• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Up: Pedro Pascal confirmed to play Joel in HBO's adaptation of TLOU

Status
Not open for further replies.

THEAP99

Banned
Can't say I'm totally on board with this one if they're going to try to be in line with the source material
 

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
giphy.gif


Disappointed by the utter failure of this board to not have used the following:
200.gif

giphy.gif
giphy.gif

Cuz they all suck?
 
I love how every casting choice almost ever, is rot with "what that's a terrible choice" but for this one, the other game board is terrified to say they don't like the choice lol.

Tom Holland as Nathan Drake, "WTF HE'S A TAD TOO SMALL AND HIS ARMS LOOK WEAK" a completely different race swapped Joel, "Wow absolutely flawless". It must be weird being in this weird terrified of everything world where you are scared to speak out because 'Big Brother' is watching to cancel you.
 

Goro Majima

Kitty Genovese Member
Always weird when they cast like this when the original character is already crystallized in the mind to look like a grizzled old white dude. These people have to keep subverting expectations I guess.

Loved him to death in Luke Cage so I’m sure his performance will be great. Just disappointing for some that might have been looking for a 1:1 interpretation from the games to the TV show.
 

kyussman

Member
Is reverse whitewashing a thing,lol.
Won't matter for people just tuning into the latest TV show...but for a fan of the games like me it will be a bit weird....was hoping for a middle aged beardy white dude....but I guess that was just a bridge too far in 2021,lol.
 

EruditeHobo

Member
Would be great casting. The need to have a character be a certain race in stories that aren't about race should be a relic of a bygone age, left in the dust.

That said I'm suspect of the source. Don't know a thing about it, and "has been offered the role" is not typically the kind of thing that becomes newsworthy. At a minimum, it's this outlet getting their industry terminology wrong...
 

kyliethicc

Member
jaime lannister GIF by Game of Thrones


He should be casted instead ^^
Nah. Too clearly European and somewhat.. too nice. Doesn't come across as Texan.
Not that this black guy would be any better. They need a legit angry Texan / southern American actor who can pull off the dark side of Joel.

Off the top of my head... maybe Ethan Hawke if he bulked up. He's Texan and old enough. Idk.
Or just throw enough money at Matthew McConaughey or Brad Pitt to get one of them to do it.
Both could pull it off and look the role. Those 2 guys can fucking act.
 
Last edited:

Dabaus

Banned
Black lead watchman and bat girl shows completely bombed out. We’re talking 60-90 percent ratings collapse over like the first 2 episodes. Spider man miles morales sold 70 percent less than the 2018 version. People like to virtue signal about how much they love certain races to earn social upcummies but this isn’t anything anybody is actually asking for and like the ones I mentioned will probably not get a second season.
 

j0hnnix

Member
chappelle show lol GIF


He's a tremendous actor but still, or more so why even contemplate this. That's like making Black Panther with John Cena.
 
Last edited:

Nester99

Member
Black lead watchman and bat girl shows completely bombed out. We’re talking 60-90 percent ratings collapse over like the first 2 episodes. Spider man miles morales sold 70 percent less than the 2018 version. People like to virtue signal about how much they love certain races to earn social upcummies but this isn’t anything anybody is actually asking for and like the ones I mentioned will probably not get a second season.

Free market is the invisible hand of god.
 

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
those gifs are so incredibly cringe only because snoy makes them themselves

Everytime I see them this meme pops up.
Screen_Shot_2017_07_13_at_1.09.20_PM.0.png


See we are cool we can rehash another meme but put our characters in it....look we are fun.
Forcing memes is the worst.....the Sony "remixes" basically made me hate the originals.
 

-tetsuo-

Unlimited Capacity
Nah. Too clearly European and somewhat.. too nice. Doesn't come across as Texan.

Not that this black guy would be any better. They need a legit angry Texan / southern American actor who can pull off the dark side of Joel.

Off the top of my head... maybe Ethan Hawke if he bulked up. He's Texan and old enough. Idk.

Because Troy Baker certinaly gives off that legit angry Texan vibe, doesn't he? Ali is a multi-oscar winning actor, I think he will be able to figure it out.
 

TintoConCasera

I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
Everytime I see them this meme pops up.
Screen_Shot_2017_07_13_at_1.09.20_PM.0.png


See we are cool we can rehash another meme but put our characters in it....look we are fun.
Forcing memes is the worst.....the Sony "remixes" basically made me hate the originals.
It's even worse when you consider that some animator had to crunch a little bit more in order to make them.
 

Corpsepyre

Banned
Black lead watchman and bat girl shows completely bombed out. We’re talking 60-90 percent ratings collapse over like the first 2 episodes. Spider man miles morales sold 70 percent less than the 2018 version. People like to virtue signal about how much they love certain races to earn social upcummies but this isn’t anything anybody is actually asking for and like the ones I mentioned will probably not get a second season.

Lol, now tell us what you really think.
 

kyliethicc

Member
Because Troy Baker certinaly gives off that legit angry Texan vibe, doesn't he? Ali is a multi-oscar winning actor, I think he will be able to figure it out.
Troy Baker is from Texas.

I was referring to Nikolaj Coster Waldau as coming across as too European. Danish people are not believably Texan lol.
 
Last edited:

EruditeHobo

Member
Omg, what the fuck is wrong with americans? Why would you change the characters physical description like that? Joel is not black, nor skinny. Why would you do this? These people are just fucking stupid. You arent correcting anything, Joel is supposed to be white just like ellie is supposed to be gay.

Those aren't equivalent at all. Ellie being gay is a huge story point in the series. Joel's ethnicity is not.
 

Jon Neu

Banned
Nah. Too clearly European and somewhat.. too nice. Doesn't come across as Texan.

Not that this black guy would be any better. They need a legit angry Texan / southern American actor who can pull off the dark side of Joel.

Off the top of my head... maybe Ethan Hawke if he bulked up. He's Texan and old enough. Idk.

You prefer fucking Ethan Hawke over Jaime Lannister?

nswgo.gif
 
Sure, he's a good actor. Let's hope he cares more about the character than naughtydog did.
Well, now they are in an awkward situation where they cannot kill him...

Honestly don't really mind the casting choice TOO much, cause I love Ali as an actor. It's just so hard to detach their probable reasoning from all of it, seems more provocateur than actual choice. But most likely this isn't even accurate, I don't really believe an Oscar winning actor would do this kind of show. But, we'll see I guess.
 

Corpsepyre

Banned
I love it, the sooner Naughty Dog goes the way of Bioware the better for all of us

Heh, why is it better for you, or anyone for that matter, that a world-class game developer, that has been churning quality for several years now, ends up failing?
 
Last edited:

Lupingosei

Banned
Heh, why is it better for you that a world-class game developer that has been churning quality for several years ends up failing?
Because they need to get hit into the face until they bleed money until they finally learn that the Twitter / Resetera crowd they admire does not buy their games.

Hollywood need to learn that too. I don't care how many studios go down until those morons finally learn who is buying their shit.
 
Last edited:

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
I always thought Josh Brolin would be the perfect casting for Joel. He's an excellent actor and pretty grizzled. If he bulks up a bit more I think he'd nail it.
Theres got to be some decent actors out there willing to do HBO shows who look like Joel. Hollywood A-list actors probably wont bother because they got films to do, but HBO shows skews to lesser name actors which are great and not even household names.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom