Game looked interesting.
Gameplay: Need to see more on level system before I make a judgement; it could be a new interesting addition. While I understand people's concern, I can't really see the game going the Division route; I don't think thats what they are going for. I hope/think it is going to be a more traditional. I'm thinking/hoping for GTA V style w/ co-op and a RPG-lite progression system.
Graphics/Art: Art direction looks pretty solid overall. Nothing will ever come close to TAS but the art deco look for Gotham was nice. Costumes were both hit and miss. Overall curious to see what this game looks like in a year's time.
Story: On one hand I am absolutely up to play as Batgirl, Robin, Red Hood, and Nightwing. On the other hand I was hoping for a slow burn Batman vs. Court of Owls detective story. Something like that could be really cool. Play up the mystery, add some spooky atmosphere, make it feel like you are always being stalked. Batman's enemies are scared of the dark corners of the city; turn it around and make the dark corners of the city scary for Batman. That being said, I fully expect Batman to show up for the last third of the game in some form of plot twist.
Overall, I am very interested. I want to see more of the gameplay/leveling system. Damien, Catwoman, Azrael, Cassandra Cain, and Huntress could all be unique and interesting DLC additions. Fully expecting we will be playing as Batman for the final third of the game. Very interested in seeing more.