• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Naughty Dog Rumored to Be Developing New IP

IbizaPocholo

NeoGAFs Kent Brockman

According to an insider that goes by the name @RalphsValve on Twitter, Naughty Dog will be working on a new IP as its next major game. The mysterious insider says very little else about the project in question, but notes that the main protagonist of the game will be a black character. As a whole, what's being expressed here wouldn't be shocking to see come about, but it's important to take it all with a grain of sale. While this insider has had scoops in the past that have later been corroborated by others, it's hard to know if this most recent bit of into will prove to be true in the future.

 

EDMIX

Member

According to an insider that goes by the name @RalphsValve on Twitter, Naughty Dog will be working on a new IP as its next major game. The mysterious insider says very little else about the project in question, but notes that the main protagonist of the game will be a black character. As a whole, what's being expressed here wouldn't be shocking to see come about, but it's important to take it all with a grain of sale. While this insider has had scoops in the past that have later been corroborated by others, it's hard to know if this most recent bit of into will prove to be true in the future.



Well we know they are doing a new IP since after Uncharted 4 so its been a few years.
 

bitbydeath

Member
First Black Lead?
d1d7623de7bcf77d44f35470c0ae8488dc3e61f2.gifv

This is bullshit
 
Last edited:
The rumors about Naughty Dog doing mocap with a black actor started even before TLOU2...and it turned out to be for the character of Isaac.
So i'll take this with a grain of salt for sure.

Was about to post something similar. I wonder if this so-called insider dug up that old piece of "information", or if there is some truth to it after all.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Eh. Admirable as it maybe, Nolan did this and completely miscast Danzel Washington’s son John David Washington. He would’ve been great as Neil. He’s good but not ready to be the male lead. The movie likely suffered as a result. Robert Pattinson should’ve been the male lead.

I don’t have any proof but I think Abby also started as a ‘wouldn’t it be cool to have a butch female lead’ character. Her character suffered as a result IMO. She looked too cartoony and weird to be relatable.

Let’s hope they have a good actor like Isaac’s actor Jeffry Wright lined up to play the lead. He needs to have screen presence and gravitas first and foremost.
 

Justin9mm

Member
The rumors about Naughty Dog doing mocap with a black actor started even before TLOU2...and it turned out to be for the character of Isaac.
So i'll take this with a grain of salt for sure.
NO! As OP suggests, you will take it with a grain of sale !
 
Last edited:

kyliethicc

Member
Eh. Admirable as it maybe, Nolan did this and completely miscast Danzel Washington’s son John David Washington. He would’ve been great as Neil. He’s good but not ready to be the male lead. The movie likely suffered as a result. Robert Pattinson should’ve been the male lead.

I don’t have any proof but I think Abby also started as a ‘wouldn’t it be cool to have a butch female lead’ character. Her character suffered as a result IMO. She looked too cartoony and weird to be relatable.

Let’s hope they have a good actor like Isaac’s actor Jeffry Wright lined up to play the lead. He needs to have screen presence and gravitas first and foremost.
Pattinson was cast as Neil because he's also Max.

 

kyliethicc

Member
Wrong, in the uncharted the lost legacy she is. along side Chloe so technically she is or one of the first african american/south african staring in naughty dogs developed title. this being Nadine and Riley from left behind for the last of us.
By lead, they mean the player character.

Nadine is never playable. Not a real lead character.

Nate, Chloe, Joel, Ellie, & Abby.

5 playable characters from ND on PS3 & PS4, none black.

(Plus technically Sam, Sara, and Cassie are briefly playable. All white.)
 
Last edited:
Eh. Admirable as it maybe, Nolan did this and completely miscast Danzel Washington’s son John David Washington. He would’ve been great as Neil. He’s good but not ready to be the male lead. The movie likely suffered as a result. Robert Pattinson should’ve been the male lead.

I don’t have any proof but I think Abby also started as a ‘wouldn’t it be cool to have a butch female lead’ character. Her character suffered as a result IMO. She looked too cartoony and weird to be relatable.

Let’s hope they have a good actor like Isaac’s actor Jeffry Wright lined up to play the lead. He needs to have screen presence and gravitas first and foremost.

completely agreed

it wouldnt surprise me if ND started design discussions with “we already know that X gender of Y race will be the lead, how do we make a story around that?”

when it should be natural, the story you want to tell may lend itself to a certain race or lead

It is pandering. You look at the game reveals lately and 50% of them seem to be black females. What percentage of the population is that? Why are we having to force that demographic so much into games rather than letting it be more natural? It’s just a way to virtue signal and it’s pretty embarrassing how forced it all is
 

FrankWza

Member
Eh. Admirable as it maybe, Nolan did this and completely miscast Danzel Washington’s son John David Washington. He would’ve been great as Neil. He’s good but not ready to be the male lead. The movie likely suffered as a result. Robert Pattinson should’ve been the male lead.

I don’t have any proof but I think Abby also started as a ‘wouldn’t it be cool to have a butch female lead’ character. Her character suffered as a result IMO. She looked too cartoony and weird to be relatable.

Let’s hope they have a good actor like Isaac’s actor Jeffry Wright lined up to play the lead. He needs to have screen presence and gravitas first and foremost.
Yeah no way branaghs character marries a black woman. The whole movie would need to be recast and rewritten
 

Stooky

Member
completely agreed

it wouldnt surprise me if ND started design discussions with “we already know that X gender of Y race will be the lead, how do we make a story around that?”

when it should be natural, the story you want to tell may lend itself to a certain race or lead

It is pandering. You look at the game reveals lately and 50% of them seem to be black females. What percentage of the population is that? Why are we having to force that demographic so much into games rather than letting it be more natural? It’s just a way to virtue signal and it’s pretty embarrassing how forced it all is
wtf are you talking about? How many games have black leads? One game is rumored to have a black lead and now its pandering? If that's true then the games industry has been pandering to white males for decades.
 
Last edited:

kyliethicc

Member
completely agreed

it wouldnt surprise me if ND started design discussions with “we already know that X gender of Y race will be the lead, how do we make a story around that?”

when it should be natural, the story you want to tell may lend itself to a certain race or lead

It is pandering. You look at the game reveals lately and 50% of them seem to be black females. What percentage of the population is that? Why are we having to force that demographic so much into games rather than letting it be more natural? It’s just a way to virtue signal and it’s pretty embarrassing how forced it all is
If you care, Neil Druckmann said Nadine was not written with any race. Just a woman from South Africa.

Then they cast Laura Bailey to play her.

Later, a character concept artist showed their drawing of Nadine as black.

They liked the look and went for it, despite already casting Bailey.

Hence the white chick playing the black chick.
 
Last edited:
By lead, they mean the player character.

Nadine is never playable. Not a real lead character.

Nate, Chloe, Joel, & Ellie.

4 playable characters from ND on PS3 & PS4, none black.

(Plus technically Sam, Sara, and Cassie are briefly playable. All white.)


Not what they phrased in their response. she wasn't playable but she was or is one of the lead characters for lost legacy. lead role doesn't necessarily mean one character or just the playable character. Two characters can be both lead roles, hence you will get some who for movies "the two leading stars" this can be applied to this particular case. because both of these characters were the leads, with Chloe being the first and Nadine the second.
 

reforen

Member
That Ralph guy has been throwing a lot of "insider" information lately but no one knows about him, better wait for a more trustworthy source, btw his twitter account is around 1 month old
 

Great Hair

Banned
Hire Idris Elba
Not a fan of Idris Elba, don´t find him to be a good lead actor, he is more a second role?actor (like in Thor, Beasts of No Nation) vs. where he plays the lead actor (shitty paris cop-movie, that one against the rock and that stupid bike, him as sniper? in suicide squad reboot ...).

Please, not another marvel IP! Why not give the voice of Kratos a chance? Voice + actor (face, persona) = done!


He’s great in Luther. It depends on the material.
Never watched that one. Thanks for the TV tip.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom