• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Naughty Dog Rumored to Be Developing New IP

SSfox

Member
It's good to see but doesn't need to be pointed out.
THIS.

I have nothing against any race, black white asian arabe i mean WHO CARES???? As long as the game is great and the character design have some fitting and sens. Reading thing like "featuring their first Black Lead" as the first thing to introduce a game just make me "EW Okay but why does it matter?" and there is nothing to get excited about.

Raven is my Favorite Ninja of all time, when Namco introduced him, despite being the first Black Ninja in videogame and any fighting game, they just introduced him as brand new character to the Tekken franchise (BTW hope he's coming in Tekken 8 also) , but nowdays everything is political (mostly with western devs, not all but most of) it's kinda snooze fest and so annoying tbh.

Again those who point out all time on this and talk all days about races are the most racists

 
Last edited:
First Black Lead?
d1d7623de7bcf77d44f35470c0ae8488dc3e61f2.gifv

This is bullshit
She’s Caucasian and Indian if I remember correctly.
 

Salz01

Member
This is why I wish Naughty Dog made a narrative focused game where you can build (character creator) any type of character and it would fit to gameplay and narrative they built. It’s the only way forward in this medium and it would appease everybody.
 

Tripolygon

Banned
THIS.

I have nothing against any race, black white asian arabe i mean WHO CARES???? As long as the game is great and the character design have some fitting and sens. Reading thing like "featuring their first Black Lead" as the first thing to introduce a game just make me "EW Okay but why doesn't matter?" and there is nothing to get excited about.
It's almost like there is a history to do with black representation that makes it matter. Because of the fact that representation matters. Because black people being represented in media matters. Because for the first 50 or so years of any media, black representation was made specifically to caricature, denigrate, disparage black image. So yes it matters, it matters that naughtydog wants to create their first lead black character. They are some of the best storytellers in the industry and it matters that they want to put a black face as the lead in their story.

You should rethink why introducing a game as having "first black lead" makes you recoil in disgust.
They seriously have to use racial identity as a tease? It is actually a hype killer. Strange times.
Who are they and who is doing the teasing?
 
Last edited:

JCK75

Member
I wasn't interested until I learned the lead was black, if that doesn't make the game fun nothing will...
 
  • LOL
Reactions: Fbh

Fbh

Member
I look forward to whatever the "B" team that doesn't involve Druckmann is working on.
Hopefully this new IP is by them as Druckmann works on more TLOU or something.
 
This is why I wish Naughty Dog made a narrative focused game where you can build (character creator) any type of character and it would fit to gameplay and narrative they built. It’s the only way forward in this medium and it would appease everybody.

Narrative focused game with a character creator is an oxymoron.

For the narrative focus to be any good it needs character focus, and for character focus you need a defined character not some blank slate for player insertion that ends up being a fucking underdeveloped robot in the story of the game, e.g. Shepherd in ME.
 

JaksGhost

Member
Naughty Dog has said nothing nor is the person making the tweet a verified source but here we are on page 4 with nothing but butthurt Caucasians in an uproar. As much as y'all bitch about "WOKENESS" you're the ones stoking the fire because it makes you angry on a personal level.
 
Last edited:

Romulus

Member
In big companies I think they traditionally design their products (so characters too) thinking on the tastes of their target user. So they offer what they think that type of customer demographics prefers to buy, what they think it's going to sell more between the main kind of people who traditionally or potentially could buy this product.

So in a market like rap, not sure about its market but I'd bet it sells a majority of its copies in USA and the majority of their customers I assume are black, so it makes sense to have mostly black artists.

For a PlayStation Studios game, their main market is Europe and they want to grow big in the biggest gaming market of the world, Asia (which means mostly China). They are selling a $80 game for a $500 toy. So between this type of customer black people is a tiny minority. It isn't like in USA, where black people is over 10% of the population.

In any case I think it's impossible to make everyone happy unless you go via the character editor route.


That's kinda where I was going, but the 90s and 2000s, the majority of rap customers were white by a massive margin. It wasn't even remotely close. And there was almost zero representation despite this. If anything, in their music vids, whites were often portrayed as bad guys, cops or rich corporate sleazeballs. But now since gaming companies are a bunch of pandering sissies, they force color whenever they can, despite the consumer base of black gamers(especially in horror or post apocalyptic games) is likely extremely low. And I highly doubt it's a genuine marketing strategy to bring them in either.
 
Last edited:

Bragr

Banned
It's almost like there is a history to do with black representation that makes it matter. Because of the fact that representation matters. Because black people being represented in media matters. Because for the first 50 or so years of any media, black representation was made specifically to caricature, denigrate, disparage black image.
Yes, but not anymore. Why does representation matter as much in 2021? if it was a few decades ago I would be with you, but right now it's used as a weapon.

White people are put down as slave owners and racists constantly. That's misrepresentation too, and it's broad and ugly and featured in music, movies, tv shows, and comedy shows on a daily basis.

My point is, black representation has progressed and been discussed more than any other culture by far, at this point in time, it's probably the last "culture" or "people" that need representation in media. The work has already been done. There has been a bigger push to get black people into every part of society than any other people in history, people can't keep using argumentation from the 1970s on why you need to push black people into media, they are already there.
 

tmlDan

Member
Hopefully it's not a shooter focused game and they differentiate themselves more from their other entries
they've never made a shooter? Maybe just 1

I wouldn't call LoU a shooter focused game unless you play that way...the only game that is a shooter is Uncharted.
 

truth411

Member
People here would still be crying even if they didn’t mention it once and just showed gameplay. Look how a rumour has people acting already and calling ND woke trash LOL
This 👆🏿 There some serious Snowflaking in this thread. I joke around with Snowflakes (Instant meltdown/fragility) not to worry, if there not Aliens then over 90% lead characters in games are White, so no need to panic. Lol.
 

EverydayBeast

thinks Halo Infinite is a new graphical benchmark
That’s why I love Naughty Dog they have last of us and uncharted in the mix and are still testing the waters, aren’t happy with success.
 

truth411

Member
Yes, but not anymore. Why does representation matter as much in 2021? if it was a few decades ago I would be with you, but right now it's used as a weapon.

White people are put down as slave owners and racists constantly. That's misrepresentation too, and it's broad and ugly and featured in music, movies, tv shows, and comedy shows on a daily basis.

My point is, black representation has progressed and been discussed more than any other culture by far, at this point in time, it's probably the last "culture" or "people" that need representation in media. The work has already been done. There has been a bigger push to get black people into every part of society than any other people in history, people can't keep using argumentation from the 1970s on why you need to push black people into media, they are already there.
This post dont even deserve a Response.

Edit: Mods should just close this thread.
 
Last edited:

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Because there hasnt been a real AAA game with a black lead since like... GTA San Andreas? It was news with Ghosts of Tsushima too except Asian lead. Its good to see
lol What?

  1. Spiderman Miles Morales
  2. Deathloop
  3. Half Life Alyx
  4. Mafia 3
  5. Starhawk
  6. Watch Dogs 2
  7. The Walking Dead
  8. GTAV
  9. Assassin's Creed Origins - This should count as two because both Bayak and his wife were black and playable characters.
  10. Forspoken. Comes out next spring.
Thats 10 games. I am sure I missed some.

I dont think anyone ever complained about any of these characters being black. The problem here is that it seems to be a mandate for ND for whatever reason.
 
Last edited:

Papacheeks

Banned
Here is a little tip for those "why does it matter" folks.

If it does not matter to you, simply shut the fuck up and ignore and let people that it matters, appreciate it.

No offence, no one in here is sayin it doesn't matter. I think many peoples opinions is as long as the game is good why yell at the roof tops about it? Detahloop had 2 black leads, but no one was really shouting on roof tops about it having black leads. Same with Mafia 3. It was part of the story, the game was so-so to be honest, but the characters were all pretty great. I didn't hear anyone yelling at the rooftops?

It's up to designers and developers. I think the louder you yell to bring attention to something the less impact it has culturally. Black Panther is a great example. ANd it was a big deal for a lot of people of color. But it also was a pretty great movie regardless of it's impact.
We are at a place now that having a person of color or minority as a lead is almost like its not a big deal to yell and grab attention about when something comes out. We've had black superheroes since the 70's-80's. Video games were back then a product of Japan which was not multicultural.

But now?

I feel as long as the game is great, then it should not be needing to be yelled at the rooftops about its diversity since when the player plays it they wont be looking for said representation that was advertised. That video someone posted with Morgan Freeman holds true if you want division in everything between how people view the world to go away and have everyone just be called "people".
The issue is places like Resetera, and sometimes threads people make here, are all about making it known to get attention and not about the message. The message comes from any person who plays the game. The more people get used to playing different characters from different ethnicities, then there wont be talking points anymore. It will just be a great game, instead a game with great representation.
Thats mostly peoples thoughts on this.
 
Last edited:

Tripolygon

Banned
Yes, but not anymore. Why does representation matter as much in 2021? if it was a few decades ago I would be with you, but right now it's used as a weapon.

White people are put down as slave owners and racists constantly. That's misrepresentation too, and it's broad and ugly and featured in music, movies, tv shows, and comedy shows on a daily basis.

My point is, black representation has progressed and been discussed more than any other culture by far, at this point in time, it's probably the last "culture" or "people" that need representation in media. The work has already been done. There has been a bigger push to get black people into every part of society than any other people in history, people can't keep using argumentation from the 1970s on why you need to push black people into media, they are already there.
Yes but not anymore? I used the first 50 years just as a representation of longevity, it didn't end after the first 50 years just like how even when slavery was abolished after 400 years of it, it didn't just simply stop and everything was ok from then on. The effects of things from the past are still well and alive to this day. There are actual people who are alive today who experienced slavery. To this day there are racist representations of black characters in media. For the record, I don't need you to be with me on this issue, if it doesn't affect you personally that's fine.

White people are put down as slave owners? Is that really a sentence that you wrote and thought made a valid point?

You are in a thread where people either facetiously or ignorantly dismiss and are getting triggered by a rumor that Naughtydog is making a game featuring their first black lead and your conclusion is enough of black people already, they have been pushed enough. There has been a constant push by black people to advance black representation in media since the very beginning, progress for social equity is not a straight line.
 

brian0057

Banned
It's gonna be a cinematic adventure, in third person, with over-the-shoulder camera, cover based shooting, light stealth, and either a male or female protagonist that may or may not have a bow and arrow.
 
Top Bottom