sony where every other 5 seconds is a mini-cutscene.
-