• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Which flagship Xbox series did you like best last gen? (Xbox One)

Which was your favorite Xbox series last gen?

  • Forza

    Votes: 69 51.1%
  • Gears

    Votes: 49 36.3%
  • Halo

    Votes: 17 12.6%

  • Total voters
    135
The big 3 of Xbox IPS are Forza, Gears, and Halo. These Ips have been instrumental for Xbox since the beginning (except Forza that replaced Project Gotham) and are the biggest known IPS in Xbox history.

However I feel things changed last gen with the Xbox One releases in these franchises.

I feel like that Halo had fallen behind Forza last generation not just in the amount of players, but the quality of the games and the consistency. The Halo MCC was a mess, and with it having been mostly fixed for awhile now it will be hard, especially for new comers, to really understand how bad it actually got with Halo MCC. then you had the lukewarm reception of Halo 5, and the mixed response of Halo Infinite after it was delayed twice due to incompetence and fan frustration. The hype seems to have died down with Infinite, with player counts mirror the drop we saw with Halo 4.

Forza Motorsport and Forza Horizon have been consistent in quality, fan feedback, addressing problems, fun updates, and they have received high sales and active player counts as a result. The games active players lasting years instead of a few months before declining. They also score highly on average can move systems on their own. At one point if it hasn't already happened I expect the Forza to become the top system selling IP for Xbox unless Halo changes direction.

In second, Gears has lost some luster but is still a major franchise. Gears 4 due to a leak is said to have had about 6 million players, Gears 5 did well, and while both aren't that remarkable and follow the traditional Gears formula they are solid games and fans feedback is appreciated.

If there's one thing for certain these 3 franchises definitely ended up going on different paths from where they were on the 360, that's for sure.
 

Aion002

Member
Forza.

I liked every game from the series, while the others... Well..

Jimmy Fallon GIF by The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon
 

Lasha

Member
I voted Forza because the franchise produces the best console racing. Sea of Thieves is my favorite IP from the Xbox one period even though I play it on PC. Rare Replay was the console's coolest exclusive.
 

Fbh

Member
I haven't played the Forza in years so I can't say much about it.

But between Gears and Halo definitely Gears. Didn't care much for the campaign on Halo 4 or 5, but Gears 4-5 were pretty fun in coop even though I still prefer the original trilogy.
 

PhaseJump

Banned
Forza Horizon 2 is absolutely awesome. The sequels got shitty and more bloated or complicated with the character plot, left side driving, and the control didn't feel as tight.
 

Codes 208

Member
Halo only because Halo MCC eventually got good. Even if it did take them four years to fix it. Ive already made my statements before that i think 5 is absolute dog shit and infinite’s multiplayer was the final nail in the coffin (f2p “live service” my ass)

Forza is a good racing sim but frankly i couldnt care less. Needs more rockets or blue shells. Something something “theyre making another left turn!”

Gears 4 was ok at most. I didnt care for fighting DB’s for roughly 2/3 of the game and the multiplayer felt like a copy and paste of 3’s minus the sawed-off.
Gears 5 however…kinda sucked even worse. like the campaign is ok but the ending scenario and character assassination of JD ruined it all for me. The multiplayer was a buggy mess of a shit show last time i played. Definitley one of those “im glad i got gamepass for this” kind of games.


So overall?: Sea of Thieves. Sea of Thieves is easily MS’ best contribution last gen.
 

0neAnd0nly

Member
You’d have to be really anti-car games to pick anything other than Forza from this list IMO.

Halo hasn’t been strong since 2, GoW hasn’t had the same impact since #1.

Forza as a series has gotten more popular since it’s beginning, not less.
 

Apocryphon

Member
Ori and Ryse. I don't understand how people can out up with the tackyness in the Forza Horizon games and Halo after Reach has been garbage. Gears was ok, but still didn't reach the heights of the 360 games. Gears 5 is good, but the Hivebusters DLC was better.
 

supernova8

Banned
I voted Forza because the franchise produces the best console racing. Sea of Thieves is my favorite IP from the Xbox one period even though I play it on PC. Rare Replay was the console's coolest exclusive.
I didn't even play it and yet I think Sea of Thieves was probably the best franchise. Would have loved to play it on PS4.
 
Forza Motorsport has been a staple for me since the second game released. I missed the first FM because I didn't have an OG Xbox but I've played it plenty since and wish I'd played it when it released. The Forza Horizon games are basically a string of my favorite arcade racers, I never get tired of them.
 

Lasha

Member
I didn't even play it and yet I think Sea of Thieves was probably the best franchise. Would have loved to play it on PS4.
I would find a PC to try SoT. SoT scales remarkably well. I love that Microsoft let at AAA studio produce a PvPvE game centered around group play with no artificial progression. SoT is such an outlier and I love it.
 

Robb

Gold Member
Out of the list, probably Forza. Although I’d go with Ori as the highlight of MS first party for me last gen.
 

ZehDon

Gold Member
In my opinion, Forza's been their best first party series for a while now. Gears 4 and 5 were solid titles, but they're struggling to re-capture the series' heyday. Needs a big shakeup - and open world isn't it. Halo was a bad joke last gen and, so far, it's prospects aren't looking much better this gen.
 

Havoc2049

Member
Sea of Thieves.

Just checked the Steam Charts.
Sea of Thieves: 19,353 24-hour peak

Forza Horizon 5: 8,814 24-hour peak
Halo Infinite: 5,769 24-hour peak
Gears 5: 263 24-hour peak
Combined: 14, 846 24-hour peak

US Microsoft Store Charts:
12. Forza Horizon 5
19. Halo Infinite
26. Sea of Thieves

UK Microsoft Most Played Charts:
11. Forza Horizon 5
19. Sea of Thieves
Halo Infinite doesn't even chart.

Gears 5 hasn't been on the Microsoft charts since like mid-2021.
 

JohnnyFootball

GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
Honestly, none of those were great. It's pretty telling how bad MS has been with exclusives since the early 2010s. Kinect truly sent them on a catastrophic downward style.
From 2006-2010 Xbox had such an incredible string of exclusives from Bioshock, Mass Effect, Halo 3, Alan Wake....etc.

Gears has been the best of those.
 
Last edited:

Graciaus

Member
None of those. Halo and Gears were both terrible compared to past titles. Forza I have no opinion on since I dislike racing games.

Looking at an exclusive list none of them interested me and didn't play most.
 

The_Mike

I cry about SonyGaf from my chair in Redmond, WA
During x360 days I loved i loved Forza gears and halo.

Ms were king of fps third person and racing games.

Now I only see Forza as the real flagship of the three.
 

Kuranghi

Member
It's Ori 2 (1 is fantastic too, but its sort of a Trine 1 > 2 situation, bigger and better in almost every way imo) for me, that game is absolutely magical, I think I'll replay it soon.

Hopefully I can figure out what was plaguing me with HDR as well, it never worked right and unless everyone else including the devs I spoke to have broken eyes (this is very unlikely) I have a plan, based on how GotG and Slywalker Saga's HDR was broken for me, to fix it. In SDR is lovely but obviously the game screams for HDR.
 

Punished Miku

Gold Member
I skipped them all. Been trying to play them a bit since I got my Series S, but there's always too much new stuff to play.

I made it through about 75% of Ryse and I had seen enough at that point. It wasn't bad honestly, but not great. Some awkward sections with arrows, and pushing stuff around.

I'll probably try Recore next one of these days.
 

Goalus

Member
I skipped them all. Been trying to play them a bit since I got my Series S, but there's always too much new stuff to play.

I made it through about 75% of Ryse and I had seen enough at that point. It wasn't bad honestly, but not great. Some awkward sections with arrows, and pushing stuff around.
There is one "arrow section" in Ryse that is pretty challenging actually if you play on legendary difficulty (the one shortly after the arrival at the British coast).
And yes, it's not a bad game (on legendary difficulty, below that it's just mindless button mashing).
If Xbox took Ryse as basis and gave it to a talented in-house team with the goal to make it "bigger and better", they could have their God of War after two or three games.
 
would it be possible to split up Forza Motorsport & Forza Horizon in the poll? I don't care about sims but I enjoy the Horizon games

That's like asking me to split Halo based on before or after 343. It's the same franchise.

If Xbox took Ryse as basis and gave it to a talented in-house team with the goal to make it "bigger and better", they could have their God of War after two or three games.

In the Xbox One gen that might as well be suicide. They needed hits much quicker, and Crytek was the developer and you know how slow they were.

Halo. Always Halo. I'm still annoyed i can't play 5 on PC. A glaring omission by Microsoft.

They needed to sell Xbox Ones lol..

Honestly, none of those were great. It's pretty telling how bad MS has been with exclusives since the early 2010s. Kinect truly sent them on a catastrophic downward style.
From 2006-2010 Xbox had such an incredible string of exclusives from Bioshock, Mass Effect, Halo 3, Alan Wake....etc.

Gears has been the best of those.

Some of those you listed were timed or buyouts, not really Microsoft series.

I do remember however when Mass Effect was actually good, those were the days.



You’d have to be really anti-car games to pick anything other than Forza from this list IMO.

There hasn't been much competition among racers or arcade racers for many years now so I can see why some people would avoid racing games since outside of experiments that don't usually get follow ups it's been the same IPs again and again.
 
Top Bottom