• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
  • Hey Guest. Check out the NeoGAF 2.2 Update Thread for details on our new Giphy integration and other new features.

Opinion Eurogamer’s Review of Wasteland 3

tsumake

Member
Dec 3, 2019
509
525
430
I don’t often read reviews of games anymore. I find video reviews and forum threads to be more informative. However I was curious about the latest Wasteland game. The author titled it a “brilliant satire” and I was curious what this game was satirizing.

The author has a decent voice and describes his adventuring in Colorado. He describes all the scenarios he encountered and how much fun he was having. The only direct satire I could find in the article was about of cult of Ronald Reagan. That was it. He apparently put in 55 hours into the game and he just hammered that point about Reagan twice.

Ok.

He continues bloviating about his wonderful experiences in the game. When it came to the actual gameplay he said it’s not as good as XCOM. No description of the combat mechanics, no comparison to WL2, just a general blithe statement.

Ok.

He ends his glowing review with this pearl:

“Wasteland 3 is a no-holds barred teardown of the American Dream, a parody of a nation that is now beyond parody. It is a satire you get to direct, and I heartily recommend doing so.”

Ok.

I know that games journalism is in dire straits, so I shouldn’t be surprised. He doesn’t back up his thesis. He basically says “I love this game because the game is funny and developers are obviously saying ‘Murrica.’ “ It just reinforces his perception of America. There could have been real satire in the game - a skewering of Cold War politics, a look at Rocky Mountain culture, pop culture references, but he doesn’t mention any of it. And again, he doesn’t mention gameplay mechanics at all.

Anyway, here’s the article:


Amusez vous
 

JLMC469

Banned
Feb 6, 2018
1,831
3,699
445
He's a fucking moron. Trying to act like the big boys and dry humping the 'Murrica is bad angle like everyone else is.

But North Amurica is so easy to satire right now:

 
  • Like
Reactions: chilichote

Vaelka

Member
Apr 1, 2019
681
949
460
Oh look, it's Wesley Yin-Poole.
Not surprised.

I stopped reading Eurogamer because of him, he's the guy who went on about DoA6 constantly writing hitpieces after hitpieces about it and brought up Trump in his '' review '' of the game.
The fact that his '' review '' was even published at all really speaks volumes for how there's no quality control.
In his article on the original Tomb Raider games which was actually decent he couldn't restrain himself from shaming classic Lara and going on the tired rant about her being '' oversexualized ''.
He also wrote those hitpieces on Skullgirls I remember and even followed it up with another hitpiece when the dev mentioned that the lead animator was a woman and took what he said totally out of context and made it sound like he was using her as a shield or something.

Wesley Yin-Poole is seriously every negative stereotype about a game journalist in one person.
Kirk Mckeand comes to mind too, how that guy still has a job is just insane to me especially since he has publically attacked other game journalists too and how he behaves on Twitter.