TheDuskwalker
Member
Looking around on forums and stuff, instead of the biased critics like Polygon, I do hear the ending for this game is pretty shit even by Far Cry standards, which is really disappointing to hear.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Far Cry 5 Reviews
- Thread starter Northeastmonk
- Start date
Phoenix RISING
Banned
I'm unconcerned with "political angles," especially with video game review sites.
I hope to write for a publication like EDGE ONE day.I appreciate their high-brow style.
I would argue that there are to 99% no games journalists around since they are more like hobby blogger anyway so who cares?
Codes 208
Member
Ive been watching some of the Vanoss guys like Wildcat and h20Delirious play it and it looks chaotic as hell (in a good way)
As far as reviews go however, i personally prefer the individual reviewers like projared, angry joe and dunkey. These guys give off legitimate points to the pros and cons of games often times ive agreed with them.
Sites like ign however...well, think of it like a lottery in regards to who is doing what. Remember that time ryan (ign's biggest xbox fanboy) gave halo 4 a 9.8 calling it the best halo game ever? 'Cause i do.
As far as reviews go however, i personally prefer the individual reviewers like projared, angry joe and dunkey. These guys give off legitimate points to the pros and cons of games often times ive agreed with them.
Sites like ign however...well, think of it like a lottery in regards to who is doing what. Remember that time ryan (ign's biggest xbox fanboy) gave halo 4 a 9.8 calling it the best halo game ever? 'Cause i do.
Damerman
Member
Feel the same way. I respect what 3 and 4 did, moreso 4 than 3, but i did not find myself going back beyond the story. Farcry 2 is still my fave. This one looks promising tho.
LaughingStock
Member
So far it feels like your old far cry but more refined.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Polygon is having a hard time coming to terms with the political themes in this game, they docked the score on that basis. 6.5/10. Waypoint is bleating too. Nothing like journalists who never set foot in Montana being upset that their stereotyping of the state isn't portrayed.
Safe to write these clowns off in the review department.
Safe to write these clowns off in the review department.
Last edited:
MayauMiao
Member
All the complaint made by Kuchera just make me want to buy game more than ever just to spite him.
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
I think I'm most excited to see how the Arcade evolves. Could give the game some legs.
TheDuskwalker
Member
Barakov
Gold Member
Haha. That's great.What a burn.
Northeastmonk
Gold Member
I was trying to be honest when I made these reviews. I sought out Metacritic the moment the idea of creating the thread came to my mind. I thought I'd grab the reviews that felt legit. A lot of these scores might seem like they come from names you don't understand, but I've literally watched places like God of a Geek and Playstation Universe appear all over Metacritic. Obviously they're coming around as being legit. They also get review copies.
I'm glad that you guys or gals have added Polygon and IGN. I also went off the whole corrupt holy man mantra. I didn't do this because I absolutely hate bad reviews, but I didn't have a lot of time today. I wanted to make a thread about these scores.
Completely unrelated..
I dislike some of the views coming out about this game. It doesn't have to be a serious identity. I'm not wanting to relate to every moment of this game and that's because I want to blow shit up too. You can't go out in a real pickup truck and blow shit up. This video game makes it possible and it makes it fun. I'm sick of the Trump nation or whatever American Horror Story did with their last season. I want a doomsday cult type of game too.
I'm glad that you guys or gals have added Polygon and IGN. I also went off the whole corrupt holy man mantra. I didn't do this because I absolutely hate bad reviews, but I didn't have a lot of time today. I wanted to make a thread about these scores.
Completely unrelated..
I dislike some of the views coming out about this game. It doesn't have to be a serious identity. I'm not wanting to relate to every moment of this game and that's because I want to blow shit up too. You can't go out in a real pickup truck and blow shit up. This video game makes it possible and it makes it fun. I'm sick of the Trump nation or whatever American Horror Story did with their last season. I want a doomsday cult type of game too.
Last edited:
HagglesworthMD
Member
Whats' with Austin Walker’s review.. A large portion of it is talking about racism and Trump. It this what games “journalism” is all about these days? Trying to out PC other reviewers? A competition to see who can look down on their readership the most?
MayauMiao
Member
Waypoint as well as Polygon can't do review of games without inserting their own political agenda. Its pretty much why Waypoint & Polygon youtube channel sucks and don't get much views compared to a one man show like ACG, or newer channels like Laymen Gaming.
HagglesworthMD
Member
Agreed.
Political agenda is creeping into a lot of sites now. I’m a grown adult with a wife and kids, when I shop for games I want to know if they are fun enough to give me a few hours of entertainment each day, not if they go hard enough against Trump or not.
More and more I feel like gaming sites are insulting my intelligence by pedalling their political persuasions on their readers.
BionicRoo
Member
The amount of work that went into making it look that good, though, is incredible: https://news.microsoft.com/en-gb/20...looks-almost-as-good-as-a-film-on-xbox-one-x/
thelastword
Banned
I don't know why the tech sites don't use AIB Vega's for their tests as well......I know they're hard to come by, but surely not for them.....This sapphire Vega 64 beats the vega LC, so it would be good to see how a couple of AIB vega's stack........including the Strix and Powercolor Red Devil.....I think Sapphire has the best Vega card out though...
llien
Member
Polygon just got....
Is there some history to Gabe vs Polygon?
Shotgun Anaconda
Member
I don't care about politics or circlejerk websites, all i want to know is if the economy in the game is broken or not. SkillUp complained that constantly paying for ammo and the small size of looted money pushes you into the microtransactions, others have said it's not intrusive. Can someone here give me their honest opinion?
chilleverest
Member
How many hours are we looking into including sidequest ? Do you guys think its worth picking up on ps4?
ancelotti
Member
I'm only a few hours into the game but early impressions are very positive. Honestly, the story is serviceable enough to set up the action and justify the existence of the world of its characters. Sorry, it doesn't explicitly lay out the case against conservatives and evangelical Christians, but I suppose you have to leave something for the DLC (and I think the subtext is still pretty obvious). Anyways, I've laughed and shaken my head at all the dumb fun a few times, which is about what I want from a Far Cry experience. The world map is outstanding and upholds the high standard Ubisoft established this generation with WD2, Wildlands, and AC:O.
The gameplay is a huge step forward for the franchise. Although it isn't technically a reboot, they've nicely refined a lot of their mechanics and made dropping the mini-map and towers addition by subtraction. The surfacing of side content, main campaign missions, and random map discoveries all flow together really nicely. I've ran into a bit of open world jank with characters and animations, but nothing out of the ordinary for this kind of game. Despite not being super impressed with the weapons, the gunplay itself seems a little more responsive and satisfying at this stage.
Anyhow, we'll see how everything carries over into the mid and late game, as well as eventually the co-op, multiplayer and arcade modes. I'm really enjoying myself and the game is definitely a safe recommendation for any fan of the genre.
The gameplay is a huge step forward for the franchise. Although it isn't technically a reboot, they've nicely refined a lot of their mechanics and made dropping the mini-map and towers addition by subtraction. The surfacing of side content, main campaign missions, and random map discoveries all flow together really nicely. I've ran into a bit of open world jank with characters and animations, but nothing out of the ordinary for this kind of game. Despite not being super impressed with the weapons, the gunplay itself seems a little more responsive and satisfying at this stage.
Anyhow, we'll see how everything carries over into the mid and late game, as well as eventually the co-op, multiplayer and arcade modes. I'm really enjoying myself and the game is definitely a safe recommendation for any fan of the genre.
Dr. Claus
Vincit qui se vincit
I am confused, didn't these people hire Ben Kuchera to run their "Penny Arcade Report"? I would have assumed they were pro-Polygon.What a burn.
Dr. Claus
Vincit qui se vincit
Entirely enjoyable and playable without spending a dime or feeling the need to. The only time you are "pressured" to buy something is if you are either A.) Impatient and want that item right now or B.) Want to collect every single skin in the game (which I am unsure if that is possible at the current time with the amount of silver you can get).
Masatshi
Member
I played 21 hours so far and have one of three regions complete (not 100%, but 94%). So I would guess it's easily around 50 hours of fun or more if you do all sidequests, fishing, collecting, etc.... doing just the main-missions will be a lot faster, not more than 20 I suppose...
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
They actually are making a great point. A real good story would address those issues.
I think it's totally fine to expect more from a game that "ACTS" like it wants display a serious topic in America. They are asking the devs to grow up and hire an actual writer. Put your big kids pants on and make a point!
I know Austin isn't having an issue with Montana not being what he thinks it is. It clearly sounds like the game doesn't make ANY statements about anything at all! Like clearly the people that live there and are shown in the game have actual thoughts and beliefs. How about showing those beliefs in the game and not just have 10 lines and then forgetting everything else.
Last edited:
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Because it's far cry. The focus was never the story or characterization, why should that change? From what I gather the gameplay is better than ever, as is the environment. The story is up to far cry 3-4 standards. Also, no towers to climb.
The devs did go to Montana, and study locals mindset there, the towns, the history. It's reflected only in so far as to give the game a theme. Giving it a political stance is not the way you do entertainment. Alienating half your audience is not the way you do profit driven business.
These journalists are upset that the game isn't pushing an agenda that reflects their own. Well good. It shouldn't be pushing agendas. The setting is merely a vehicle for somewhat satirical mass entertainment, not for a political treatise on current affairs as they are perceived by one end of the political spectrum. Ubisoft Montreal wanted to make the game they wanted to make. So they made it. The end.
Last edited:
J Bro
Banned
No they didn't. Maybe you should stop reading fake news. :^)
Absolutely.
Shotgun Anaconda
Member
So you didnt feel like your money isnt enough to buy ammo, weapons and vehicle (not counting skins and with a normal amount of saving)?
Lionel Richie
Member
That shit isn't even journalism, it's just... I don't even know man, I'm just really grateful that I'm not their target audience.
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Because sometimes we would like for the content creators to "graduate" to the next level to make it a better overall game or movie (in this case game). Just because the characters might have had a different belief than me, doesn't mean it would alienate me or others that think like me. It'll be okay to treat the gamer as a grown up.
It's not about agendas at all. But if this is the game that they wanted to make fine! But it's okay for others to not like that and want more. It's cool.
Just because someone disagrees with you doesn't mean it's not journalism.
Last edited:
J Bro
Banned
Propaganda is "something more".
Dr. Claus
Vincit qui se vincit
Nope.
Chip Chipperson
Banned
If the game is this divisive and that racist Austin Walker as well as other known left leaning sites are up in arms because it’s not what they wanted, then I know I’m gonna enjoy the hell out of it.
Sorry it isn’t Kill Conservative Whitey Simulator 5000
Sorry it isn’t Kill Conservative Whitey Simulator 5000
Chip Chipperson
Banned
Well the ending to FC3 was dumb and I don’t even remember the endings to 4 or Primal so it’s not like they set the world on fire either.
Blood Dragon had the best with you riding that corny dragon with the cheesy 80s rocker blasting in the background.
Last edited:
Deuterium
Member
What exactly is "the case against conservatives and evangelical Christians"?
Wouldn't the following be more sensible: "...the case against violent political or religious extremism". I would include anti-religious extremism, within the former statement, as well..
Last edited:
Phoenix RISING
Banned