• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Better two year launch line up, Xbox One or Xbox Series?

Better lineup after two years

  • Xbox One

    Votes: 75 74.3%

  • Xbox Series S and X

    Votes: 26 25.7%
  • Total voters
    101
Yoboman

Yoboman

Member
Same rules as other thread. Nov 22 2013 - Nov 22 2015. Late ports and third party exclusives not included. Bold indicates cross gen

Xbox One First two Years

  • Forza Motorsport 5
  • Killer Instinct
  • Ryse Son of Rome
  • Forza Horizon 2
  • Sunset Overdrive
  • Ori and the Blind Forest
  • Forza Motorsport 6
  • Halo 5
Xbox Series First two Years
  • Forza Horizon 5
  • Psychonauts 2
  • Halo Infinite
  • Grounded
  • Gears 5 Hivebusters
  • As Dusk Falls
  • Pentiment
let me know if I missed any games
 
T

Three

Member
Wasn't Hivebusters DLC or was it sold as a standalone game too?
If it's just DLC what's it doing there 😄

GymWolf said:
Xbox one, no doubt.

X360 crush both with ease.
Click to expand...

Mass Effect and Bioshock were amazing but I'm not sure how better 360 would fare on the first party list above. Xbox One would have them beat I think.
 
Last edited:
anthony2690

anthony2690

Banned
I think you have missed flight simulator & deathloop, regardless of being late ports they are actually first party.

But if third party exclusives do not count (noticed you didn't put Titanfall, Crimson, lococycle Dragon & DR3) doesn't that mean you shouldn't be counting sunset overdrive, Ori and the blind forest, ryse son of Rome & as dusk falls?

OP you broke your own rules!

Anyway I voted series X, as halo infinite, Forza horizon 5 & psychonauts 2 have been some of my fave games ever on the platform.

Also I really really want a new killer instinct that comes close to the quality of street fighter 6 now :(
 
Last edited:
T

Three

Member
MidGenRefresh said:
You missed Microsoft Flight Simulator.

Also, most (if not all) of the games you listed are playable on Xbox One.

So, yeah, this gen is a joke.
Click to expand...
The ones that are bolded are crossgen.

anthony2690 said:
I think you have missed flight simulator

But if third party exclusives do not count (noticed you didn't put Titanfall, Crimson Dragon & DR3) doesn't that mean you shouldn't be counting sunset overdrive, Ori and the blind forest, ryse son of Rome & as dusk falls?

Anyway I voted series X, as halo infinite, Forza horizon 5 & psychonauts 2 have been some of my fave games ever on the platform.

Also I really really want a new killer instinct that comes close to the quality of street fighter 6 now :(
Click to expand...
Titanfall was published by EA. The games above are all first party. MS published. Good call on Dead Rising 3.
 
Last edited:
makaveli60

makaveli60

Member
Xbox One and it’s not even a contest. 2 years in and we can’t even see when this gen will start properly without the shackles of lastgen, if ever. PS5 is the same, but at least it has 1 proper nextgen game (Ratchet and Clank).
 
anthony2690

anthony2690

Banned
Three said:
The ones that are bolded are crossgen.


Titanfall was published by EA. The games above are all first party. MS published. Good call on Dead Rising 3.
Click to expand...
OP says "no third party exclusives" :p
Plus ori & the blind forest is on the switch, I double dipped on that game, loved it :)

Even if published by Microsoft, they are still third party devs right? :p
 
Last edited:
T

Three

Member
anthony2690 said:
OP says "no third party exclusives" :p
Plus ori & the blind forest is on the switch, I double dipped on that game, loved it :)

Even if published by Microsoft, they are still third party right? :p
Click to expand...
They are classified as first party if they are published by MS. Some people call this second party but technically the term doesn't exist.

If the studio was important no game would be first party because even with the likes of Halo Infinite and Killer Instinct other third party studios developed it.

MidGenRefresh said:
Forza Horizon 2 on Xbox 360 was a different game than what we got on Xbox One. It's not cross-gen as we understand it now.
Click to expand...
Never played the 360 version so never knew this, how did it differ?
 
Last edited:
anthony2690

anthony2690

Banned
Three said:
They are classified as first party if they are published by MS. Some people call this second party but technically the term doesn't exist.

If the studio was important no game would be first party because even with the likes of Halo Infinite and Killer Instinct other third party studios developed it.
Click to expand...
Good point!
Then again killer instinct was done by third party devs too.
Loved that game, huge shame we still don't have a new title, but I'm hoping with stuff like sf6 raising the bar, if it ever returns, I hope they will be influenced :)

I wouldn't even complain if they released the next game on playstation either, if it got the game more presence in the fgc & it means my friends on others platforms can experience it too :)
 
MidGenRefresh

MidGenRefresh

*Refreshes biennially
Three said:
Never played the 360 version so never knew this, how did it differ?
Click to expand...

360 version was developed on older engine used for the first game. The biggest difference is the map. A lot of areas were cut / downsized. Most of the country side is not accessible, I think that 360 version don't even haver cross-country events. Graphically it's also a completly different game, not a simple "one or two presets down" that we have today.

 
Frank Horrigan

Frank Horrigan

Banned
How is this even a question?

When it comes to launch line ups, the OG xbox had a better line up than xboxs 4th console.

In a room of ex xbox heads, Phil Spencer would be laughed out of it for the embarrassing line up.

When Don "watch how badly I can fuck xbox up" Mattrick puts out a better line up than you, it's time to leave.

Op you missed out dead rising from the xbox one list and NFL live tv games (lol)
 
Last edited:
GymWolf

GymWolf

Member
Three said:
Wasn't Hivebusters DLC or was it sold as a standalone game too?
If it's just DLC what's it doing there 😄



Mass Effect and Bioshock were amazing but I'm not sure how better 360 would fare on the first party list above. Xbox One would have them beat I think.
Click to expand...
You forgot condemned, the best first person horror brawler ever created.
 
Skifi28

Skifi28

Member
Frank Horrigan said:
How is this even a question?

When it comes to launch line ups, the OG xbox had a better line up than xboxs 4th console.

In a room of ex xbox heads, Phil Spencer would be laughed out of it for the embarrassing line up.

When Don "watch how badly I can fuck xbox up" Mattrick puts out a better line up than you, it's time to leave.
Click to expand...

I guess gamepass > everything else.
 
Yoboman

Yoboman

Member
anthony2690 said:
I think you have missed flight simulator & deathloop, regardless of being late ports they are actually first party.

But if third party exclusives do not count (noticed you didn't put Titanfall, Crimson, lococycle Dragon & DR3) doesn't that mean you shouldn't be counting sunset overdrive, Ori and the blind forest, ryse son of Rome & as dusk falls?

OP you broke your own rules!

Anyway I voted series X, as halo infinite, Forza horizon 5 & psychonauts 2 have been some of my fave games ever on the platform.

Also I really really want a new killer instinct that comes close to the quality of street fighter 6 now :(
Click to expand...
Just following the same criteria as the other thread for consistency, so that's why Flight Sim and Deathloop aren't counted but I think it's fair those are big games for Series X still. Xbox One also had some good ones in retrospect if he we include third party like Titanfall and Tomb Raider

Sunset, Ori, Ryse and Dusk Falls are all MS published so have counted as first party publishing.
 
Pelta88

Pelta88

Member
XB1 by a country mile. The comparison between games got me in my feelings too. In my opinion, games like Ryse, Ori, & Sunset when compared to Grounded and Pentiment shows a staggering drop in quality.

Truly sad shit.

857ed1aae6c3d465eb6de96f5c1475da35a1136d.gif
 
Last edited:
J

jorgejjvr

Gold Member
I get the rules this is setting, but in reality we get consoles to play all sorts of games. I can see that list and say One had better exclusives. But in actuality, I didn't play them. Killer instinct and horizon, a car game,I would have never given a shot at full price. But now due to gp, I found I Love horizon 5 , even tho I'm no car guy. with gp I actually get to play all those, were with the One I had to be picky and basically only had Halo

Furthermore, all the other 200+ games in the service means more games to play than on the One

Edit: I also found I liked Ori by trying it on my series x due to gp, but not originally when it came out on the One
 
Last edited:
E

Evil Calvin

Afraid of Boobs
Yoboman said:
Same rules as other thread. Nov 22 2013 - Nov 22 2015. Late ports and third party exclusives not included. Bold indicates cross gen

Xbox One First two Years

  • Forza Motorsport 5
  • Killer Instinct
  • Ryse Son of Rome
  • Forza Horizon 2
  • Sunset Overdrive
  • Ori and the Blind Forest
  • Forza Motorsport 6
  • Halo 5
Xbox Series First two Years
  • Forza Horizon 5
  • Psychonauts 2
  • Halo Infinite
  • Grounded
  • Gears 5 Hivebusters
  • As Dusk Falls
  • Pentiment
let me know if I missed any games
Click to expand...
Considering zero games of note came out this year...I would pick Xbox One (Grounded was early access for two years), As Dusk Falls is an indie really. All of the others was last year.......and Pentiment isn't out.

Nothing resembling AAA has come out by a MS studio this year.

How does that even happen Phil?
 
Roberts

Roberts

Member
This gen. Psychonauts 2 is one of my favourite games ever. Grounded is top3 games this year. Hivebusters might be short but it is just about the most fun and best paced Gears campaign ever. HI is way better than 5. FH5 is the best FH. And I really hope Pentiment is going to blow me away. Oh, and As Dusk Falls was super fun playing with a friend.
 
EverydayBeast

EverydayBeast

thinks Halo Infinite is a new graphical benchmark
First two years of a console don’t blow people away I think halo infinite is better than halo 5.
 
FeralEcho

FeralEcho

Member
I didn't own an Xbox one since I didn't have an Xbox console last gen and I find myself playing mostly Xbox one and good old 360 games that i loved back in the day through the amazing BC.so yeah Xbox one for sure between the two...no contest.
 
remember_spinal

remember_spinal

Banned
If i were making the list i probably wouldn’t have included Hivebusters as its DLC, the same way I didn’t include Ghost of Tsushima DLC expansion or Death Strandings
 
K

Kvally

Banned
Evil Calvin said:
Considering zero games of note came out this year...I would pick Xbox One (Grounded was early access for two years), As Dusk Falls is an indie really. All of the others was last year.......and Pentiment isn't out.

Nothing resembling AAA has come out by a MS studio this year.

How does that even happen Phil?
Click to expand...
True. And it's a good thing Sony delayed God of War, Gran Turismo and Horizon to this year, instead of the original 2021 releases. 2022 would look BAAAD for them. They probably should have moved one of them to 2023 alongside Spider-Man 2.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Insomniac leak indirectly revealed sales of Xbox first-party games on PC
Sales-Age 2 3 4
191
14K
Doctor Hades replied
Poll Shows Players Want Gears of War Above Halo as The Most Wanted Xbox Series on PlayStation
Community 2 3
115
5K
Lupin25 replied
IGN: Phil Spencer Has Now Been Head of Xbox for 10 Years; We Look Back at His First Decade
Opinion Analysis 2 3
130
7K
ZehDon replied
Xbox Black Friday starts on November 17
News Hype Platform 2 3
121
7K
Leonidas replied
  • Locked
Rumor - Xbox Live Gold Being Retired - Replaced by Game Pass "Core" - $9.99 - Game Pass Discounts w/ Limited Selection of "Free" Games at Launch
2 3
147
8K
ReBurn replied
Top Bottom