• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

HBO orders alternate universe Civil War drama [update: interview w/ producers]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alternative history is a fascinating and largely unexplored genre. If it's anything like Man in the High Castle, I'm in.

You really think they're going to portray slave owners in a positive light? This is going to be a 1984-esque / V for Vendetta dystopia.

What gives you and so many others that impression?
 
You really think they're going to portray slave owners in a positive light?

It doesn't matter if they portray them as POS, fans will make their own decisions on what is positive or not. That's why shit like this is taboo.

I personally believe they will just present them as is, with some nuance and leave it up to the audience to figure out who they root for.
 

ZOONAMI

Junior Member
Benioff and Weiss didn't make the white saviour issue, that was the author of the book.

Were the Valyrians ever described as white or just purple eyes and blonde hair?

Valerians are Roman, so not necessarily the whitest of skin tones but yeah still Caucasian.
 

SheSaidNo

Member
Half the writers announced in the press release are black and just looking at their twitter it doesn't seem they would be into the white savior narrative among other things.

Pe2CfWO.png
 
Alternative history is a fascinating and largely unexplored genre. If it's anything like Man in the High Castle, I'm in.

You really think they're going to portray slave owners in a positive light? This is going to be a 1984-esque / V for Vendetta dystopia.

I think they'll absolutely humanize slave owners in the name of "we need to how that these people did bad things but weren't monsters"
 

jerry113

Banned
What gives you and so many others that impression?

The synopsis says that the Union is alive and well in this fictional reality. They refer to abolitionists and freedom fighters and characters on "both sides of the demilitiarized zone" as being protagonists.

The south doesn't take over the union in this show. The country had just split in two.

The series takes place in an alternate timeline, where the southern states have successfully seceded from the Union, giving rise to a nation in which slavery remains legal and has evolved into a modern institution. The story follows a broad swath of characters on both sides of the Mason-Dixon Demilitarized Zone – freedom fighters, slave hunters, politicians, abolitionists, journalists, the executives of a slave-holding conglomerate and the families of people in their thrall."
 

Bronx-Man

Banned
The reaction online to this is literally the same reaction to Secret Empire. This is not a good time for alt-history.
I'm more interested in why all of sudden you have these "What if Nazis won?? What if Confederates won??" pieces of media going around right as actual goddamn nazis and confederates have taken us over.
 

Barzul

Member
The premise is kinda lazy too. Institutional slavery wouldn't have survived that long, even in the South. Now if it was about Jim Crow segregation still continuing, hellish but that would be more plausible. Who asked for this basically?
 
Alternative history is a fascinating and largely unexplored genre. If it's anything like Man in the High Castle, I'm in.

You really think they're going to portray slave owners in a positive light? This is going to be a 1984-esque / V for Vendetta dystopia.

Man in High Castle was a great premise RUINED by shit characters, awful pacing, and horrendous plot twists (when your most likeable, sympathetic character is the fucking Nazi you KNOW you fucked up bad).

Hopefully this series does a better job.
 
The synopsis says that the Union is alive and well in this fictional reality. They refer to abolitonists and freedom fighters and characters on "both sides of the demilitiarized zone" as being protagonists.

The south doesn't take over the union in this show. The country had just split in two.

Still don't see how that translates to dystopia, at least not on the Southern side.
 

Sunster

Member
The premise is kinda lazy too. Institutional slavery wouldn't have survived that long, even in the South. Now if it was about Jim Crow segregation still continuing, hellish but that would be more plausible. Who asked for this basically?

apparently their gonna "tackle shit that's gone unaddressed"
 
I'm somewhat interested and will withhold judgement until after watching it, however it's a shame they just didn't adapt Octavia Butler's novel Kindred for this and at least have a sci fi/time travel aspect to it.
 
They created a show where the only black people are slaves and pirates. I read the books, Martin didn't make every single person white.

Majority of the seven kingdoms was white, what are you on about? You have Dorne in the south, but the majority of 'brown' people we across the sea.

There just was not a lot of blacks in the books with large roles
 

Random Human

They were trying to grab your prize. They work for the mercenary. The masked man.
I'm more interested in why all of sudden you have these "What if Nazis won?? What if Confederates won??" pieces of media going around right as actual goddamn nazis and confederates have taken us over.

Nazism and racism has been effectively normalized, so you can use it as "cool" world building now.
 

adj_noun

Member
I'm more interested in why all of sudden you have these "What if Nazis won?? What if Confederates won??" pieces of media going around right as actual goddamn nazis and confederates have taken us over.

I think you hit on the reason in the latter part of your post. It's a reaction to what we're seeing happen.
 
The synopsis says that the Union is alive and well in this fictional reality. They refer to abolitionists and freedom fighters and characters on "both sides of the demilitiarized zone" as being protagonists.

The series takes place in an alternate timeline, where the southern states have successfully seceded from the Union, giving rise to a nation in which slavery remains legal and has evolved into a modern institution. The story follows a broad swath of characters on both sides of the Mason-Dixon Demilitarized Zone – freedom fighters, slave hunters, politicians, abolitionists, journalists, the executives of a slave-holding conglomerate and the families of people in their thrall.”

The south doesn't take over the union in this show. The country had just split in two.

How much you want to bet the "slave hunters" become fan favorites in many circles? Again, as a person whose family line was directly affected by that "institution" why again would I want to see a vision of what if people that look like me weren't freed?!?!
 
I'm more interested in why all of sudden you have these "What if Nazis won?? What if Confederates won??" pieces of media going around right as actual goddamn nazis and confederates have taken us over.
It's not all of a sudden. "Nazis won" alt-history has been around for decades, as have "Confederates won" stories. Man in the High Castle came out in 1962. The show came out in 2015

Also speculative fiction, and sci-fi in general, is often used as a reaction and reflection to the problems and concerns of the era they're released. Hence these stories coming out and getting adaptations now
I think you hit on the reason in the latter part of your post. It's a reaction to what we're seeing happen.
 

Sunster

Member
Majority of the seven kingdoms was white, what are you on about? You have Dorne in the south, but the majority of 'brown' people we across the sea.

There just was not a lot of blacks in the books with large roles

I am more referring to extras (something they had direct control of), not characters. In all the trading ports we see in the show, no black traders or merchants. Only slaves and pirates. It's not some huge issue, but it's a thing, a thing that leads me to believe the white savior will appear in this show.
 

Slayven

Member
How much you want to bet the "slave hunters" become fan favorites in many circles? Again, as a person whose family line was directly affected by that "institution" why again would I want to see a vision of what if people that look like me weren't freed?!?!

Concept art

ferguson-riot-protest-shooting-2.jpg
 

Mister Wolf

Member
How much you want to bet the "slave hunters" become fan favorites in many circles? Again, as a person whose family line was directly affected by that "institution" why again would I want to see a vision of what if people that look like me weren't freed?!?!

Don't be surprised if the "slave hunters" are black.
 

Dead Man

Member
In a show about black slaves owned by white people written by 2 white guys with a history of writing about white saviors saving black people I am pretty comfortable assuming that there will be a few in this show.



Really though this is the question. "Hey what if this oppressed and marginalized group was still in chains and considered subhuman property? Let's explore that!"

For those who do glorify the South it might be a bit of a wake up call as to what their victor would entail in the 21st century.
 
This could end up being a total trainwreck but I'm not gonna shit on it before seeing it. I'm at least interested to see how well these guys can build a world on their own (without source material that is).
 
It's not all of a sudden. "Nazis won" alt-history has been around for decades, as have "Confederates won" stories. Man in the High Castle came out in 1962. The show came out in 2015

Also speculative fiction, and sci-fi in general, is often used as a reaction and reflection to the problems and concerns of the era they're released. Hence these stories coming out and getting adaptations now

This. It's been explored from an academic standpoint as well, and not just of the white power persuasion. I have a very good book from 2000 that explores Hitler's tactical mistakes. One from 2003 that explores different scenarios in American history - John Tyler, Revolution of 1877, Whiskey Rebellion, JFK lives, no Pearl Harbor, etc.

For me I love the academia of it, having a premise and trying to see if it was plausible for it to happen. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.

I'm still on S1 of GoT, so all of the criticism there I'm not familiar with.
 

Dead Man

Member
It's not all of a sudden. "Nazis won" alt-history has been around for decades, as have "Confederates won" stories. Man in the High Castle came out in 1962. The show came out in 2015

Also speculative fiction, and sci-fi in general, is often used as a reaction and reflection to the problems and concerns of the era they're released. Hence these stories coming out and getting adaptations now

Indeed.
 
Just no. Fuck no. In an era where black actors are still struggling to get decent roles, I dont need to see anymore media with us portrayed as subservient and abused. There's enough of that shit going on in real life and Im tired of seeing it in film and television. Give me more shows like Blackish and Atlanta that put a primarily black cast in positive roles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom